The Value Relevance of Forced Top Management Departures

Abstract

This paper studies the value relevance of management turnover based on a sample of Dutch events. Consistent with previous studies we find weak or insignificant aggregate announcement effects on stock prices. The evidence is in conflict with effective internal monitoring from which positive abnormal returns would result. The hypothesis is that two opposing forces underlie the inconclusive result: (1) A positive real effect of the unanticipated forced resignation of a poor performing manager and (2) A negative information effect if the change signals worse management performance than anticipated. To test the hypothesis, announcement effects on trading volumes are analyzed too. Our conclusion supports the hypothesis: forced management departures are value relevant.top management turnover/resignations/changes; corporate governance; internal monitoring; value relevance; event study.