Frost, J. William

English

Works

 Swarthmore CollegeWorks   Religion Faculty Works   7-1-1989  Review Of "The Transformation Of American Quakerism: Orthodox Friendsy 1800-1907" By T. D. Hamm  J. William Frost Swarthmore College   Let us know how access to this work benefits you.  Follow this and additional works at: http://works.swarthmore.edu/fac-religion   Part of the Religion Commons   Recommended Citation J. William Frost. (1989). "Review Of "The Transformation Of American Quakerism: Orthodox Friendsy 1800-1907" By T. D. Hamm". Pennsylvania Magazine Of History And Biography. Volume 113, Issue 3. 483-485. http://works.swarthmore.edu/fac-religion/103  This work is brought to you for free and open access by the Swarthmore College Libraries. It has been accepted for inclusion in Religion Faculty Works by an authorized administrator of Works. For more information, please contact myworks@swarthmore.edu.   ReviewReviewed Work(s): The Transformation of American Quakerism: Orthodox Friends, 1800-1907 by Thomas D. HammReview by: J. William FrostSource: The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, Vol. 113, No. 3 (Jul., 1989),pp. 483-485Published by: The Historical Society of PennsylvaniaStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/20092382Accessed: 17-05-2017 14:25 UTC JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusteddigital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information aboutJSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available athttp://about.jstor.org/termsThe Historical Society of Pennsylvania is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extendaccess to The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and BiographyThis content downloaded from 130.58.88.100 on Wed, 17 May 2017 14:25:25 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/termsThis content downloaded from 130.58.88.100 on Wed, 17 May 2017 14:25:25 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms1989 BOOK REVIEWS 483 McPherson describes ably), Stowe's book provides a feminist critique of a society corrupted by an industrializing nation controlled by male values. All these questions derive from a professional perspective which empha-sizes the power of social, cultural, and institutional contexts to shape human choices. But McPherson knowingly chose the other path, emphasizing hu-mans shaping their world. The result is a superb traditional retelling of the nation's most important public experience. Historians interested in alter-native stories can set their contributions alongside McPherson's and be assured that they are in the best of company. University of Kansas PHILLIP S. PALUDAN The Transformation of American Quakerism: Orthodox Friends, 1800-1907. By THOMAS D. HAMM. (Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana Uni-versity Press, 19 8 8. xvii, 2 61 p. Appendixes, bibliography, index. $25.00.) Easterners often assume that all nineteenth-century American Quakers followed the pattern of the Philadelphia Yearly Meeting. In actuality, two thirds of American Friends-almost all of those west of the Alleghenies-between 1860 and 1900 repudiated most of what Philadelphia Quakers had long defined as correct faith and practice. A midwestern Friend by 1900 attended revivals, cared little about the Inner Light, went to church (not a meeting) to hear a sermon and sing hymns, paid money for a minister, and ignored Quaker traditions of pacifism, plain style of dress, and speech. The two most prominent twentieth-century Friends-Herbert Hoover and Richard Nixon-came out of a Quakerism that owed more to evangelicalism and holiness than to George Fox and William Penn. The complex and confusing story of the transformation of mid- and far western Quakerism has for the first time been clearly delineated in Thomas Hamm's prize-winning book. The Hicksite-Orthodox split in the Philadelphia Yearly Meeting in 1827 ended with all American Quakers divided into two camps. The Hicksites had overwhelming numerical domination in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York, and Maryland. Elsewhere the Orthodox prevailed, and Hamm's book concentrates upon their innovations. After 1827, the Orthodox composed two factions; both agreed upon the primacy of scripture, the atonement, virgin birth, and the necessity of religious experience. Quietists (later termed Wilburites or Conservatives) opposed the evangelical emphasis on higher education, Sunday schools, and cooperation with other denominations in benevolent activities. Their religion centered in a disciplined quest for This content downloaded from 130.58.88.100 on Wed, 17 May 2017 14:25:25 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms484 BOOK REVIEWS July holiness obtained gradually through silent waiting on the Lord. The evan-gelicals (later termed Gurneyites) wanted to revitalize what they saw as the dead traditionalism of many Friends. The result was a series of separations in New England, Ohio, and Indiana before 18 5 0 and in Iowa and Kansas in the 1870s. Gurneyites and Conservatives remained together in the Phil-adelphia Yearly Meeting