In 2009 an outbreak of the termite Coptotermes gestroi caused major damage to buildings and vegetation in Fiji. Termite control is most commonly performed using synthetic insecticides, although many botanically-derived toxins are also being evaluated. The woody legume, Abrus precatorius, contains the toxic protein abrin, and has been investigated previously for insecticidal properties. The current study used laboratory experiments to evaluate extracts of A. precatorius as potential control agents for C. gestroi. In Petri dish assays, exposure to water- and methanol-based extracts of leaf and seed material significantly increased mortality and shortened time to death of C. gestroi. The results suggest that extracts of A. precatorius have potential for use as control agents of C. gestroi and should be evaluated further to determine their mode of action and efficacy under field conditions

Brodie, Gilianne D.

Hodge, Simon

Prasad, Ravikash

Vanderwoude, C.

University of the South Pacific Electronic Research Repository

     The Weta 50:38-47                                                                                  38 Extracts of the rosary pea, Abrus precatorius, are toxic to the invasive termite, Coptotermes gestroi  Ravikash. R. Prasad* Faculty of Science, Environment and Technology, The University of the South Pacific, Suva, Fiji  Gilianne Brodie Faculty of Science, Environment and Technology, The University of the South Pacific, Suva, Fiji  Cas Vanderwoude Hawaii Ant Laboratory, University of Hawaii (Manoa), Hilo, Hawaii, USA  Simon Hodge Faculty of Science, Environment and Technology, The University of the South Pacific, Suva, Fiji, and Faculty of Agriculture and Life Sciences, Lincoln University, Christchurch, New Zealand * author for correspondence:  email: researchravi@yahoo.com  Abstract In 2009 an outbreak of the termite Coptotermes gestroi caused major damage to buildings and vegetation in Fiji.  Termite control is most commonly performed using synthetic insecticides, although many botanically-derived toxins are also being evaluated.  The woody legume, Abrus precatorius, contains the toxic protein abrin, and has been investigated previously for insecticidal properties.  The current study used laboratory experiments to evaluate extracts of A. precatorius as potential control agents for C. gestroi.  In Petri dish assays, exposure to water- and methanol-based extracts of leaf and seed material significantly increased mortality and shortened time to death of C. gestroi.  The results suggest that extracts of A. precatorius have potential for use as control agents of C. gestroi and should be evaluated further to determine their mode of action and efficacy under field conditions.      39     Ravikash Prasad et al.  Introduction In 2009 an outbreak of the Asian subterranean termite, Coptotermes gestroi (Wasmann 1896) (Isoptera: Rhinotermitidae), occurred in the Lautoka district of Viti Levu in Fiji causing major damage to homes, schools and vegetation.  According to the Biosecurity Authority of Fiji (pers. comm.) the Fijian government spent more than FJ$3 million between 2009 and 2011 on the problem of C. gestroi infestation, which involved application of chemical treatments, repair of damaged structures and education of local residents.  Control of C. gestroi in the Lautoka area was primarily based on the commercially-available product ‘Termidor’ (which contains the active ingredient fipronil) imported from Australia, with prices to treat a typical Fijian house ranging between FJ$170 to FJ$250.  The Fiji Government indicated that new termite infestations would only be treated on a ‘user pays’ basis, and home owners that could not afford to pay for the chemical treatments would also be liable to pay for their own house repairs, estimated in the region of FJ$8000, close to the estimated per capita gross national income of FJ$8300 in 2011 (Burese, 2011; Malo, 2011; UNdata Fiji, 2013).   Coptotermes gestroi originates from South East Asia and is considered one of the most destructive, economically important, termite species worldwide. Control of C. gestroi is still commonly performed using synthetic insecticides, such as bistrifluron, hexaflumuron and imidacloprid (Lee et al.,2004; 2009; Hafiz and Hassan, 2008).  However, although these insecticides can be highly effective, the adverse effects of these chemicals on the wider environment and human health are of increasing concern and so alternative termite control methods continue to be investigated (Verma et al., 2009).  