A cost-effectiveness study by Sue Goldie and colleagues finds that better family planning, provision of safe abortion, and improved intrapartum and emergency obstetrical care could reduce maternal mortality in India by 75% in 5 years

A Costello

A Rosenfield

AB Biswas

AM Gulmezoglu

B Ekman

B Johns

B McPake

BJ Brabin

C AbouZahr

C Crowther

C Dolea

C Pagel

C Ronsmans

CJL Murray

D Hu

DA Grimes

Delphine Hu

DV Mavalankar

E Ahman

E Lule

F Terris-Prestholt

GJ Hofmeyr

H Katrak

I Shah

J Borghi

J Menken

J Shiffman

K Hill

K Iyengar

KS Khan

KS Vora

L Brenzel

L Cahuana-Hurtado

L Duley

LM French

LM Koonin

M Berer

M Prakasamma

N Nakhaee

N Prata

N Schuitemaker

Natalie Carvalho

OM Campbell

P Padmanaban

R Bhat

R Duggal

R Laxminarayan

R Levine

RA Bang

RB Johanson

S Harlap

S Ma

S Mills

S Singh

S Thaddeus

SD Iyengar

SJ Goldie

SK Henshaw

Steve Sweet

Sue J. Goldie

T Adam

T Sutherland

Uma Chandra Mouli Natchu

V Filippi

WJ Graham

Zulfiqar A. Bhutta

PLoS Medicine

English

PubMed

Crossref

Alternative Strategies to Reduce Maternal Mortality in India: A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis

BackgroundApproximately one-quarter of all pregnancy- and delivery-related maternal deaths worldwide occur in India. Taking into account the costs, feasibility, and operational complexity of alternative interventions, we estimate the clinical and population-level benefits associated with strategies to improve the safety of pregnancy and childbirth in India.Methods and findingsCountry- and region-specific data were synthesized using a computer-based model that simulates the natural history of pregnancy (both planned and unintended) and pregnancy- and childbirth-associated complications in individual women; and considers delivery location, attendant, and facility level. Model outcomes included clinical events, population measures, costs, and cost-effectiveness ratios. Separate models were adapted to urban and rural India using survey-based data (e.g., unmet need for birth spacing/limiting, facility births, skilled birth attendants). Model validation compared projected maternal indicators with empiric data. Strategies consisted of improving coverage of effective interventions that could be provided individually or packaged as integrated services, could reduce the incidence of a complication or its case fatality rate, and could include improved logistics such as reliable transport to an appropriate referral facility as well as recognition of referral need and quality of care. Increasing family planning was the most effective individual intervention to reduce pregnancy-related mortality. If over the next 5 y the unmet need for spacing and limiting births was met, more than 150,000 maternal deaths would be prevented; more than US$1 billion saved; and at least one of every two abortion-related deaths averted. Still, reductions in maternal mortality reached a threshold ( approximately 23%-35%) without including strategies that ensured reliable access to intrapartum and emergency obstetrical care (EmOC). An integrated and stepwise approach was identified that would ultimately prevent four of five maternal deaths; this approach coupled stepwise improvements in family planning and safe abortion with consecutively implemented strategies that incrementally increased skilled attendants, improved antenatal/postpartum care, shifted births away from home, and improved recognition of referral need, transport, and availability/quality of EmOC. The strategies in this approach ranged from being cost-saving to having incremental cost-effectiveness ratios less than US$500 per year of life saved (YLS), well below India's per capita gross domestic product (GDP), a common benchmark for cost-effectiveness.ConclusionsEarly intensive efforts to improve family planning and control of fertility choices and to provide safe abortion, accompanied by a paced systematic and stepwise effort to scale up capacity for integrated maternal health services over several years, is as cost-effective as childhood immunization or treatment of malaria, tuberculosis, or HIV. In just 5 y, more than 150,000 maternal deaths would be averted through increasing contraception rates to meet women's needs for spacing and limiting births; nearly US$1.5 billion would be saved by coupling safe abortion to aggressive family planning efforts; and with stepwise investments to improve access to pregnancy-related health services and to high-quality facility-based intrapartum care, more than 75% of maternal deaths could be prevented. If accomplished over the next decade, the lives of more than one million women would be saved

Sue J Goldie

Directory of Open Access Journals

Alternative strategies to reduce maternal mortality in India: a cost-effectiveness analysis.

