Reduced extracellular matrix accumulation in the sclera of myopic eyes leads to increased ocular extensibility and is related to reduced levels of scleral transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β). The current study investigated the impact of this extracellular environment on scleral cell phenotype and cellular biomechanical characteristics. Scleral cell phenotype was investigated in vivo in a mammalian model of myopia using the myofibroblast marker, α-smooth muscle actin (α-SMA). In eyes developing myopia α-SMA levels were increased, suggesting increased numbers of contractile myofibroblasts, and decreased in eyes recovering from myopia. To understand the factors regulating this change in scleral phenotype, the competing roles of TGF-β and mechanical stress were investigated in scleral cells cultured in three-dimensional collagen gels. All three mammalian isoforms of TGF-β altered scleral cell phenotype to produce highly contractile, α-SMA-expressing myofibroblasts (TGF-β3 > TGF-β2 > TGF-β1). Exposure of cells to the reduced levels of TGF-β found in the sclera in myopia produced decreased cell-mediated contraction and reduced α-SMA expression. These findings are contrary to the in vivo gene expression data. However, when cells were exposed to both the increased stress and the reduced levels of TGF-β found in myopia, increased α-SMA expression was observed, replicating in vivo findings. These results show that although reduced scleral TGF-β is a major contributor to the extracellular matrix remodeling in the myopic eye, it is the resulting increase in scleral stress that dominates the competing TGF-β effect, inducing increased α-SMA expression and, hence, producing a larger population of contractile cells in the myopic eye