A number of natural products and plant extracts have been screened for inhibitory activities against invasive or pest social insects such as ants, wasps and termites, with a view to controlling these species in a more ‘environmentally friendly’ manner.  For example, extracts of boxthorn (Lycium shawii) and cassava (Manihot esculenta) have recently been shown to have strong toxic effects against samsam and leaf cutter ants respectively (de Cavalho Alves et al., 2013; Mashaly et al., 2014), whereas the argentine ant, now a major invasive species in New Zealand, was repelled from herbage treated with by essential oils of wintergreen, cinnamon, cloves, peppermint and (especially) spearmint (Scocco et al., 2012).  With regard to      The Weta 50:38-47                                                                                  40 termiticides, extracts from white cedar Melia azedarach, aroeira Myracrodruon urundeuva, teak Tectona grandis, stilt-mangrove Rhizophora apiculata and the ‘suicide tree’ Cerbera odollum have all been shown to have toxic effects against C. gestroi (Hashim et al., 2009; Khalil et al., 2009; Nascimento et al. 2009).    The leguminous plant Abrus precatorius L. (Fabaceae) (‘rosary pea’, ‘jequirity’) is a high-climbing or trailing woody vine that grows in tropical climates (Anand et al., 2010).  The plant is native (or an ancient introduction) to Fiji but, because of its tendency to smother or over-grow other native vegetation, is often considered as invasive or a nuisance weed.  Abrus precatorius has numerous and wide-ranging bioactive properties and the insecticidal effects of this species have been investigated for over a hundred years (e.g. Stillmark, 1888; Bhatia et al., 2013).  The aim of this study was to use laboratory assays to evaluate water- and methanol-based seed and leaf extracts of A. precatorius for toxicity towards C. gestroi by measuring both final mortality and time to death.  Materials and Methods Termites were collected from trees and posts in Tavakubu and Central College School, Lautoka, and housed in glass tanks (90% relative humidity; 28ºC) with wood fragments until used in assays. Abrus precatorius leaves and seeds were collected from Malomalo Village and the leaves and seeds washed, frozen for 3 days, freeze dried for 3 days and then ground to a fine powder using an electric grinder.  Methanol extracts were prepared by mixing 500g of leaf or seed powder with 1 L of methanol (99%) in a conical flask, shaking for 48 hours on an electric shaker and then repeatedly filtering until clear.  The filtrate was dried using a rotary evaporator at 60˚C and a stock solution prepared by re-dissolving 10 g of the dried extract in 20 ml of methanol to obtain a 50% w/v solution, which was in turn serially diluted to give desired concentrations for bioassays (10% and 1% w/v).  Water extracts were made by direct mixing of A. precatorius leaf or seed powder in distilled water at the required concentrations (10% and 1% w/v).  The mixtures were placed on a shaker for 48 h and then filtered.  All solutions were stored at 4oC until used.  Toxicity assays were performed using glass Petri dishes (9 cm diameter) as the experimental arenas.  Filter papers were dampened  41     Ravikash Prasad et al.  with 2 ml of solution and excess fluid allowed to evaporate. There were three replicate Petri dishes for all test solutions.  Distilled water or methanol (99%) were used as appropriate control treatments.  Twenty five termites were added to each of the Petri dishes, and daily mortality of C. gestroi recorded in each dish for 10 days, with dead individuals being removed each day to prevent contamination.  The Petri dishes were maintained in a hygrostatic tank at 28ºC and 90±10% RH and the high humidity ensured the filter papers remained moist throughout the 10 d trial.     The  mean  time  of  death  (MTD; d)  for  termites  in  each  Petri  dish was calculated by:                where di = the ith day since the assay started and Di = number of termites which were recorded newly dead on di.  Results There was a strong correlation between MTD and concentration for both the water and methanol extracts (Figure 1: rs > |0.75|; P < 0. 0.005 for all extracts).  Death was most rapid when termites were exposed to methanol extracts compared to water extracts (cf. Figure 1a & 1b), although mortality had still reached 100% in both of the 10% extracts by Day 10 (Table 1).   Termite mortality exhibited a clear positive relationship with extract concentration for all four types of extract after 1 d and 2 d exposure (Table 1).  