Approximately one-quarter of all pregnancy- and delivery-related maternal deaths worldwide occur in India. Taking into account the costs, feasibility, and operational complexity of alternative interventions, we estimate the clinical and population-level benefits associated with strategies to improve the safety of pregnancy and childbirth in India.Country- and region-specific data were synthesized using a computer-based model that simulates the natural history of pregnancy (both planned and unintended) and pregnancy- and childbirth-associated complications in individual women; and considers delivery location, attendant, and facility level. Model outcomes included clinical events, population measures, costs, and cost-effectiveness ratios. Separate models were adapted to urban and rural India using survey-based data (e.g., unmet need for birth spacing/limiting, facility births, skilled birth attendants). Model validation compared projected maternal indicators with empiric data. Strategies consisted of improving coverage of effective interventions that could be provided individually or packaged as integrated services, could reduce the incidence of a complication or its case fatality rate, and could include improved logistics such as reliable transport to an appropriate referral facility as well as recognition of referral need and quality of care. Increasing family planning was the most effective individual intervention to reduce pregnancy-related mortality. If over the next 5 y the unmet need for spacing and limiting births was met, more than 150,000 maternal deaths would be prevented; more than US$1 billion saved; and at least one of every two abortion-related deaths averted. Still, reductions in maternal mortality reached a threshold (∼23%–35%) without including strategies that ensured reliable access to intrapartum and emergency obstetrical care (EmOC). An integrated and stepwise approach was identified that would ultimately prevent four of five maternal deaths; this approach coupled stepwise improvements in family planning and safe abortion with consecutively implemented strategies that incrementally increased skilled attendants, improved antenatal/postpartum care, shifted births away from home, and improved recognition of referral need, transport, and availability/quality of EmOC. The strategies in this approach ranged from being cost-saving to having incremental cost-effectiveness ratios less than US$500 per year of life saved (YLS), well below India's per capita gross domestic product (GDP), a common benchmark for cost-effectiveness.Early intensive efforts to improve family planning and control of fertility choices and to provide safe abortion, accompanied by a paced systematic and stepwise effort to scale up capacity for integrated maternal health services over several years, is as cost-effective as childhood immunization or treatment of malaria, tuberculosis, or HIV. In just 5 y, more than 150,000 maternal deaths would be averted through increasing contraception rates to meet women's needs for spacing and limiting births; nearly US$1.5 billion would be saved by coupling safe abortion to aggressive family planning efforts; and with stepwise investments to improve access to pregnancy-related health services and to high-quality facility-based intrapartum care, more than 75% of maternal deaths could be prevented. If accomplished over the next decade, the lives of more than one million women would be saved.Please see later in the article for the Editors' Summar

Goldie Sue J.

Sweet Steve

Carvalho Natalie

Natchu Uma Chandra Mouli

Hu Delphine

Public Library of Science (PLOS)

