It is a common practice to fix a vertical gnomon and study the moving shadow
cast by it. This shows our local solar time and gives us a hint regarding the
season in which we perform the observation. The moving shadow can also tell us
our latitude with high precision. In this paper we propose to exchange the
roles and while keeping the shadows fixed on the ground we will move the
gnomon. This lets us understand in a simple way the relevance of the tropical
lines of latitude and the behavior of shadows in different locations. We then
put these ideas into practice using sticks and threads during a solstice on two
sites located on opposite sides of the Tropic of Capricorn.Comment: Published version available at
  http://cms.iafe.uba.ar/gangui/didaastro/#Publication

Alejandro Gangui

Rohr René R. J.

The Physics Teacher

English

arXiv

It is a common practice to fix a vertical gnomon and study the moving shadow cast by it. This shows our local solar time and gives us a hint on the season in which we perform the observation. The moving shadow can also tell us our latitude with high precision. In this paper we propose to exchange the roles and while keeping the shadows fixed on the ground we will move the gnomon. This lets us understand in a simple way the relevance of the tropical lines of latitude and the behavior of shadows in different locations. We then put these ideas into practice using sticks and threads during a solstice on two sites located on opposite sides of the Tropic of Capricorn.Fil: Gangui, Alejandro. Consejo Nacional de Investigaciónes Científicas y Técnicas. Oficina de Coordinación Administrativa Ciudad Universitaria. Instituto de Astronomía y Física del Espacio. - Universidad de Buenos Aires. Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales. Instituto de Astronomía y Física del Espacio; Argentin

Gangui, Alejandro

LAReferencia - Red Federada de Repositorios Institucionales de Publicaciones Científicas Latinoamericanas

