Clean Clothes Campaign

English

DigitalCommons@ILR

Home News Get involved Safety Living Wage Behind
The Scenes Issues Resources About us
Share in WhatsApp
The National Peoples’ Tribunal for living wages and decent working conditions of
garment workers continued today at Kannada Sahitya Parishad, with much rigour
and conviction with the participation of experts, union leaders, brand
representatives and workers.
Minimum Wages  for garment workers should be fixed at Rs. 12,000
Experts testify that minimum wage presently calculated grossly
inadequate
Major clothing brands and garment manufacturers condemned for wage
theft
Unions point to policy deficit which is contributing to low wages
Experts and unions show how nature of garment industry is continuing to
keep workers in the cycle of poverty
In a short film on the lives of garment workers’ experiences, one of the issues
highlighted was that unfortunately workers still consider sexual harassment
as a norm, as it is tacitly condoned by those who are responsible to monitor
and prevent it. The harsh environment of the factory does not enable workers
to share or communicate these issues with each other. If it is considered a
norm, there is no opposition to sexual harassement.
Meenakshi Sundaram from (CITU) highlighted that the calculation of minimum wages took into account only food,
clothing, shelter and a partial consideration for health and education. But in the current climate of privatization of
these services, the minimum wage does not compensate adequately.  This has resulted in standardizing an
inadequate wage for living. Without a strong process of unionization of workers, workers cannot achieve a decent
wage.
Women workers in India
Human Rights Trial on Garment Industry Concludes — Clean Clothes ... http://www.cleanclothes.org/news/2012/11/24/human-rights-trial-on-gar...
1 of 3 4/18/2016 3:14 PM
Jeroen Merk, Senior Researcher, Clean Clothes Campaign, Netherlands stated that brands started social audits
and adopted codes of conduct in the 90s, but since then, the picture continues to look grim, which reveals how
brands made little efforts to address issues and concerns of workers.
Vijay Bhaskar, Asst. Professor from Madras Institute of Development Studies (MIDS) suggested that the
Government has not done enough to assist the garment industry to become more competitive internationally. Utsa
Patnaik, member of the Jury responded by saying that the Government is in fact attacking the industry by
destructive policies such as making export of cotton easy, which led to the suicides by handloom weavers much
before farmers’ suicides in India.
V Prakash, Supreme Court Advocate, Chennai shared how the labour department conspires with the employers
to make it difficult for workers to form unions. He also informed the jury that the Supreme Court has challenged
the practice of affixing CCTV cameras to monitor workers in factories which invades their right to privacy.
Ashim Roy, General Secretary of NTUI argued that there is a policy deficit from the Government to ensure living
wage paid by industries. He said that the Government has left it to the market to fix wages but given the high
unemployment and underemployment it is impossible for the labour market to provide for a decent living wage.
The wages should be such that people can get out of poverty and not subsist within it.
The worker gets caught in a vicious cycle by working long hours and with such low wages. Getting out of it seems
almost impossible without some changes in the current system. There is no scope for intellectual and/or physical
development for the workers. Since they are unable to send their children to schools or give them nutritious food,
their children are susceptible to get caught in the same loop.
Arvind Narrain from Alternative Law Forum and Vikas Barnwal, from Society for Labour and Development made a
submission from the people’s advocacy group. They summarized and highlighted that living wage is insufficient
for workers to support their families. No bonus, forced overtime, lack of PF, no medical expenses covered –
makes the situation worse.
Secondly, wage theft through underpayment, non-payment, late payment and illegal deduction was also
discussed. They pointed to the poor working conditions in factories  – where they have to forgo breakfast, suffer
during menstruation, child care and they also suffer subsequent health problems like TB, asthma etc. Further,
they reiterated that workers are not being treated with dignity – they are verbally abused and insulted. Human
dignity is at stake. There are also high levels of gender discrimination in factories. If a worker dresses up well,
lewd comments are passed on her. One of the workers’managlsutra was cut off, and many of the workers’ have
been physically abused. In addition to this, the impossibility of forming unions makes the situation worse. They are
unable to collectively withstand these attacks. Article 21 and 43 of the Indian Constitution were used as reference
points to highlight these issues.
Following the two day national tribunal, the jury will deliver a verdict on the 25  of November at Unnati Auditorium.
The verdict will encapsulate the concerns emerging from both days on issues of wage theft, low wages, sexual
harassment and working conditions of garment workers. The jury will present recommendations to brands, unions
and government officials in order to address issues raised at the tribunal.
The jury will deliver the verdict on 25  November on Unnati Auditorium, Pampa Mahakavi Raste, Shankar Puram,
Next to National College Swimming Pool followed by a question and answer session with the gathering and the
media. The verdict will present recommendations to brands, unions and government officials in order to address
th
th
Human Rights Trial on Garment Industry Concludes — Clean Clothes ... http://www.cleanclothes.org/news/2012/11/24/human-rights-trial-on-gar...
2 of 3 4/18/2016 3:14 PM
Mission
How We Work
Local CCC's
The Issues
FAQ
Get Active
Stay Informed
Why a living wage?
Asia Floor Wage
Sign the Living Wage petition
Contact Information
For the Press
About this site
issues raised at the tribunal.
Filed under: India living wage
Human Rights Trial on Garment Industry Concludes — Clean Clothes ... http://www.cleanclothes.org/news/2012/11/24/human-rights-trial-on-gar...
3 of 3 4/18/2016 3:14 PM


Human Rights Trial on Garment Industry Concludes

https://digitalcommons.ilr.cornell.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4498&amp;context=globaldocs

Human Rights Trial on Garment Industry Concludes

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

DigitalCommons@ILR