Aikin, Scott F.

Scholarship at UWindsor

University of WindsorScholarship at UWindsorOSSA Conference Archive OSSA 8Jun 3rd, 9:00 AM - Jun 6th, 5:00 PMReply to my Commentator - AikinScott F. AikinVanderbilt UniversityFollow this and additional works at: http://scholar.uwindsor.ca/ossaarchivePart of the Philosophy CommonsThis Reply is brought to you for free and open access by the Faculty of Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences at Scholarship at UWindsor. It has beenaccepted for inclusion in OSSA Conference Archive by an authorized administrator of Scholarship at UWindsor. For more information, please contactscholarship@uwindsor.ca.Scott F. Aikin, "Reply to my Commentator - Aikin" ( June 3, 2009). OSSA Conference Archive. Paper 180.http://scholar.uwindsor.ca/ossaarchive/OSSA8/papersandcommentaries/180            	                               ﬀ         ﬁ ﬂ    ﬃ   ! " # $ % & ! ' % !  # ( )* + , # # - . $  ( + / 0 1 1 ﬃ 2 3   4 5  6 7     8 5 	   9   ﬂ     6 :  6           ; <  = 	      <   >  <   ? @ A B C D C E @ F G H E I J K L H M KN I M O H J P A B K Q M A R H J D A K FS S S T UJ L I M V I B BW I D @ R A B B H X Y W Z [ \ ] ^Q _ `D a C K K b c b I A d A M e R I M O H J P A B K b H OUf g h i j k g l k m n o p g q k n p k o i i o r n s t u n v n o r k l i o t m n o w g x f t n o l p g t m y k u t z l n p o s { p n | s jx p g j j k t { k l } ~ p k u r h g u t x p g j j k t { k u l n p g n f p g q k t o n l p o  t n p k r p k n o r u x g j n p k o r v n o  k l k j | m k | k g n u t { } f n g  k u n n p g n l k j |  m k | k g n u l g x o t x k i n  u n p g  u m k i k t s h  r g l n r k n x p u t { | r o hl n r u x n j v l k h g t n u x g j j v l k j |  r k | s n u t { l n g n k h k t n l  k } { }    j j   l n g n k h k t n l g r k | g j l k    n oi r g { h g n u x g j j v u t x o t l u l n k t n l i k k x p  g x n l  k } { }   f m o t z n k  u l n   g t m i j g t l  k } { }  n p kp k m o t u l n u x i g r g m o  w g x f t n o l p g t m y k u t o s n j u t k   g t m s j n u h g n k j v n o n p k o r u k l n p g n u | n r s ks t m k r x s n n p k Ł s l n u | u x g n u o t o t k x o s j m p g q k | o r p o j m u t { n p k h  k } { }   k q u t g l z l n p k l u l n p g n n p kn p k r u l s t n p k h g n u  g  j k  u | u n u l n r s k  n p k t p k x g t t o n m k h o t l n r g n k u n  }  w v n p k l u l u l n p g nn p k l n r o t { i r o { r g h u t r p k n o r u x v u k j m l s t m k r x s n n u t { r k g l o t l g { g u t l n n p k x g l k | o r n p ki r o { r g h } ~ p k  s u x  g t m m u r n v g r { s h k t n u l n p g n f  g h k h  k r o | n p k n g r { k n g s m u k t x k | o r n p kn p k o r v z l g r { s h k t n l  g h t o n x o t q u t x k m  g t m l o n p k v h s l n t o n  k { o o m g r { s h k t n l } ~ p ki r o x k l l g r { s h k t n u l n p g n u | r p k n o r u x g j g r { s h k t n l x g t o t j v v u k j m  s g j u | u k m g l l k t n  p k t  kl k k n p k h g l k t n u r k j v r p k n o r u x g j  n p k t n p k g r { s h k t n l   v n p k l n g t m g r m l o | n p k n p k o r v  h s l nt o n  k q k r v { o o m }  m h u n n k m j v  n p u l u l t o n l n r u x n l k j |  m k | k g n | o r n p k n p k o r v  u n m o k l t o n k t n g u ju n l o  t | g j l u n v  u | n r s k    s n u n x k r n g u t j v u l g i r o  j k h } f | n p g n z l t o n l k j |  m k | k g n  | u t k }w g x f t n o l p g t m y k u t z l | u r l n o  Ł k x n u o t u l n p g n  i k r p g i l  n p k r p k n o r u x g j u n v o |g r { s h k t n l h g v  k       g t g j o { o s l n o k  n k r t g j o  Ł