Using published Higgs search data we investigate whether any evidence
supports the possibility that the Higgs may be mixed with other neutral
scalars. We combine the positive evidence for the Higgs at 125.5 GeV with
search constraints at other masses to explore the viability of two simple
models. The first Higgs 'friend' model is simply a neutral scalar mixed with
the Higgs. In the second Higgs 'accomplice' model the new scalar has an
enhanced coupling to photons due to couplings to additional charged fields. We
find that the latter scenario allows improvement in fitting the data by
accommodating enhanced diphoton rates and suppression in other channels for a
Higgs mass of 125.5 GeV. Small excesses at other masses allow the additional
scalar to further improve the fit to the data, particularly if it has mass in
the vicinity of 210 GeV. Due to observed event rates at 125.5 GeV and strong
limits in high mass Higgs searches, mixing angles greater than pi/4 are
typically disfavored at the 95% confidence level, depending on the mass of the
scalar.Comment: 11 pages, 4 figures. v2 references added, Higgs data update