Mortality was more rapid when exposed to the methanol extracts compared to the water extract of comparable concentrations.  For the highest (50%) concentration of methanol extracts, all termites were dead after 1 d exposure to the seed extract and after 2 d exposure to the 50% leaf extract.   There was no control mortality in the water and methanol extracts after 1 d and 2 d (Table 1).  However mortality of termites in the control methanol treatment was high after 10 d (83%), suggesting exposure to methanol residues was having some chronic inhibitory effects   Discussion The results indicate that exposure to leaf and seed extracts of A. precatorius can cause mortality and shorten time to death in the termite C. gestroi.  Previously, Setiawan et al. (2009) reported that methanol      The Weta 50:38-47                                                                                  42 extracts of leaves and seeds of A. precatorius could produce 100% mortality of C. gestroi in 12 days using a ‘force-feeding’ method.  Our study has reconfirmed the toxicity A. precatorius extracts against C. gestroi, and extended these results by demonstrating that water-based extracts are also toxic, and that mortality can be caused by contact with A. precatorius extracts or residues as well as by ingestion.    Bait toxicant systems, where active ingredients are incorporated into food baits which are then carried into the termite colony by foraging workers, can substantially reduce pesticide use (Su & Scheffrhan, 1998).  In these bait systems, a slow mode of action is important as sufficient time is required for foraging termites to contact the toxin and then return to the colony.  This type of action was apparent for some A. precatorius extracts: for example the 10% leaf extracts acted fairly slowly (MTD ≈ 4-6 d) but still caused 100% mortality after 10 days.  A further desirable property of the A. precatorius extracts was that there were no obvious repellent effects towards C. gestroi and this may have prevented lethal doses being received.   Hoddle (2004) suggested there is scope to control invasive species in a sustainable fashion if one problem species is utilized in some manner that helps to control another.  Many other important insect pests of South Pacific islands (e.g. mosquitoes and aphids) have also been shown to be susceptible to A. precatorius extracts.  Thus the development of viable and effective insecticides from this plant may offer multiple advantages in a South Pacific setting, in terms of reduced synthetic pesticide use, more environmentally sound pest control, management of a problem weed, and, ultimately, some economic benefit to the local communities involved.     This study provides preliminary data describing the strong negative effects of A. precatorius on C. gestroi.  However we have not as yet identified the active ingredient(s) and their concentrations in the extracts, and so could not estimate the actual doses of chemicals the termites received.  Further investigation of A. precatorius extracts is required to ascertain their mode of action and their effectiveness when applied to natural substrates (e.g. soil; foliage; timber) or incorporated into bait toxicant formulations in a field setting.   43     Ravikash Prasad et al.  Acknowledgements We wish to thank Lautoka Central College for allowing us to use their laboratories for experiments and officers of The Biosecurity Authority of Fiji for helping locate and collect termites. This research was funded by the University of the South Pacific.  References Anand AR, Kishor OV, Rajkumar SV, Chandrashekhar U D & Tanaj ND. 2010: Abrus precatorius Linnaeus: A phytopharmological review. Journal of Pharmacy Research, 3: 2585-2587.  Bhatia M, Siddiqui NA & Gupta S. 2013: Abrus precatorius (L.): an evaluation of traditional herb. Indo American Journal of Pharmacy Research, 3: 3295-3315.   Burese I. 2011: Chemical boost for eradication. In: The Fiji Times, 1/3/11,  Fiji Times Limited, Suva. http://www.fijitimes.com/story.aspx?id=167218  Hafiz AMA, Hassan AA. 2008: Preliminary field efficacy of transfer effect of slow acting termiticide (imidacloprid) on subterranean termites population (Coptotermes gestroi) (Wasmann) (Isoptera: Rhinotermitidae). Journal of Biosciences, 19: 101-106.  Hashim R, Boon JG, Sulaiman O, Kawamura F, Lee CY. 2009: Evaluation of the decay resistance properties of Cerbera odollam extracts and their influence on properties of particleboard. International journal Biodeterioration and Biodegradation, 63: 1013–1017.  Hoddle MS. 2004: Restoring balance: Using exotic species to control invasive exotic species. Conservation Biology, 18: 38-49.  