On orthogonal tensors and best rank-one approximation ratio

Abstract

As is well known, the smallest possible ratio between the spectral norm and the Frobenius norm of an $m \times n$ matrix with $m \le n$ is $1/\sqrt{m}$ and is (up to scalar scaling) attained only by matrices having pairwise orthonormal rows. In the present paper, the smallest possible ratio between spectral and Frobenius norms of $n_1 \times \dots \times n_d$ tensors of order $d$, also called the best rank-one approximation ratio in the literature, is investigated. The exact value is not known for most configurations of $n_1 \le \dots \le n_d$. Using a natural definition of orthogonal tensors over the real field (resp., unitary tensors over the complex field), it is shown that the obvious lower bound $1/\sqrt{n_1 \cdots n_{d-1}}$ is attained if and only if a tensor is orthogonal (resp., unitary) up to scaling. Whether or not orthogonal or unitary tensors exist depends on the dimensions $n_1,\dots,n_d$ and the field. A connection between the (non)existence of real orthogonal tensors of order three and the classical Hurwitz problem on composition algebras can be established: existence of orthogonal tensors of size $\ell \times m \times n$ is equivalent to the admissibility of the triple $[\ell,m,n]$ to the Hurwitz problem. Some implications for higher-order tensors are then given. For instance, real orthogonal $n \times \dots \times n$ tensors of order $d \ge 3$ do exist, but only when $n = 1,2,4,8$. In the complex case, the situation is more drastic: unitary tensors of size $\ell \times m \times n$ with $\ell \le m \le n$ exist only when $\ell m \le n$. Finally, some numerical illustrations for spectral norm computation are presented