Orthodox, but the price of unity was isolation and loss of influence on western Friends-though individual Friends and Hav-erford College still had an impact. Friends' desire to end slavery prompted many to fight in the Civil War, thereby weakening pacifism and undermining the traditional disciplinary system. A small elite among Gurneyite Friends attempted to revitalize the Orthodox by founding schools and Sunday schools, promoting Bible study, ending disownment for marriage to a non-Quaker, and stressing a conversion experience. But silent meetings proved less efficient in converting people than revivals. Traveling Quaker ministers began soliciting testimonies and holding protracted meetings. The number of converts (including birthright Friends and outsiders) showed the value of revivals, and new techniques swept midwestern Quaker meetings in the 1870s and 1880s. The holiness movement provided a theology for post-18 60 revivalism. Holiness emphases came to Friends from the Methodists and the Oberlin theology of Charles Finney. Holiness advocates insisted that in addition to conversion there was a second act of grace which brought sanctification. The fruits of sanctification appeared in a holy life-no dancing, card playing, novel reading, attending theater. Holiness preachers distrusted denomina-tional differences and opposed modernism. After 1890 many holiness ad-vocates became fundamentalists. The revival and holiness seemed to many midwestern Quakers-their leader was David Updegraff-to be commanded in the Bible. Revivals needed revivalists, and these preachers brought a new conception of the role of means of grace: set prayers, sermons, hymns, salaried ministers. Within twenty years the Gurneyite Friends repudiated silent meetings, the traditional Quaker attitudes toward paid ministers, the gradual process of religious growth, and virtually all Quaker traditions. Only when midwestern holiness Friends began practicing baptism did evangelical Friends in Eng-land and elsewhere draw back. The holiness Friends came to dominate yearly meetings in Ohio, Iowa, Kansas, Oregon, and California. Evangelical Friends who accepted the pastoral system but not holiness or sacraments prevailed in New England, Indiana, and North Carolina. Orthodox Friends in Great Britain, Philadelphia, Maryland, and New York continued un-programmed or silent meetings and never espoused either the revival or holiness emphases. Instead, after 1900 they accepted liberalism or modern-ism and modified evangelicalism. This content downloaded from 130.58.88.100 on Wed, 17 May 2017 14:25:25 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/termsThe Limits of Sisterhood: The Beecher Sisters on Women's Rights and Woman's Sphere. Edited by JEANNE BOYDSTON, MARY KELLEY, and ANNE MARGOLIS. (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1988. xxiv, 369p. Chronology, illustrations, index. Cloth, $32.00; paper, $12.95.) In the mid- and late nineteenth century, Anglo-American Victorians read-and wrote-a prodigious number of "life and letter" biographies. Combining commentary with lengthy extracts, such biographies aimed to give the life in the subject's own words. In The Limits of Sisterhood, Jeanne Boydston, Mary Kelley, and Anne Margolis offer a volume reminiscent of the nineteenth century's beloved form, but now containing critical commentary often missing from their predecessors. Rigorously limiting their selection, the editors have chosen documents that illustrate two central and intertwining themes-women's rights and woman's sphere-in the lives of Catharine Beecher, Harriet Beecher Stowe, and Isabella Beecher Hooker. Their choice of correspon-dence, journal entries, and extracts from published work, unified by com-mentary and headnotes, constitutes a major contribution to American women's studies, culture studies, and social history. Catharine Beecher and Harriet Beecher Stowe have received considerable attention from scholars and the reading public, whereas Isabella Beecher Hooker, say the editors, has been unjustly ignored, overshadowed by her 1989 BOOK REVIEWS 485 Quakers today are so numerically insignificant that the arcane details of each faction are of little general interest. Hamm's book is important because he shows the strengths and weaknesses of a variety of conceptual schemas in understanding religious history. Friends' responses to four major devel-opments among Protestants-evangelicalism, revivals, holiness, and liber-alism-were conditioned by intellectual presuppositions, class differences, economic transformation, Quaker traditions, and the general cultural milieu. The Quakers adjusted differently than Methodists, Presbyterians, and Bap-tists, yet these denominations also fragmented between 1820 and 1880. The history of nineteenth-century Friends is one of division; the twentieth century saw all Quaker bodies joining in attempts to reaffirm a common tradition. Hamm's theological sophistication, knowledge of general historical trends, exhaustive research, and clear writing have resulted in a superb book. Friends Historical Library, Swarthmore College J. WILLIAM FROST 