Khalil HPSA, Kong NH, Ahmad MN, Bhat AH, Jawaid M, Jumat S. 2009: Selective solvent extraction of the bark of Rhizophora apiculata as an anti-termite agent against Coptotermes gestroi.  Journal of Wood Chemistry and Technology, 29: 286-304.       The Weta 50:38-47                                                                                  44 Lee LC, Lee CY, Vongkaluang C, Jaafar MA, Pornkulwat S, Ouimette DG, Tolley M. & Borthe P. 2004 Field efficacy of Recruit® III termite bait (0.5% noviflumuron) against Coptotermes gestroi (Isoptera : Rhinotermitidae) in Southeast Asia. Presented at the 2004 Annual Meeting and Exhibition.of the  Entomological Society of America.  Malo M. 2011: Termite user-pay system costly. In: The Fiji Times, 6/1/11. Fiji Times Ltd., Suva.  http://www.fijitimes.com/story.aspx?id=163401.  Mashaly AMA, Farooq M, Hozzein W, Al-Qahtani AM, Al-Mekhlafi FA. 2014: Assessment of toxic baits for the control of the samsum ant, Pachycondyla sennaarensis (Formicidae: Ponerinae).  African Entomology, 22: 204-209.   Nascimento SM, Franca TML, Ballesteiro PM, Barsanulfo ME. (2009): Potential insecticidal effects of aqueous tree leaf extracts against the subterranean termite Coptotermes gestroi (Isoptera: Rhinotermitidae).  Sociobiology, 53: 719-728.  Sajap AS, Lee LC, Shah ZM. 2009: Elimination of subterranean termite colonies with hexaflumuron in an improved bait matrix, preferred textured cellulose (PTC).  Sociobiology, 53: 891-901.   Santos MAI, Correa AD, Alves APD, Simao AA, Alves DS, de Olivereira RL, Saczk AA, Carvalho GA. 2013: Cassava leaf methanolic extracts an an alternative to control of fall armyworm and leaf cutter ants. Semina: Ciênces Agrárias, 34: 3501-3511.  Setiawan KH, Tarmadi D, Prianto AH, Yusuf S. 2009: Termicidal activities of Abrus precatorius L. leaves extract against subterranean termite Coptotermes gestroi. In: W. Diwanto and A. Kusumaningtyas (eds.) Proceedings of The First International Symposium of Indonesian Wood Research Society, Indonesia Wood Research Society, Indonesia.   45     Ravikash Prasad et al.  Scocco CM, Suiter DR, Gardner WA. 2012: Repellency of five essential oils to Linepithema humile (Hymenoptera: Formicidae). Journal of Entomological Science, 47: 150-159.  Stillmark H. 1888: About ricin, a toxic enzyme from the seeds of Ricinus communis L. and some other Euphorbiaceae.  Arbeiten aus dem Pharmakologischen Institut Dorpat, 3: 59-151.  Su NY, Scheffrhan RH. 1998: A review of subterranean termite control practices and prospects for integrated pest management programmes.  Integrated Pest Management. Reviews, 3: 1-13.  UNdata 2013: Fiji Islands. data.un.org/CountryProfile.aspx?crName=FIJI. Accessed 19/12/2013.  Verma M, Sharma S, Prasad R. 2009: Biological alternatives for termite control: A review.  International Biodeterioration and  Biodegradation, 63: 959-972.       The Weta 50:38-47                                                                                  46    Figure 1.  Mean time to death (MTD; days; mean ± SE; N = 3) of 25 Coptotermes gestroi exposed to filter papers treated with (a) methanol and (b) water extracts of Abrus precatorius leaves and seeds. The doses given are relative concentrations (%) of original leaf and seed extracts (see Methods for details).     0123456789100 1 10 50MTD (d)Concentration (%) Leaf Seeda) MeOH extracts0123456789100 1 10MTD (d)Concentration (%) Leaf Seedb) H2O extracts 47     Ravikash Prasad et al.       Concentration   Solvent Tissue Time 0% 1% 10% 50% rS P Methanol Leaf 1 d 0 1.3 20.0 74.7 0.931 < 0.001   2 d 0 8.0 45.3 100 0.987 < 0.001   10 d 82.7 100 100 100 0.598 0.011           Seed 1 d 0 10.7 41.3 100 0.986 < 0.001   2 d 0 28.0 81.3 100 0.941 < 0.001   10 d 82.7 100 100 100 0.598 0.011          Water Leaf 1 d 0 6.7 12.0 - 0.892 < 0.001   2 d 0 6.7 16.0 - 0.946 < 0.001   10 d 26.7 52.0 100 - 0.834 0.002           Seed 1 d 0 6.7 10.7 - 0.897 < 0.001   2 d 0 10.7 24.0 - 0.942 < 0.001   10 d 26.7 100 100 - 0.845 0.002   Table 1.  Mortality (%; mean; N = 3) of 25 Coptotermes gestroi after 1, 2 and 10 days exposure to methanol and water extracts of Abrus precatorius leaves and seeds in Petri dish toxicity assays.  The doses given are relative concentrations (%) of original leaf and seed extracts (see Methods for details).  (rS - Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient).

Extracts of the rosary pea, Abrus precatorius, are toxic to the invasive termite, Coptotermes gestroi

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

University of the South Pacific Electronic Research Repository