As the observer moves on from the equator, the three dec-lination lines shift their positions with respect to the base of the gnomon, and also the curvature of the outer two lines gets modified. In  Ref. 3 we showed the gradual displacement of the straight middle line for four locations south of the equa-tor: it is shifted toward the south an amount proportional to the increase in the absolute value of the latitude. In general, for small displacements in latitude the difference in the cur-vature and relative positions of the outer two declination lines is not drastic, but the directions of the shadows at solar noon can surprise many of us.Both teachers and students sometimes think that the equa-torial line is the site where astronomical phenomena change drastically, e.g., where the crescent Moon inverts the orienta-tion of its illuminated “face” and, also, where Sun shadows point in opposite directions at noon. This confusion may arise from our habit of speaking in terms of (Northern and Southern) hemispheres and from our frequent disposition to contrast what we would see were we living in one or the other.In the case of the Sun, its location in the sky (its declination) is actually more important for astronomy than the terrestrial equator, as we will now see.Diurnal astronomy during a solsticeDuring the 2011 December solstice, in collaboration with colleagues from a few South American cities, we carried out a joint shadow-observing activity with the aim to emphasize aspects that were characteristic to each location (like the length of the shadows at noon cast by vertical gnomons) from others that were common to all cities (like the approximately similar concavity of the solstice declination line). This activ-ity was a follow up on the one already reported here.3Figure 2 shows two observational settings from different latitudes in Brazil: one in the city of Natal (Rio Grande do Norte) and the other in Caxias do Sul (Rio Grande do Sul). These cities have the (geographical) property of being located on opposite sides of the Tropic of Capricorn.In both cases, 1-meter vertical gnomons were employed and their shadows were marked on the floor with sticks. Sun rays going from the tip of each gnomon to the sticks were ma-terialized with threads, as shown in the picture from Caxias do Sul (Fig. 2). As we can see, the surprising fact now is to find solar noon shadows falling on opposite sides of the base of the gnomon. The shortest shadow in Caxias do Sul points toward the south; the corresponding one in Natal points toward the north. Clearly, the key latitude is the tropic, not the equator. During the December solstice (with the Sun at declination = –23.5°), cities situated north or south of latitude 23.5°S will experience opposite-pointing noon shadows (see Fixing the Shadows While Moving the GnomonAlejandro Gangui, IAFE/Conicet and Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina                    It is a common practice to fix a vertical gnomon and study the moving shadow cast by it. This shows our local solar time and gives us a hint on the season in which we per-form the observation. The moving shadow can also tell us our latitude with high precision. In this paper we propose to exchange the roles and while keeping the shadows fixed on the ground we will move the gnomon. This lets us understand in a simple way the relevance of the tropical lines of latitude and the behavior of shadows in different locations. We then put these ideas into practice using sticks and threads during a solstice on two sites located on opposite sides of the Tropic of Capricorn.Sundials usually include three lines (called declination lines) drawn on their surfaces (or dial faces). One of these is a straight line that corresponds to the shadow cast by the style (the time-telling edge of the gnomon) during the day on both equinoxes, and is oriented exactly in the east-west direction. The other two lines are curved and are located on opposite sides of the straight one: they also have opposite curvatures, with their concavity pointing away from the middle line. These two lines correspond to the style’s shadow during each of the solstices: the one to the north of the middle line is fol-lowed by the shadow during the December solstice (and the one to the south, during the June solstice).1All this is easy to see for a vertical gnomon placed exactly on the equator. During northern spring and summer (from approximately March 21 to Sept. 21), as the Sun is located to the north of the celestial equator (and its declination is posi-tive), the shadows of the style will fall to the south of its base.2 Moreover, the longest shadow at solar noon will be that of June 21, the Northern Hemisphere summer solstice (see Fig. 1).Fig. 1. Diagram in perspective showing the north-south (meridian) line and the three declination lines typical of simple sundials. The vertical gnomon corresponds to an observer placed on the equator. It will cast shadows on the floor along curves that fit inside the two extreme ones depicted in this figure. The straight middle line cor-responds to the shadows during equinoxes. The curved line to the left corresponds to the shadows during the June 21 solstice.The Physics Teacher ◆ Vol. 53, April 2015                          199200 The Physics Teacher ◆ Vol. 53, April 201532.8°N). In this case the observa-tions should be performed dur-ing days close to the June solstice. The solar noon shadow projected by the gnomon in Dallas will fall toward the north, while the solar noon shadow projected by the gnomon located in San José will fall toward the south.In summary, while in general during outdoor diurnal astro-nomical activities we expect to have a static gnomon fixed to the ground and see the shadows cast by it moving around, here we saw that it is also possible (within an acceptable level of approxima-tion) to keep fixed the declination lines and “move” instead the gno-mon. Doing this allows us to pre-dict, without traveling away from our site, what other observers in other locations will actually see. If we stick to latitudes within a few tens of degrees from the equator (to put a number, latitudes below 40°), the declination lines are not altered very much.1 Displacing the gnomon along the merid-ian line, as shown here in Fig. 3, may let us learn quite simply the relevance of the tropical lines of latitude and may provide us with a way to understand why noon shadows in tropical regions change their orientations during spring and summer in the way they do.AcknowledgmentsWe thank our colleagues from the project “Oblicuidad de la eclíptica,” especially Professors Auta Stella de Medeiros and Odilon Giovannini, for sharing with us their observations and pictures. We also thank the referees for their useful comments that helped improve the paper. A.G. acknowledg-es support from Conicet and from the University of Buenos Aires.References1.  René R. J. Rohr, Les Cadrans Solaires: Histoire, Théorie, Pra-tique (Editions Oberlin, Strasbourg, 1986).2.  Alejandro Gangui, “Whither does the Sun rove?” Phys. Teach. 49, 91–93 (Feb. 2011).3.  Nestor Camino and Alejandro Gangui, “Diurnal astronomy: Using sticks and threads to find our latitude on Earth,” Phys. Teach. 50, 40–41 (Jan. 2012).Alejandro Gangui is staff researcher at the Institute for Astronomy and Space Physics (IAFE) and is professor of physics at the University of Buenos Aires (UBA). gangui@iafe.uba.arFig. 3). As a corollary of this, those sites located exactly along the Tropic of Capricorn will project no noon shadow at all.Of course, a similar observational exercise can be planned for cities located on opposite sides of the Tropic of Cancer, for example, San José de Costa Rica (Lat: 9.9°N) and Dallas (Lat: Fig. 2. Two observational settings for studying the shadows cast by 1-meter vertical gnomons dur-ing the 2011 December solstice. Left image is from Natal (Lat: 5.8°S), while the image to the right is from Caxias do Sul (Lat: 29.2°S). Theoretical values for the angles between the gnomon and the solar noon threads (the shortest ones) are 17.7° = |5.8°-23.5°| for Natal, and 5.7° = (29.2°-23.5°) for Caxias do Sul. Measured values were actually 17° and 7°, respectively. Note that while the concav-ity of both curves made by the sticks on the ground is approximately the same (the picture on the right was rotated in order to better show this), these declination lines fall on opposite sides of the gnomon: the one in Natal falls to the north of the base of the gnomon and the one in Caxias do Sul to the south. In both images the north is to the right, as can be inferred by the last shadow cast by the gnomons—and visible in the pictures—which, coming from the southwestern setting Sun, points approximately toward the northeast. Photographs are courtesy of Auta Stella de Medeiros (Natal) and Odilon Giovannini (Caxias).Fig. 3. Fixing the shadows and moving the gnomons. This diagram is similar to that of Fig. 1, but now for gnomons placed on different latitudes. The one on the equator (Lat: 0°) would be placed on the straight middle line, as requiredby symmetry. Those located to the south of the equator, for example in Natal (Lat: 5.8°S) and in Caxias do Sul (Lat:29.2°S), are shown in the diagram. One gnomon located in Buenos Aires (Lat: 34.5°S) would be placed further to the right of these. Hence, shadows observed in Caxias do Sul or in Buenos Aires at noon can never point toward the north. (Although we know that the declination lines are slightly modified if we change the latitude of observers located not very far from the equator; here, for simplicity, we considered them unchanged.)

Fixing the shadows while moving the gnomon

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

LAReferencia - Red Federada de Repositorios Institucionales de Publicaciones Científicas Latinoamericanas

Crossref

CONICET Digital