Prastiya Indra Gunawan, Prastiya

Universitas Airlangga Repository

4/29/23, 7:03 AM Gmail - Fw: [CEP] Ask for review of the manuscript (CEP-21-197)https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/?ik=ac3cfdff47&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f:1758642065182226475&simpl=msg-f:175864206518222… 1/2Lintang Qusnul Budi Setiawati <lintangqusnulbs@gmail.com>Fw: [CEP] Ask for review of the manuscript (CEP-21-197)1 messagePrastiya Indra Gunawan <prastiya_ig@yahoo.co.id> Fri, Feb 24, 2023 at 12:02 AMTo: Lintang Qusnul Budi Setiawati <lintangqusnulbs@gmail.com>----- Pesan yang Diteruskan -----Dari: Clin Exp Pediatr <office@e-cep.org>Kepada: Prastiya Indra Gunawan <prastiya_ig@yahoo.co.id>Terkirim: Senin, 27 September 2021 pukul 03.05.08 WIBJudul: [CEP] Ask for review of the manuscript (CEP-21-197)[Clinical and Experimental Pediatrics] Request for manuscript review : 1stSender : Clinical and Experimental PediatricsRecipient : Prastiya Indra GunawanManuscript ID : CEP-21-197Title :Evaluating the importance of clinical manifestation and laboratory parametersassociated with progression to severe dengue in children: a systematic reviewand meta-analysisReview Period : September 19, 2021 ~ October 04, 2021Comment :Dear Dr. Prastiya Indra Gunawan :You have been assigned as a reviewer of Manuscript I.D. (CEP-21-197) entitled"Evaluating the importance of clinical manifestation and laboratory parametersassociated with progression to severe dengue in children: a systematic review and meta-analysis" submitted to the Clinical and Experimental Pediatrics. We would like to requestyou to complete your review in period of review.You are kindly requested to visit the journal website (http://submit.e-cep.org), and log inwith your I.D. and password, and go to the Reviewer Center. Please read the reviewerinstructions of the journal and proceed as guided.We would like to remind you to scrutinize into reference contents, and encourage thecitation of up-to date informations in national journals including the Clinical andExperimental Pediatrics.This letter is to just reminder you of review request, Please reply as soon as possible ifpossible.Thank you for your dedication to the Clinical and Experimental PediatricsSincerely,Man Yong Han, M.D.Editor-in-Chief4/29/23, 7:03 AM Gmail - Fw: [CEP] Ask for review of the manuscript (CEP-21-197)https://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/?ik=ac3cfdff47&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f:1758642065182226475&simpl=msg-f:175864206518222… 2/2Clinical and Experimental Pediatrics Editorial Office#1606, Seocho World Officetel, 19 Seoun-ro, Seocho-gu, Seoul 06732, KoreaTEL : +82-2-3473-7305FAX : +82-2-3473-7307E-mail : office@e-cep.orgWebsite : http://submit.e-cep.org/#1606, Seocho World Officetel, 19 Seoun-ro, Seocho-gu, Seoul 06732, KoreaCopyright© The Korean Pediatric Society.4/29/23, 7:02 AM Gmail - Fw: [Shared assessment] Manuscript ID [CEP-21-197] Letter of decision 1st - Major revisionhttps://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/?ik=ac3cfdff47&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f:1758642184812489980&simpl=msg-f:175864218481248… 1/3Lintang Qusnul Budi Setiawati <lintangqusnulbs@gmail.com>Fw: [Shared assessment] Manuscript ID [CEP-21-197] Letter of decision 1st -Major revision1 messagePrastiya Indra Gunawan <prastiya_ig@yahoo.co.id> Fri, Feb 24, 2023 at 12:04 AMTo: Lintang Qusnul Budi Setiawati <lintangqusnulbs@gmail.com>----- Pesan yang Diteruskan -----Dari: Clin Exp Pediatr <office@e-cep.org>Kepada: Prastiya Indra Gunawan <prastiya_ig@yahoo.co.id>Terkirim: Kamis, 21 Oktober 2021 pukul 09.02.41 WIBJudul: [Shared assessment] Manuscript ID [CEP-21-197] Letter of decision 1st - Major revision[Clinical and Experimental Pediatrics] Review result : 1stDate sent : October 21, 2021Date Decisioned : October 21, 2021Manuscript ID : CEP-21-197Title :Evaluating the importance of clinical manifestation and laboratory parametersassociated with progression to severe dengue in children: a systematic reviewand meta-analysisReview result : Major revision   (Revision Period : ~ 2021-12-18)Comments toAuthors(Editorial Office) :Dear Indra SandinirwanThank you for submitting your manuscript titled ¡°Evaluating the importance ofclinical manifestation and laboratory parameters associated with progression tosevere dengue in children: a systematic review and meta-analysis¡± [CEP-21-197] to the Clinical and Experimental Pediatrics.The reports of the referees have been received and are placed at the end ofthis email for your reference.As indicated by the comments, the reviewers feel that the manuscript requiresextensive revisions. Therefore, at this point, we cannot commit to a finaldecision, as that depends on your revision of the manuscript. Please ensurethat the revised version submitted by you incorporates the suggested changes.You must thoroughly and satisfactorily address each comment made by thereviewers in a point-by-point format, using the following process:1) Download the point-by-point response template.    