Review Of  The Transformation Of American Quakerism: Orthodox Friendsy 1800-1907  By T. D. Hamm

 Swarthmore College
Works 
 
 
Religion Faculty Works 
 
 
7-1-1989 
 
Review Of "The Transformation Of 
American Quakerism: Orthodox Friendsy 
1800-1907" By T. D. Hamm 
 
J. William Frost 
Swarthmore College  
 
Let us know how access to this work benefits you. 
 
Follow this and additional works at: http://works.swarthmore.edu/fac-religion  
 Part of the Religion Commons 
 
 
Recommended Citation 
J. William Frost. (1989). "Review Of "The Transformation Of American Quakerism: Orthodox Friendsy 
1800-1907" By T. D. Hamm". Pennsylvania Magazine Of History And Biography. Volume 113, Issue 3. 
483-485. 
http://works.swarthmore.edu/fac-religion/103 
 
This work is brought to you for free and open access by the Swarthmore College Libraries. It has 
been accepted for inclusion in Religion Faculty Works by an authorized administrator of Works. For 
more information, please contact myworks@swarthmore.edu. 
 
 
Review
Reviewed Work(s): The Transformation of American Quakerism: Orthodox Friends, 1800-
1907 by Thomas D. Hamm
Review by: J. William Frost
Source: The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, Vol. 113, No. 3 (Jul., 1989),
pp. 483-485
Published by: The Historical Society of Pennsylvania
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/20092382
Accessed: 17-05-2017 14:25 UTC
 
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted
digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about
JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
 