BACKGROUND: Approximately one-quarter of all pregnancy- and delivery-related maternal deaths worldwide occur in India. Taking into account the costs, feasibility, and operational complexity of alternative interventions, we estimate the clinical and population-level benefits associated with strategies to improve the safety of pregnancy and childbirth in India. METHODS AND FINDINGS: Country- and region-specific data were synthesized using a computer-based model that simulates the natural history of pregnancy (both planned and unintended) and pregnancy- and childbirth-associated complications in individual women; and considers delivery location, attendant, and facility level. Model outcomes included clinical events, population measures, costs, and cost-effectiveness ratios. Separate models were adapted to urban and rural India using survey-based data (e.g., unmet need for birth spacing/limiting, facility births, skilled birth attendants). Model validation compared projected maternal indicators with empiric data. Strategies consisted of improving coverage of effective interventions that could be provided individually or packaged as integrated services, could reduce the incidence of a complication or its case fatality rate, and could include improved logistics such as reliable transport to an appropriate referral facility as well as recognition of referral need and quality of care. Increasing family planning was the most effective individual intervention to reduce pregnancy-related mortality. If over the next 5 y the unmet need for spacing and limiting births was met, more than 150,000 maternal deaths would be prevented; more than US$1 billion saved; and at least one of every two abortion-related deaths averted. Still, reductions in maternal mortality reached a threshold ( approximately 23%-35%) without including strategies that ensured reliable access to intrapartum and emergency obstetrical care (EmOC). An integrated and stepwise approach was identified that would ultimately prevent four of five maternal deaths; this approach coupled stepwise improvements in family planning and safe abortion with consecutively implemented strategies that incrementally increased skilled attendants, improved antenatal/postpartum care, shifted births away from home, and improved recognition of referral need, transport, and availability/quality of EmOC. The strategies in this approach ranged from being cost-saving to having incremental cost-effectiveness ratios less than US$500 per year of life saved (YLS), well below India's per capita gross domestic product (GDP), a common benchmark for cost-effectiveness. CONCLUSIONS: Early intensive efforts to improve family planning and control of fertility choices and to provide safe abortion, accompanied by a paced systematic and stepwise effort to scale up capacity for integrated maternal health services over several years, is as cost-effective as childhood immunization or treatment of malaria, tuberculosis, or HIV. In just 5 y, more than 150,000 maternal deaths would be averted through increasing contraception rates to meet women's needs for spacing and limiting births; nearly US$1.5 billion would be saved by coupling safe abortion to aggressive family planning efforts; and with stepwise investments to improve access to pregnancy-related health services and to high-quality facility-based intrapartum care, more than 75% of maternal deaths could be prevented. If accomplished over the next decade, the lives of more than one million women would be saved

Goldie, SJ

Sweet, S

Carvalho, N

Natchu, UCM

Hu, D

University of Melbourne Institutional Repository

Alternative strategies to reduce maternal mortality in India: A cost-effectiveness analysis

Background: Approximately one-quarter of all pregnancy- and delivery-related maternal deaths worldwide occur in India. Taking into account the costs, feasibility, and operational complexity of alternative interventions, we estimate the clinical and population-level benefits associated with strategies to improve the safety of pregnancy and childbirth in India. Methods and Findings: Country- and region-specific data were synthesized using a computer-based model that simulates the natural history of pregnancy (both planned and unintended) and pregnancy- and childbirth-associated complications in individual women; and considers delivery location, attendant, and facility level. Model outcomes included clinical events, population measures, costs, and cost-effectiveness ratios. Separate models were adapted to urban and rural India using survey-based data (e.g., unmet need for birth spacing/limiting, facility births, skilled birth attendants). Model validation compared projected maternal indicators with empiric data. Strategies consisted of improving coverage of effective interventions that could be provided individually or packaged as integrated services, could reduce the incidence of a complication or its case fatality rate, and could include improved logistics such as reliable transport to an appropriate referral facility as well as recognition of referral need and quality of care. Increasing family planning was the most effective individual intervention to reduce pregnancy-related mortality. If over the next 5 y the unmet need for spacing and limiting births was met, more than 150,000 maternal deaths would be prevented; more than US$1 billion saved; and at least one of every two abortion-related deaths averted. Still, reductions in maternal mortality reached a threshold (~23%–35%) without including strategies that ensured reliable access to intrapartum and emergency obstetrical care (EmOC). An integrated and stepwise approach was identified that would ultimately prevent four of five maternal deaths; this approach coupled stepwise improvements in family planning and safe abortion with consecutively implemented strategies that incrementally increased skilled attendants, improved antenatal/postpartum care, shifted births away from home, and improved recognition of referral need, transport, and availability/quality of EmOC. The strategies in this approach ranged from being cost-saving to having incremental cost-effectiveness ratios less than US$500 per year of life saved (YLS), well below India’s per capita gross domestic product (GDP), a common benchmark for cost-effectiveness. Conclusions: Early intensive efforts to improve family planning and control of fertility choices and to provide safe abortion, accompanied by a paced systematic and stepwise effort to scale up capacity for integrated maternal health services over several years, is as cost-effective as childhood immunization or treatment of malaria, tuberculosis, or HIV. In just 5 y, more than 150,000 maternal deaths would be averted through increasing contraception rates to meet women’s needs for spacing and limiting births; nearly US$1.5 billion would be saved by coupling safe abortion to aggressive family planning efforts; and with stepwise investments to improve access to pregnancy-related health services and to high-quality facility-based intrapartum care, more than 75% of maternal deaths could be prevented. If accomplished over the next decade, the lives of more than one million women would be saved.Version of Recor

Goldie, Sue

Sweet, Steven

Carvalho, Natalie Ida

Natchu, Uma Chandra Mouli

Hu, Delphine

Harvard University - DASH

Ahman E

AMDD Working Group on Indicators

An alternative strategy to reduce maternal mortality.