k x n l o t w o o r k z l i r o o | } ~ p u l h g v  kr u { p n   s n n p u l l n r g n k { v u l n o i o l u n g t o t  r p k n o r u x g j | k g n s r k o | n p k n p k o r v  n p k  r s n k t k l l o | u n lr k | k r k t n  g l g r k g l o t n p g n Ł s l n u | u k l u n }  o t l k  s k t n j v  u n s t m k r x s n l g r p k n o r u x g j n p k o r v o |r k g l o t l } w o r k o q k r  w o o r k g t l n r g n k { u k l g r k g r { s h k t n g n u q k j v q u x u o s l u t l k n n j u t { m u l i s n k l } w g x f t n o l p g t m y k u t z l l k x o t m o  Ł k x n u o t u l g l n o  p k n p k r n p k r k u l g j k { u n u h g n km u | | k r k t x k  k n  k k t  s g j u | u k m g t m s t  s g j u | u k m  k j u k |  g l x r u i n u o t l } ~ p k v g r k r u { p n n p g n n o k j u k q k i u l n o g x x k i n i g l g n r s k l n g n k h k t n  g t m u t n p u l x g l k  u n u l g x g l k o |  p g n f z q k x g j j k mg l l k t n  s t q g r t u l p k m }  s n l s r k j v  k x g t l k k n p k m u | | k r k t x k  k n  k k t                        ¡   ¢   £ g t m          £ ¤      ¢ } f n u l n p k j o { u x g j { g i  k n  k k t n p k n  o n p o s { p n l n p g nv u k j m l  s g j u | u x g n u o t o | g l l k t n }~ p k n p u r m o  Ł k x n u o t u l n p g n n p k r p k n o r u x g j n p k o r v m o k l t o n r k x o { t u  k n p k m u | | k r k t x k k n  k k t  g m g t m x o t q u t x u t { g r { s h k t n l  g t m l o h v l n k i  ¥   n p k g m h u l l u o t o |g r { s h k t n g n u q k r k { r k n  u l t o n g j j o  g  j k } ~ p u l h g v  k g t k | | k x n u q k m k | k t x k g { g u t l n h v¦ § ¨ ¨ © ª ¨ « « ¬ ª ­ ® ¯ ° ± ² ³ ¬ ´ µ ¶ § ® © © µ ¶ « µ · ¯ ¸ ® ¶ ® ¶ ¹ ¯ ° ¨ º ¬ ´ ® ¨ ¯ ® ¨ « µ » « ¨ ¸ » ¼ ´ ¨ » · ¯ ¬ ¯ ® µ ¶ » µ ´ ½ ¨ º ® ¶ ¬ « ¾ « º ® ¨ ­ ¿ À Á Á Â Ã ²Ä§ ¨ ¨ © ª ¨ « « ¬ ª µ ¶ Å µ µ ´ ¨ ¾ « Æ ´ µ µ » ¬ ¶ Ç ° µ ­ ® ¯ » ¬ ® ¸ « ¯ ° ¨ Ç ® ¬ ¸ ¨ È ¯ ® È ¬ ¸ Ç ¨ © ¬ ¶ Ç « µ » ¬ ¶ ¯ ® ¼ « È ¨ Æ ¯ ® È ® « © ¿ À Á Á É Ã ²Ê~ ~ Ë }  f Ì f ÍÎi r o x k l l g r { s h k t n   s n u n o i k t l r p k n o r u x n o n p k o j m Ï j g n o t u x  o r r v n p g n g r { s h k t n l  t oh g n n k r p o  | g j j g x u o s l   u j j i g l l u | x o t q u t x u t { }~ p k | u t g j o  Ł k x n u o t u l n p g n n p k r k  s u r k m r p k n o r u x g j o  Ł k x n u q k l o | g r { s h k t n t k k m t o ns t m k r x s n o s r Ł s l n u | u x g n u o t | o r  k u t { h o q k m  v n p k h }  s n  p k t  k | u t m o s r l k j q k l h o q k mo r s t h o q k m  v g r { s h k t n   k m o t o n i o u t n n o n p k u r r p k n o r u x g j o  Ł k x n u q k l   s n n o n p k  s g j u n vo | n p k u r i r k h u l k l o r n p k j o { u x o | n p k u r l s i i o r n } f |  k q u k  g r { s h k t n l  o t n p k l n r o t {i r o { r g h  g l k t n u r k j v r p k n o r u x g j   k p g q k t o n p u t { n o { o o t } u t  n o x o h h k t n g r v  u t  n o i g i k rÐ Ñ Ò Ñ Ð Ñ Ó Ô Ñ§³ ® Õ ® ¶ Ö § ² ¬ ¶ Ç ± ² ³ ² § ® © © µ ¶ « À Á Á Â ² ½ ¨ º ® ¶ ¬ « ® ¬ ¶ µ ¯ ° ¨ ´ ® « © Ö « Õ ¨ Æ ¯ ® È ® « © Ö ¬ ¶ Ç ¯ ° ¨ Æ ´ µ × ¸ ¨ © µ » « ¨ ¸ » ¼ ´ ¨ » · ¯ ¬ ¯ ® µ ¶ ²Y @ H? @ A B C D C E @ A a I BTC JUL ØÁ Ù Ú ²³ ® Õ ® ¶ Ö § ² À Á Á É ² Å µ µ ´ ¨ ¾ « ° ¬ ¶ Ç ¬ ¶ Ç ¯ ° ¨ Ç ® ¬ ¸ ¨ È ¯ ® È ¬ ¸ Ç ¨ © ¬ ¶ Ç « µ » ¬ ¶ ¯ ® ¼ « Õ ¨ Æ ¯ ® È ® « © ²_ CUK @ Û H D K ? @ A B C D C E @ F Ü H R A H ÛÀØÙ À ²

Reply to my Commentator - Aikin

http://scholar.uwindsor.ca/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2184&context=ossaarchive

Reply to my Commentator - Aikin

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

Scholarship at UWindsor