For a fermionic quantum field theory in d=1+1 dimensions, there is a subtle
difference between summing over spin structures and gauging (β1)F. If the
gravitational anomaly vanishes mod 16, then both operations are equivalent and
yield a bosonic theory. But if the gravitational anomaly only vanishes mod 8,
then only gauging (β1)F is allowed, and the result is a fermionic theory.
Our goal is to understand in detail how this happens, despite the fact (β1)F
is defined in terms of shifting the spin structure, which would na\"ively
suggest that both operations are equivalent. We do this from three
perspectives: an abstract view in terms of anomalies, explicit CFT
calculations, and a Symmetry TFT perspective. To conclude, we illustrate our
results using the heterotic string and the famous self-triality of 8
Majorana-Weyl fermions.Comment: 44 pages, 9 figure