An analysis of anemia and pregnancyrelated maternal mortality.

Antibiotic regimens for endometritis after delivery.

Assessing the cost-effectiveness of contraceptive methods in Shiraz, Islamic Republic of Iran.

Availability and use of emergency obstetric care services in four districts of West Bengal,

Bulletin on rural health statistics in India.

Chapter 26: Maternal and perinatal conditions.

Chapter 3: Reproductive health.

Comparison of domiciliary and institutional delivery-care practices in Rural Rajasthan,

Contraception. Disease control priorities in developing countries. 2nd edition.

Cost-effectiveness of misoprostol and prenatal iron supplementation as maternal mortality interventions in home births in rural India.

Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division

Disease control priorities in developing countries. 2nd edition. Washington (D.C.): The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/The World Bank. Available: http://www.dcp2.org.

Division. Available: http://www.supply.unicef.dk/catalogue/.

Do women with pre-eclampsia and their babies benefit from magnesium sulphate? The Magpie Trial: a randomised placebo controlled trial.

Estimated global resources needed to attain universal coverage of maternal and newborn health services.

Estimates of maternal mortality worldwide between

Estimating causes of death: new methods and global and regional applications for 1990. Murray CJL,

Estimation of potential effects of improved community-based drug provision, to augment health-facility strengthening, on maternal mortality due to postpartum haemorrhage and sepsis in sub-Saharan Africa: an equity-effectiveness model.

External cephalic version for breech presentation at term.

Fertility regulation behaviors and their costs: contraception and unintended pregnancies

for Population Sciences (IIPS)

for Population Sciences (IIPS) and ORC Macro

Generating political priority for maternal mortality reduction in 5 developing countries.

Generation of political priority for global health initiatives: a framework and case study of maternal mortality.

Global burden of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy in the year 2000. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization. Available: http://www.who.int/healthinfo/statistics/bod_ hypertensivedisordersofpregnancy.pdf.

Global burden of maternal hemorrhage in the year 2000. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization. Available: http://www.who.int/healthinfo/statistics/bod_maternalhaemorrhage.pdf.

Global burden of maternal sepsis in the year 2000. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization.

Health dimensions of sex and reproduction. Cambridge: Harvard School of Public Health.

Hospital admissions resulting from unsafe abortion: estimates from 13 developing countries.

Improving maternal survival in South Asiawhat can we learn from case studies?

India’s transport sector: the challenges ahead. Vol 1. Washington (D.C.): World Bank Group. Available: http://www-wds.

Innovations and challenges in reducing maternal mortality in Tamil Nadu,

Integrating health interventions for women, newborn babies, and children: a framework for action.

Intervention cost– effectiveness: overview of main messages. Disease control priorities in developing countries. 2nd edition.

Is antenatal syphilis screening still cost effective in sub-Saharan Africa.

Lancet Maternal Survival Series steering group (2006) Strategies for reducing maternal mortality: getting on with what works.

Legalized abortion and the public health; report of a study by a committee of the Institute of Medicine. Washington (D.C.): National Academy of Sciences.

Macroeconomics and health: investing in health for economic development: report of the Commission on Macroeconomics and Health. Geneva: World Health Organization.

Magnesium sulphate and other anticonvulsants for women with eclampsia.

Magnesium sulphate for preventing preterm birth in threatened preterm labour. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 4:

Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana

Maternal health in Gujarat, India: a case study.

Maternal health in poor countries: the broader context and a call for action.

Maternal health situation in India: a case study.

Maternal health: a case study of Rajasthan.

