Aronson, Robert E.

O'Campo, Patricia

Peak, Geri L.

JScholarship

The Use of Neighborhood Mapping in Community Evaluation: The Experience of the Baltimore City Healthy Start Evaluation.

O'Campo, Patricia J.

The Use of Neighborhood Mapping in Community Evaluation: The Experience of the Baltimore City Healthy Start Evaluation Robert E. Aronson, Patricia J. O'Carnpo and Geri L. Peak Introduction; The Healthy Start Infant Mortality Prevention Demonstration Program is a federally funded initiative targeting thirteen cities and two rural areas across the United States which began in 1991. The program's goal is to reduce the infant mortality rate in these areas by 50% through the provision of comprehensive community-based services to pregnant women, their infants and their neighborhoods. In Baltimore, Healthy Start efforts are focused at two levels: the Project Area, encompassing 95 of Baltimore City including the highest risk neighborhoodsL; and two smaller "Taruet -Axeas", the Sandtown-Winchester/Harlem Park neighborhood in West Baltimore (Target Area A), and the Middle East neighborhood in East Baltimore (Target Area B) (See Map 1). The target area neighborhoods represent areas of the city with the highest social and reproductive risks. It is in these two target areas where the most intensive infant mortality reduction activities are being undertaken. A principle feature of Baltimore's Healthy Start Program is the establishment of "Neighborhood Healthy Start Centers" (NHSC's) in each of the target areas. Each NHSC is designed to be a "one stop shop" providing a broad array of social and health educational services ranging from addressing "urgent social needs" (no or substandard housing, addictions, lack of food, etc.) to breastfeeding promotion programs to educational and support groups around such topics as parenting, life planning, wellness and fathers' involvement in pregnancy and parenting. The NHSC operating in the target area to be described in this paper serves more than six hundred women each year (representing approximately 80% of the pregnant and new mothers in the target area). Outreach services of the NHSC send representatives of the program into the neighborhood where they knock on every door in the target areas at least once every eight weeks. Pregnant women and new mothers with infants less than 6 months old are recruited into the program to participate in services offered on site at the NHSC as well as to receive home visits from local residents trained as Neighborhood Health Advocates and professionally trained case managers. The Men's Services component of Healthy Start works with the male partners of Healthy Start clients, and has become a model program not only for the community but also for the nation. Healthy Start's visibility in the target areas is punctuated by the fact that it is the largest employer of neighborhood residents in each of its sites. Through its comprehensive services to women, their children and their male partners, and its strategy of employing community residents, Healthy Start aims to contribute to a process of "neighborhood transformation" that will produce changes in physical, social and behavioral aspects of the neighborhood that increase risk for poor pregnancy outcome and infant mortality. The Community Evaluation is one component of the local evaluation of Baltimore's Healthy Start Program. Relying on in-depth ethnographic and qualitative research as well as survey % methodology, the community evaluation describes the relation between the program and the target neighborhoods, including the role that Healthy Start plays in contributing to a process of positive social and behavioral change conducive to improved rates of infant mortality. In addition to describing longitudinal change in neighborhoods throughout the life of the program, the community evaluation provides on-going feedback regarding issues of community norms, support and acceptance of the program by neighborhood residents to Healthy Start staff to facilitate the success of the program. Map 1 : Baltimore City Healthy Start Target Areas The Use of Neiyhborhood Ma~~inin_~ i  Comrnunitv Evaluation; The community evaluation of Baltimore Healthy Start uses a participatory research approach referred to in the literature as "community diagnosisu2" and represents an attempt to triangulate qualitative ethnographic methods and quantitative methods in a systematic research process. Building on the work done by Nichter (1984) in India on "project community diagnosis'* we are applying it to a program evaluation context in the U.S. Data are collected using "rapid assessment procedures" (RAP) as described by Scrimshaw and Hurtado6, and includes such research methods as neighborhood mapping, key informant and ethnographic interviewing, as well as focus groups and the use of primary and secondary sources of data on neighborhood and residents characteristics. The inclusion of community residents as part of the evaluation team is a key feature of this evaluation. The framing of evaluation questions, data collection and data interpretation are conducted with the participation of the neighborhood residents serving on the community evaluation team. Neighborhood mapping has been used extensively in developing countries as well as industrialized countries in a process of needs assessment for program planning. Experience in India7 using participatory mapping methods have shown that even maps crudely drawn on the ground can depict detailed information from villagers on locations of homes, locations of pregnant women, persons with handicaps, malnourished children as well as social information such as household caste. In developed countries, such as the U.K., desktop mapping combined with geographic information systems containing census data has enabled community nursing professionals to identify high risk areas where their attention is most needed8. Little has been done to incorporate neighborhood mapping in the evaluation of public health program activities. Perhaps this is due in part to the emphasis in programs on change at the individual level. For programs that seek to bring about social and physical change within a locale, such as recent efforts toward "neighborhood transformation", the same methods used in baseline needs assessment can be used to document and describe change over time. In addition, context related factors depicted in neighborhood mapping can be useful in showing how individual level change of program participants may vary with characteristics of the residential environment. The community evaluation of