Role of physicians’ reactance in e-iatrogenesis: a case study with ASTI guiding mode on the management of hypertension

Abstract

Clinical decision support systems (CDSSs) have the potential to increase guideline adherence, but factors of success are not yet understood. ASTI guiding mode (ASTI-GM) is an on-demand guideline-based CDSS where the user navigates in a knowledge base to get the best treatment for a given patient. We conducted a web-based evaluation of ASTI-GM, carried out as a before-after study, where general practitioners (GPs) were asked to solve 5 clinical cases, first without ASTI-GM, then using the system. Of the 136 GPs that resolved the case on the management of hypertension, compliance with best practices increased from 69.1% to 80.9% with ASTI-GM. When the navigation matched the set of patient parameters described in the clinical case, the increase was even higher and reached 92.9%. E-iatrogenesis has been measured at 19.1%, with 5.1% of commission errors, 8.1% of negative reactance, and 5.9% of neutral reactance. Role of physicians’ reactance in noncompliance with guideline-based CDSSs should be further investigated