Maternal healthcare financing: Gujarat’s Chiranjeevi Scheme and its beneficiaries.

Maternal morbidity during labour and the puerperium in rural homes and the need for medical attention: A prospective observational study in Gadchiroli, India.

Maternal mortality after cesarean section in The Netherlands.

Maternal mortality declining in middleincome countries; women still die in pregnancy and childbirth in low-income countries.

Maternal mortality in India: 1997–2003; trends, causes and risk factors.

Maternal mortality-reduction programme in Andhra Pradesh.

Measuring the shortage of medical practitioners in rural and urban areas in developing countries: a simple framework and simulation exercise with data from India.

Meeting MDG-5: an impossible dream?

Misoprostol for the prevention and treatment of pospartum hemorrhage.

National laws and unsafe abortion: the parameters of change.

National Rural Health Mission (2005–2012) Mission document. Available: http://india.gov.in/outerwin.php?id=http://mohfw.nic.in/NRHM/ NRHM%28National%20Rural%20Health%20Mission%29.htm.

Obstetric care in poor settings in Ghana, India, and Kenya. Washington (D.C.): The World Bank. Available:

of Health and Family Welfare, Department of Family Welfare

on behalf of The Lancet Maternal Survival Series steering group (2006) Maternal mortality: who, when, where and why.

on behalf of The Lancet Maternal Survival Series steering group (2006) Mobilising financial resources for maternal health.

Organization (ILO).Laborsta database. Available: http:// laborsta.ilo.org/.

Organization (WHO)

Organization (WHO)CHOICE: choosing interventions that are cost-effective.

Planned Caesarean section for term breech delivery.

Pregnancy-related deaths in rural Rajasthan, India: exploring causes, context, and care-seeking through verbal autopsy.

Prevention and treatment of postpartum endometritis.

Public health policy for cervical cancer prevention: role of decision science, economic evaluation, and mathematical modeling.

Reproductive and Child Health Programme Document (RCH II–Document 2): the principles and evidence base for State RCH II Programme Implementation Plans (PIPs).

Reproductive Health Costing Tools Model.

Risks of mifepristone abortion in context.

Setting priorities for safe motherhood interventions in resource-scarce settings.

Shah I Unsafe abortion: global and regional estimates of unsafe abortion and associated mortality

Sood N A comparison of the health systems in China and India. Rand Corporation. Available: http://www.rand.org/pubs/occasional_papers/2008/ RAND_OP212.pdf.

State of the world’s children. Available: http://www.unicef.org/ sowc/archive/ENGLISH/The%20State%20of%20the%20World%27s%20Children %202004.pdf.

The Alan Guttmacher Institute (AGI)

The application of the mother baby package reproductive health costing spreadsheet in Morelos:

The costs, benefits, and cost-effectiveness of interventions to reduce maternal morbidity and mortality in Mexico.

The global burden of unsafe abortion in the year 2000, Geneva: World Health Organization, Available: http://www.who. int/healthinfo/statistics/bod_abortions.pdf.

The incidence of abortion worldwide.

The political economy of abortion in India: cost and expenditure patterns.

The state of political priority for safe motherhood in India.

TheAlanGuttmacherInstitute(AGI)(2007)Factsoninducedabortionworldwide: worldwide incidence and trends. Available: http://www.guttmacher.org/pubs/ fb_IAW.html.

Too far to walk: maternal mortality in context.

Unsafe abortion: global and regional estimates of unsafe abortion and associated mortality

Vaccine– preventable diseases. Disease control priorities in developing countries. 2nd edition.

Vacuum extraction versus forceps for assisted vaginal delivery.

WHO analysis of causes of maternal death: a systematic review.

WHO multicentre randomised trial of misoprostol in the management of the third stage of labour.

World Health Organization. Available: http:// www.who.int/healthinfo/statistics/bod_obstructedlabour.pdf.

World Health Organization. Available: http://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/publications/monitoring/ 9241562706/en/index.html.

http://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/4553340/2857650.pdf?sequence=1

Alternative Strategies to Reduce Maternal Mortality in India: A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

Crossref

Directory of Open Access Journals

Public Library of Science (PLOS)

University of Melbourne Institutional Repository

Harvard University - DASH