Introduction: The aim of this study was to evaluate the most suitable
physical outcome measures to be used with critical care patients following
discharge. ICU survivors experience physical problems
such as reduced exercise capacity and intensive care acquired
weakness. NICE guideline ‘Rehabilitation after critical illness’ (1) recommends
the use of outcome measures however does not provide
any specific guidance. A recent Cochrane review noted wide variability
in measures used following ICU discharge (2).
Methods: Discharged ICU patients attended a five week multidisciplinary
programme. Patients’ physical function was assessed during
the programme, at 6 months and 12 months post discharge. Three
outcome measures were included in the initial two cohorts. The Six
Minute Walk Test (6MWT) and the Incremental Shuttle Walk test
(ISWT) were chosen as they have been used within the critical care
follow up setting (2). The Chester Step Test (CST) is widely thought
to be a good indicator of ability to return to work (one of the programmes
primary aims). Ethics approval was waived as the
programme was part of a quality improvement initiative.
Results: Data was collected for the initial patients attending the
programme (n = 13), median age was 52 (IQR = 38-72), median ICU
LOS was 19 days (IQR = 4-91), median APACHE II was 23 (IQR = 19-41)
and 11 were men. One patient was so physically debilitated that the
CST or ISWT could not be completed however a score was achieved
using the 6MWT. Another patient almost failed to achieve level 1 of
the ISWT. Subsequent patients for this project (total n = 47) have all
therefore been tested using the 6MWT. Good inter-rater and intrarater
reliability and validity have been reported for the 6MWT (3).
Conclusions: Exercise capacity measurement is not achievable for
some patients with either the ISWT or the CST due to the severity of
their physical debilitation. Anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder and
depression are common psychological problems post discharge (4),
therefore using a test with a bleep is not appropriate. Therefore, the 6MWT is the most appropriate physical outcome measure to be used
with critical care patients post discharge