Healthy Start hypothesizes that women living in high risk neighborhoods (defined as census block groups with high rates of poor physical conditions such as vacant or boarded houses, liquor stores, etc.) will experience (1) poorer pregnancy outcomes and (2) lower rates of recruitment into and participation in Healthy Start activities. This paper will report on the process and results of the mapping of the physical characteristics of Baltimore Healthy Start's Target Area A. Conce~tual Framework; The community diagnosis approach provides a useful process for exploring the physical, social and cultural context of community-based programs and the problems they address. What it does not provide is a conceptual framework for determining what aspects of the context are relevant to the program or the problem. Relying on Whitehead's (1984) "Cultural Systems Paradigm" (CSP)9 the community evaluation examined a myriad of factors that may directly or indirectly affect infant mortality and pregnancy outcome. The categories of the CSP of interest to the community diagnosis were adapted into a conceptual framework depicted in Figure 1. Page 3 Figurel: Conceptual Framework: "The Neighborhood Milieu" Social Norms & Culture Idea Systems Behavioral Systems . - . . . . . . .  Social Organization Social Systems History & Change Physical Environment Individual Factors Maternal Characteristics Maternal Health Behaviors The conceptual framework defines broad domains of individual and neighborhood level factors that can contribute to such adverse pregnancy outcomes as low and very low birth weight, preterm delivery and late or no entry into prenatal care. At the neighborhood level, the three broad domains include 1) neighborhood physical characteristics, 2) social norms and cultural features, and 3) the social organization of the neighborhood including local manifestations of wider socio- economic and political trends. Of particular concern in this paper are the physical characteristics of the neighborhood and their relevance to pregnancy related health and behavioral outcomes and to issues of program implementation (such as recruitment and participation rates). This domain is assessed through a process of physical mapping of the target areas. The purpose of the neighborhood mapping component is as follows: to provide more in-depth description of the target area than can be obtained through survey, census or statistical data; to identify neighborhood physical, social, economic and political features that may contribute to poor pregnancy outcomes and collect baseline measures of these features so that appropriate interventions can be designed both in the current program and in future efforts; to identify high risk neighborhoods within the target area and to link information on environmental conditions to program participants; and to document changes in target neighborhood conditions over time as part of the overall community evaluation. Physical characteristics of the neighborhood to be mapped were selected based upon issues and themes generated by residents in focus group discussions and plausible mechanisms by which they might be related to infant mortality and other poor pregnancy outcomes. In addition, local institutions, services and resources which may be of relevance to program implementation were mapped to assist in program development activities1'. The research conducted in the neighborhood mapping portion of the community diagnosis attempts to explore characteristics of the neighborhood environment that may be related to infant mortality and/or poor pregnancy outcomes such as low birth weight and pre-tern delivery, and/or related to participation in Healthy Start's programs and services. Each of the variables to be included in the neighborhood mapping process relates to infant mortality and poor pregnancy outcome in one of three ways: 1) indicates a direct health hazard to the mother or infant; 2) indicates an indirect health hazard mediated by stress; 3) affects behavior which increases risk of poor pregnancy outcome. Table 2 shows some of the physical characteristics of neighborhoods studied in the community diagnosis and neighborhood mapping along with the possible mechanisms by which they are related to infant mortality and poor pregnancy outcome, or to Healthy Start participation. Page 5 TABLE 2: PHYSICAL CONDITIONS OF HEALTHY START NEIGHBORHOODS A .  POSSIBLE MECHANISMS BY WHICH THEY DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY AFFECT PREGNANCY OUTCONlES Page 6 PHYSICAL CONDITIONS Vacant Houses Churches Businesses Liquor Licenses POSSIBLE MECHANISMS Living in an area with a high concentration of vacant houses can expose individuals to direct health risks (rodents, fires, crime and violence), and indirect health risks (stress and lack of social supp~r t l~ .~ )  which may effect pregnancy, birth weight and infant mortality. High concentrations of vacanct houses may also decrease the likelihood that women leave their homes to go to the NHSC for activities. Churches have been shown to serve as buffers to the stress of living in poverty, in that they provide much needed social support to members.I4 Churches may also be actively involved in addressing local social concerns. Alternatively, their presence may just mean that rents are cheap and codes are not enforced, making it easier to locate in the area. The constituency of the church is another factor, in that many urban churches have members from outside the community or outside the city who may have little commitment to the neighborhood of the church. Availability of employment opportunities can serve as a supportive mechanism in the environment, depending on the number and types of jobs available to local residents. Lax requirements for zoning may place more businesses in poor residential neighborhoods. Presence of businesses with liquor licenses may affect the availability and use of alcohol. Alcohol and other substance use that interferes with proper nutrition is a risk factor for poor pregnancy outcome. Excessive prenatal exposure to alcohol can lead to fetal alcohol syndrome. Lax requirements for zoning may place more liquor in poor residential neighborhoods. Liquor stores may also be hangouts for people that can be threatening to the neighbors, affecting their ability to leave their homes and interact with their neighbors. These conditions may also effect the likelihood that women leave their homes to go to the NHSC for activities. Contexts that are perceived as threatening may also influence the extent to which recruitment staff and outreach staff provide