Lusk, Kirsty

Maley, Willy

English

Enlighten

13/09/2016 Six days that shook the world: how the Easter Rising changed everythinghttps://theconversation.com/six­days­that­shook­the­world­how­the­easter­rising­changed­everything­57140 1/4AuthorsWilly MaleyProfessor of Renaissance Studies,University of GlasgowKirsty LuskPre­doctoral researcher, University ofGlasgowAcademic rigour, journalistic flairSix days that shook the world: how the Easter Risingchanged everythingApril 4, 2016 3.42pm BSTThe Easter Rising of April 1916 did not just lay the foundations for Irish independence.It was an event of importance across the world. Arguably it helped usher in an era ofstruggles for independence, as well as laying down a milestone in social and genderequality that had similarly far-reaching eﬀects.When Irish Volunteer Patrick Pearse loudly declared independence outside the DublinGeneral Post Oﬃce on April 24 1916 as one of leaders of over 1,700 insurrectionists, itwas an attack on the heart of the British Empire. This was a time when it was alreadyunder pressure on the back of the Boer War and World War I.Though the rising was thwarted ﬁve days later and Irish independence would nothappen until 1923, many believe that the actions that began that Easter Monday helpedinspire similar rebellions in more distant parts of the British Empire. Not least itencouraged nationalists in India, even if they rejected the road of armed resistance. Itwas not long until the Amritsar massacre of 1919 that helped pave the way to Indianindependence several decades later.Arguably the events in Dublin inspired other revolutionaries too, notably the Russianbolsheviks. One of the ringleaders of the Easter Rising was James Connolly, who led theDublin mural. Brian Lawless13/09/2016 Six days that shook the world: how the Easter Rising changed everythinghttps://theconversation.com/six­days­that­shook­the­world­how­the­easter­rising­changed­everything­57140 2/4socialist Irish Citizen Army, which contributed some 200 men. Both Lenin and Trotskyresponded sympathetically to Connolly’s melding of Marxism and nationalism, playingup the signiﬁcance of the rising and the mutual beneﬁts of the nationalist, women’s andworkers’ struggle – a point still highly relevant today.It is oǔen overlooked that both Connolly and the Russian Marxists were inspired by the Paris Commune of 1871, in which 20,000 insurrectionistswere killed by French loyalist troops. An early account of the Easter Rising compared the twoevents, pointing out that street ﬁghting on such ascale in a European city was rare.It is also worth mentioning Edinburgh-bornConnolly’s connection to Scottish socialist John Maclean and Red Clydeside. As Maclean later said:I was arrested and taken to Edinburgh castle as a prisoner of war [for being a communist],was bailed out, and was sentenced to penal servitude for three years at Edinburgh highcourt on Apri1 12 1916. When Jim Connolly saw how things were going in Edinburgh heresolved on the Easter rebellion in Dublin, the beginning of Ireland’s new ﬁght for freedom,a ﬁght that can only end in an Irish workers’ republic based on communism.People from Scotland and elsewhere travelled to Dublin to take part in the rising. RedClydeside then had its own insurrectionist moment in the battle for Glasgow’s GeorgeSquare of 1919.Equality strugglePatrick Pearse’s proclamation of the Irish republic, which was partly based on RobertEmmet’s proclamation of Irish independence of 1803, enshrined equal suﬀrage andequal rights. It spoke of “religious and civil liberty, equal rights and equal opportunitiesto all its citizens” and “cherishing all children of the nation equally”.James Connolly: ringleader. Wikimedia13/09/2016 Six days that shook the world: how the Easter Rising changed everythinghttps://theconversation.com/six­days­that­shook­the­world­how­the­easter­rising­changed­everything­57140 3/4Women’s suﬀrage had already been gaining ground elsewhere. Adult women hadgained the right to vote in New Zealand in 1893 and South Australia in 1894, which alsoextended them the right to stand for parliament. Yet by the time of the Easter Rising,most jurisdictions had not followed suit. The fact that equal suﬀrage and revolutionseemed bound up together in Ireland undoubtedly helped further the internationalcause. By the time women received the vote when the Irish Free State was established in1923, it had been extended by Moscow in the declaration by the provisional governmentof Russia of March 1917 and also in Canada and the United States in 1920.It would take until 1928 in the UK, 1944 in France and 1945 in Italy.Easter 1916 was also a ﬁght against social inequality. Connolly told his Irish CitizenArmy to hold on to their weapons when the battle seemed to be over, as they wereﬁghting for a diﬀerent Ireland from the purely nationalist Irish Volunteers. Connolly’sadvice to his comrades was perhaps on the assumption that if the rising succeeded, theywould have to be prepared to challenge their more conservative allies. Following the war of independence between the British and Irish (1919-21), these divisions led to abloody civil war in 1922-23. People then held on to their guns for many years to come.The proclamation begins …13/09/2016 Six days that shook the world: how the Easter Rising changed everythinghttps://theconversation.com/six­days­that­shook­the­world­how­the­easter­rising­changed­everything­57140 4/4UK Britain Russia Scotland Lenin Easter RisingThe divided legacyOpinion still divides on what the rising produced. Take the French connection. Whilesome historians emphasise the parallels with the Paris Commune, others argue that theIrish Free State had more in common with Catholic conservatism than radicalrepublicanism. This rings true, particularly if we fast-forward to the Spanish Civil Warand reﬂect on the fact that most Irish people supported fascist Franco. Then again,there were Irish Volunteers ﬁghting against Franco’s side who were named the ConnollyColumn in honour of their fallen leader, which shows that the socialist tradition playedits part there too.This illustrates that 1916 had a divided legacy. Connolly wrote a pamphlet in 1908, Socialism in Ireland, which insisted on the possibility of a socialist future, despite claimsthat the country was too economically backward and the clergy too conservative topermit such an outcome. But Connolly’s vision depended on independence for a unitedIreland. The “carnival of reaction” that he predicted would result from partition of thenorth and south would postpone that vision and prolong the road to socialism. Neitherthe free state, nor later the free market, could fulﬁl the socialist vision.Neither did it live up to what Pearse envisaged – an Ireland that would be Gaelic,independent, republican and united. Which, if any, of the leaders of the rising wouldrecognise the state of independence that they fought for today? When we mark thecentenary in the coming weeks, that is not a question that should be dismissed lightly.Dublin GPO after the insurrection. Diego Sideburns, CC BY­SA

