This study proposes that legacies of Puritanism are reflected in the way journalists
cover a range of events and processes. The consequences are ambiguous:
sometimes they may be harmful, other times they are laudable. Media coverage
of the death of Peter Connelly (Baby P) in 2007 is chosen as an example of the
social production of cultures of guilt and blame. In particular, journalists’
productive efforts perform significant and active roles in colouring public
responses to events. Thereby journalists may reflect in their secularised ethics the
hidden influences of nineteenth-century Evangelical traditions and earlier
Calvinist ones. Following the analysis of Weber, the paper argues that media
approaches to rationality also reflect an impress of lingering Puritan structures of
thought. The argument contrasts journalism with the Bohemian writing traditions,
which were perhaps suffocated by more urgent Calvinistic approaches alongside
the development of industrial capitalism. The paper concludes that newsroom
practices and values amount to implicit or covert cultural policies of their own