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://about.jstor.org/terms
The Historical Society of Pennsylvania is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend
access to The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography
This content downloaded from 130.58.88.100 on Wed, 17 May 2017 14:25:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
This content downloaded from 130.58.88.100 on Wed, 17 May 2017 14:25:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
1989 BOOK REVIEWS 483 
McPherson describes ably), Stowe's book provides a feminist critique of a 
society corrupted by an industrializing nation controlled by male values. 
All these questions derive from a professional perspective which empha-
sizes the power of social, cultural, and institutional contexts to shape human 
choices. But McPherson knowingly chose the other path, emphasizing hu-
mans shaping their world. The result is a superb traditional retelling of the 
nation's most important public experience. Historians interested in alter-
native stories can set their contributions alongside McPherson's and be 
assured that they are in the best of company. 
University of Kansas PHILLIP S. PALUDAN 
The Transformation of American Quakerism: Orthodox Friends, 1800-1907. By 
THOMAS D. HAMM. (Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana Uni-
versity Press, 19 8 8. xvii, 2 61 p. Appendixes, bibliography, index. 
$25.00.) 
Easterners often assume that all nineteenth-century American Quakers 
followed the pattern of the Philadelphia Yearly Meeting. In actuality, two 
thirds of American Friends-almost all of those west of the Alleghenies-
between 1860 and 1900 repudiated most of what Philadelphia Quakers had 
long defined as correct faith and practice. A midwestern Friend by 1900 
attended revivals, cared little about the Inner Light, went to church (not 
a meeting) to hear a sermon and sing hymns, paid money for a minister, 
and ignored Quaker traditions of pacifism, plain style of dress, and speech. 
The two most prominent twentieth-century Friends-Herbert Hoover and 
Richard Nixon-came out of a Quakerism that owed more to evangelicalism 
and holiness than to George Fox and William Penn. The complex and 
confusing story of the transformation of mid- and far western Quakerism 
has for the first time been clearly delineated in Thomas Hamm's prize-
winning book. 
The Hicksite-Orthodox split in the Philadelphia Yearly Meeting in 1827 
ended with all American Quakers divided into two camps. The Hicksites 
had overwhelming numerical domination in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New 
York, and Maryland. Elsewhere the Orthodox prevailed, and Hamm's book 
concentrates upon their innovations. After 1827, the Orthodox composed 
two factions; both agreed upon the primacy of scripture, the atonement, 
virgin birth, and the necessity of religious experience. Quietists (later termed 
Wilburites or Conservatives) opposed the evangelical emphasis on higher 
education, Sunday schools, and cooperation with other denominations in 
benevolent activities. Their religion centered in a disciplined quest for 
This content downloaded from 130.58.88.100 on Wed, 17 May 2017 14:25:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
484 BOOK REVIEWS July 
holiness obtained gradually through silent waiting on the Lord. The evan-
gelicals (later termed Gurneyites) wanted to revitalize what they saw as the 
dead traditionalism of many Friends. The result was a series of separations 
in New England, Ohio, and Indiana before 18 5 0 and in Iowa and Kansas 
in the 1870s. Gurneyites and Conservatives remained together in the Phil-
adelphia Yearly Meeting Orthodox, but the price of unity was isolation and 
loss of influence on western Friends-though individual Friends and Hav-
erford College still had an impact. 
Friends' desire to end slavery prompted many to fight in the Civil War, 
thereby weakening pacifism and undermining the traditional disciplinary 
system. A small elite among Gurneyite Friends attempted to revitalize the 
Orthodox by founding schools and Sunday schools, promoting Bible study, 
ending disownment for marriage to a non-Quaker, and stressing a conversion 
experience. But silent meetings proved less efficient in converting people 
than revivals. Traveling Quaker ministers began soliciting testimonies and 
holding protracted meetings. The number of converts (including birthright 
Friends and outsiders) showed the value of revivals, and new techniques 
swept midwestern Quaker meetings in the 1870s and 1880s. 
The holiness movement provided a theology for post-18 60 revivalism. 
Holiness emphases came to Friends from the Methodists and the Oberlin 
theology of Charles Finney. Holiness advocates insisted that in addition to 
conversion there was a second act of grace which brought sanctification. 
The fruits of sanctification appeared in a holy life-no dancing, card playing, 
novel reading, attending theater. Holiness preachers distrusted denomina-
tional differences and opposed modernism. After 1890 many holiness ad-
vocates became fundamentalists. 
The revival and holiness seemed to many midwestern Quakers-their 
leader was David Updegraff-to be commanded in the Bible. Revivals 
needed revivalists, and these preachers brought a new conception of the 
role of means of grace: set prayers, sermons, hymns, salaried ministers. 
Within twenty years the Gurneyite Friends repudiated silent meetings, the 
traditional Quaker attitudes toward paid ministers, the gradual process of 
religious growth, and virtually all Quaker traditions. Only when midwestern 
holiness Friends began practicing baptism did evangelical Friends in Eng-
land and elsewhere draw back. The holiness Friends came to dominate 
yearly meetings in Ohio, Iowa, Kansas, Oregon, and California. Evangelical 
Friends who accepted the pastoral system but not holiness or sacraments 
prevailed in New England, Indiana, and North Carolina. Orthodox Friends 
in Great Britain, Philadelphia, Maryland, and New York continued un-
programmed or silent meetings and never espoused either the revival or 
holiness emphases. Instead, after 1900 they accepted liberalism or modern-
ism and modified evangelicalism. 
This content downloaded from 130.58.88.100 on Wed, 17 May 2017 14:25:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
The Limits of Sisterhood: The Beecher Sisters on Women's Rights and Woman's 
Sphere. Edited by JEANNE BOYDSTON, MARY KELLEY, and ANNE 
MARGOLIS. (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1988. 
xxiv, 369p. Chronology, illustrations, index. Cloth, $32.00; paper, 
$12.95.) 
In the mid- and late nineteenth century, Anglo-American Victorians 
read-and wrote-a prodigious number of "life and letter" biographies. 
Combining commentary with lengthy extracts, such biographies aimed to 
give the life in the subject's own words. 
In The Limits of Sisterhood, Jeanne Boydston, Mary Kelley, and Anne 
Margolis offer a volume reminiscent of the nineteenth century's beloved 
form, but now containing critical commentary often missing from their 
predecessors. Rigorously limiting their selection, the editors have chosen 
documents that illustrate two central and intertwining themes-women's 
rights and woman's sphere-in the lives of Catharine Beecher, Harriet 
Beecher Stowe, and Isabella Beecher Hooker. Their choice of correspon-
dence, journal entries, and extracts from published work, unified by com-
mentary and headnotes, constitutes a major contribution to American 
women's studies, culture studies, and social history. 
Catharine Beecher and Harriet Beecher Stowe have received considerable 
attention from scholars and the reading public, whereas Isabella Beecher 
Hooker, say the editors, has been unjustly ignored, overshadowed by her 
1989 BOOK REVIEWS 485 
Quakers today are so numerically insignificant that the arcane details of 
each faction are of little general interest. Hamm's book is important because 
he shows the strengths and weaknesses of a variety of conceptual schemas 
in understanding religious history. Friends' responses to four major devel-
opments among Protestants-evangelicalism, revivals, holiness, and liber-
alism-were conditioned by intellectual presuppositions, class differences, 
economic transformation, Quaker traditions, and the general cultural milieu. 
The Quakers adjusted differently than Methodists, Presbyterians, and Bap-
tists, yet these denominations also fragmented between 1820 and 1880. 
The history of nineteenth-century Friends is one of division; the twentieth 
century saw all Quaker bodies joining in attempts to reaffirm a common 
tradition. Hamm's theological sophistication, knowledge of general historical 
trends, exhaustive research, and clear writing have resulted in a superb 
book. 
Friends Historical Library, 
Swarthmore College J. WILLIAM FROST 


https://works.swarthmore.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1102&amp;context=fac-religion

Review Of The Transformation Of American Quakerism: Orthodox Friendsy 1800-1907 By T. D. Hamm

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

Works

Works