Six days that shook the world: how the Easter Rising changed everything

Enlighten: Publications

13/09/2016 Six days that shook the world: how the Easter Rising changed everything
https://theconversation.com/six­days­that­shook­the­world­how­the­easter­rising­changed­everything­57140 1/4
Authors
Willy Maley
Professor of Renaissance Studies,
University of Glasgow
Kirsty Lusk
Pre­doctoral researcher, University of
Glasgow
Academic rigour, journalistic flair
Six days that shook the world: how the Easter Rising
changed everything
April 4, 2016 3.42pm BST
The Easter Rising of April 1916 did not just lay the foundations for Irish independence.
It was an event of importance across the world. Arguably it helped usher in an era of
struggles for independence, as well as laying down a milestone in social and gender
equality that had similarly far-reaching effects.
When Irish Volunteer Patrick Pearse loudly declared independence outside the Dublin
General Post Office on April 24 1916 as one of leaders of over 1,700 insurrectionists, it
was an attack on the heart of the British Empire. This was a time when it was already
under pressure on the back of the Boer War and World War I.
Though the rising was thwarted five days later and Irish independence would not
happen until 1923, many believe that the actions that began that Easter Monday helped
inspire similar rebellions in more distant parts of the British Empire. Not least it
encouraged nationalists in India, even if they rejected the road of armed resistance. It
was not long until the Amritsar massacre of 1919 that helped pave the way to Indian
independence several decades later.
Arguably the events in Dublin inspired other revolutionaries too, notably the Russian
bolsheviks. One of the ringleaders of the Easter Rising was James Connolly, who led the
Dublin mural. Brian Lawless
13/09/2016 Six days that shook the world: how the Easter Rising changed everything
https://theconversation.com/six­days­that­shook­the­world­how­the­easter­rising­changed­everything­57140 2/4
socialist Irish Citizen Army, which contributed some 200 men. Both Lenin and Trotsky
responded sympathetically to Connolly’s melding of Marxism and nationalism, playing
up the significance of the rising and the mutual benefits of the nationalist, women’s and
workers’ struggle – a point still highly relevant today.
It is oǔen overlooked that both Connolly and the 
Russian Marxists were inspired by the Paris 
Commune of 1871, in which 20,000 insurrectionists
were killed by French loyalist troops. An early 
account of the Easter Rising compared the two
events, pointing out that street fighting on such a
scale in a European city was rare.
It is also worth mentioning Edinburgh-born
Connolly’s connection to Scottish socialist John 
Maclean and Red Clydeside. As Maclean later said:
I was arrested and taken to Edinburgh castle as a prisoner of war [for being a communist],
was bailed out, and was sentenced to penal servitude for three years at Edinburgh high
court on Apri1 12 1916. When Jim Connolly saw how things were going in Edinburgh he
resolved on the Easter rebellion in Dublin, the beginning of Ireland’s new fight for freedom,
a fight that can only end in an Irish workers’ republic based on communism.
People from Scotland and elsewhere travelled to Dublin to take part in the rising. Red
Clydeside then had its own insurrectionist moment in the battle for Glasgow’s George
Square of 1919.
Equality struggle
Patrick Pearse’s proclamation of the Irish republic, which was partly based on Robert
Emmet’s proclamation of Irish independence of 1803, enshrined equal suffrage and
equal rights. It spoke of “religious and civil liberty, equal rights and equal opportunities