services to women in theseareas. Data Collection and Geocoding; Data for the neighborhood mapping were collected during neighborhood walk-throughs using c'ommunity residents who recorded detailed observational data on every block, street and alley in the target area. Simple data collection forms were created that provided space for the observers to record addresses and descriptions for each category of interest. In addition to documenting the overall condition of the blocks, attention was given to the following specific categories of data: vacantlboarded housing, businesses, churches, schools, recreational centers and parks, service providers, clubs, and descriptive data on sanitation conditions. Data were also obtained on clients in the Healthy Start program including the addresses of clients recruited into the program, their degree of participation, and those lost to follow-up. These data were used to examine the geographic distribution of clients enrolled, and clients lost to follow- up and to link client participation to the physical characteristics of the environment that were observed in the neighborhood walk-through. Routinely available secondary data: Other data were obtained from state, city and U.S. Census sources. Housing inspection data (including violations) were obtained from the Baltimore City Department of Housing and Community Development. Liquor license data were obtained from the Baltimore City Board of Liquor License Commissioners. Birth certificate data containing information on pregnancy outcome were obtained from Maryland Vital Records. Geocoding of data: All of the data collected for the physical mapping of the Healthy Start Target Areas were geocoded using the desktop mapping software MapInfo 3.0. Geocoding refers to the assigning of geographic indicators to each record of a data file. In most cases, physical features of a neighborhood were given a street address which could be geocoded as a precise latitude and longitude, permitting their representation as a point on a map (e.g. playground at 1650 N. Carey Street). In addition, census tracts and census block groups were assigned to each entry, so data could be aggregated at these geographic levels. Maps generated for the neighborhood mapping are of two basic types, point data maps and thematic maps. Point data maps show the locations of specific neighborhood features such as vacant houses, licensed liquor stores, businesses and churches. Point data maps are helpful in describing the specific context in which program participants live, including detailed descriptions of the street and block. Thematic maps aggregate and present data in the form of counts, rates, percentages, etc. across a geographic space such as census tracts or census block groups. Thematic mapping permits the displaying of data that are only available in aggregate form based upon geographic region (such as census data). It also permits visual comparison of smaller geographic units within the target area. Point data can also be presented on top of thematic maps, such as when program participants are presented on a map . depicting level of neighborhood physical risks. Page 7 Factor analvsis of neighborhood physical features: Rates of physical conditions by census block groups were factor analyzed to determine if the characteristics "hang together" in a single factor. Using SPSS for Windows, the physical characteristics for each census block groups were analyzed using principal components factor analysis and a varirnax rotation. Factor scores for each census block group were saved as variables to pennit the creation of thematic maps representing different levels of scoring of the physical risk conditions in the neighborhood. e Neighborhood Physical Context of Baltimore Healthy Start; Target Area A of Baltimore's Healthy Start Program is located in the heart of West Baltimore. The area is bounded by North Avenue, Pennsylvania Avenue, Fremont Avenue, Franklin Street and Pulaski Street (see Map 2). Map 3 presents combined data on vacantlboarded houses, churches and businesses. During the time frame when data on vacant houses were collected, a total of 947 vacant/boarded houses were identified. Houses were identified as vacant if they were boarded or obviously unoccupied and not advertised as for sale or rent. The data were collected in the summer and fall of 1993 and are subject to continual change. With new funding available for renovation and demolition, many of the identified houses are either no longer vacant or have been demolished. Other houses have become vacant since the time of the data collection. Nevertheless, these data will serve as the best baseline indicator of vacant housing in the target area that is available. Vacant housing: Residents complained of the vacant houses during focus  group^^^.'^ because they are targets for illegal dumping, rodent infestation and illegal drug activities ("stash houses"). They also pose a hazard for children who may venture in to play. The presence of vacant houses in a neighborhood poses both a direct and indirect effect on the health of residents by exposing residents to hazards and by contributing to the stress of urban living." Vacant and boarded homes are distributed throughout the target area but not in a uniform manner. Pockets of most densely concentrated vacant houses are apparent on Map 3.  A band of streets near the middle and southern sections of the target area seems to be the most concentrated areas for vacant housing. Some areas are free of vacant housing because they contain newly developed housing units or public housing units managed by the Baltimore City Housing Authority. The area in the northwest section of the target area has the fewest vacant and boarded houses. Map 4 shows the density of vacant houses by census block group. Density was calculated by dividing the total number of vacant houses within each block group by the total number of housing units within the block group. This method of calculation actually dilutes the density of the most concentrated areas, because these areas also have the greatest number of rental units. Since the denominator is total housing units (rather than total number of houses/buildings), areas in which houses are more likely to be broken into several rental units will have inflated denominators and reduced overall densities. Map 4 shows a strong west to east gradient in density of vacant housis, with density increasing as we move east toward downtown. Page 8 Map 2: Healthy Start Target Area A Franklin St Map 3: Vacant houses, churches and businesses W N A v  Franklin St 