to all its citizens” and “cherishing all children of the nation equally”.
James Connolly: ringleader. Wikimedia
13/09/2016 Six days that shook the world: how the Easter Rising changed everything
https://theconversation.com/six­days­that­shook­the­world­how­the­easter­rising­changed­everything­57140 3/4
Women’s suffrage had already been gaining ground elsewhere. Adult women had
gained the right to vote in New Zealand in 1893 and South Australia in 1894, which also
extended them the right to stand for parliament. Yet by the time of the Easter Rising,
most jurisdictions had not followed suit. The fact that equal suffrage and revolution
seemed bound up together in Ireland undoubtedly helped further the international
cause. By the time women received the vote when the Irish Free State was established in
1923, it had been extended by Moscow in the declaration by the provisional government
of Russia of March 1917 and also in Canada and the United States in 1920.
It would take until 1928 in the UK, 1944 in France and 1945 in Italy.
Easter 1916 was also a fight against social inequality. Connolly told his Irish Citizen
Army to hold on to their weapons when the battle seemed to be over, as they were
fighting for a different Ireland from the purely nationalist Irish Volunteers. Connolly’s
advice to his comrades was perhaps on the assumption that if the rising succeeded, they
would have to be prepared to challenge their more conservative allies. Following the 
war of independence between the British and Irish (1919-21), these divisions led to a
bloody civil war in 1922-23. People then held on to their guns for many years to come.
The proclamation begins …
13/09/2016 Six days that shook the world: how the Easter Rising changed everything
https://theconversation.com/six­days­that­shook­the­world­how­the­easter­rising­changed­everything­57140 4/4
UK Britain Russia Scotland Lenin Easter Rising
The divided legacy
Opinion still divides on what the rising produced. Take the French connection. While
some historians emphasise the parallels with the Paris Commune, others argue that the
Irish Free State had more in common with Catholic conservatism than radical
republicanism. This rings true, particularly if we fast-forward to the Spanish Civil War
and reflect on the fact that most Irish people supported fascist Franco. Then again,
there were Irish Volunteers fighting against Franco’s side who were named the Connolly
Column in honour of their fallen leader, which shows that the socialist tradition played
its part there too.
This illustrates that 1916 had a divided legacy. Connolly wrote a pamphlet in 1908, 
Socialism in Ireland, which insisted on the possibility of a socialist future, despite claims
that the country was too economically backward and the clergy too conservative to
permit such an outcome. But Connolly’s vision depended on independence for a united
Ireland. The “carnival of reaction” that he predicted would result from partition of the
north and south would postpone that vision and prolong the road to socialism. Neither
the free state, nor later the free market, could fulfil the socialist vision.
Neither did it live up to what Pearse envisaged – an Ireland that would be Gaelic,
independent, republican and united. Which, if any, of the leaders of the rising would
recognise the state of independence that they fought for today? When we mark the
centenary in the coming weeks, that is not a question that should be dismissed lightly.
Dublin GPO after the insurrection. Diego Sideburns, CC BY­SA



http://eprints.gla.ac.uk/124368/1/124368.pdf

Six days that shook the world: how the Easter Rising changed everything

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

Enlighten

Enlighten: Publications