CEP_ Point-by-point response.docx2) Copy each ¡®comment to the author¡± made by the reviewer.3) Enter your reply directly underneath each comment.You may then upload the replies, along with both versions of the revisedmanuscript, as follows:1) The ¡®clean¡¯ version of the manuscript, using the file designation¡®Manuscript¡¯;2) The version of the manuscript with ¡®tracked changes,¡¯ in which you have4/29/23, 7:02 AM Gmail - Fw: [Shared assessment] Manuscript ID [CEP-21-197] Letter of decision 1st - Major revisionhttps://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/?ik=ac3cfdff47&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f:1758642184812489980&simpl=msg-f:175864218481248… 2/3used the ¡°Track Changes¡± tool on Word. Save the file as ¡®Track (for review)¡¯;3) The ¡®Response to Comments¡¯ file containing the point-by-point replies.While submitting your revised manuscript, you will be able to respond to thecomments made by the reviewer(s). In order to help expedite the processing ofthe revised manuscript, please be as specific as possible in your responses tothe reviewer(s).Key Message (mandatory)CEP cordially requests that you submit a key message of up to 70 words inlength summarizing the core concept of your manuscript.Graphical Abstract (optional)You are also strongly encouraged to submit a graphical abstract. For detailedinformation about the graphical abstract requirements, please refer to theGraphical abstracts section at http://submit.e-cep.org/authors/authors.php.If you have any questions, please feel free to contact the editorial office atoffice@e-cep.org.Please note that your revised manuscript will most likely be re-reviewed by theoriginal reviewers and that no guarantee can be made regarding itsacceptance.Since we always try to ensure timely publication of manuscripts submitted tothe Clinical and Experimental Pediatrics, your revised manuscript should beuploaded as soon as possible. However, if you are unable to submit yourrevision within the stipulated time period, we may have to consider your paperas a new submission.The deadline for submission of the revised version is 18-December-2021.Please follow the instructions provided in the ¡°Author Center¡± section andupload the responses and the revised manuscript online at http://submit.e-cep.org.Once again, we thank you for submitting your manuscript to the Clinical andExperimental Pediatrics. We look forward to receiving your revision.Best regardsMan Yong HanEditor-in-ChiefClinical and Experimental PediatricsCrosscheck Report file : cross_file_20210219.pdfComments:Reviewer#1Although the topics is interesting, otherwise it is a usual topics that alreadypublished by many authors. It lack of novelty. Beside, the plagiarism checker isup to 41%. The discussion does not describe the entire significant factor thatassociated to Dengue severity. The authors should describe it more depth. Itmean the authors should revise the manuscript.Reviewer#2In this paper, the authors have performed a very extensive systematic literaturereview and meta-analysis on risk factors for severe dengue fever in childrenusing appropriate methodologies. However, it is unfortunate that the results ofthis study are not very different from the contents of previous similar studies orguidelines, so there is little new content.4/29/23, 7:02 AM Gmail - Fw: [Shared assessment] Manuscript ID [CEP-21-197] Letter of decision 1st - Major revisionhttps://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/?ik=ac3cfdff47&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f:1758642184812489980&simpl=msg-f:175864218481248… 3/3In addition, the following areas are of particular concern:1. Some studies included in the meta-analysis have too wide a 95% CI forspecific factors, which raises doubts about the quality and validity of thestudies.2. Some risk factors, particularly test findings, are too vague or highlyheterogeneous among the included studies.In conclusion, I recommend that the authors reselect the studies based onclearer and more restrictive criteria and proceed with the analysis.Comments from Reviewer 1:Although the topics is interesting, otherwise it is a usual topics that alreadypublished by many authors. It lack of novelty. Beside, the plagiarism checker isup to 41%. The discussion does not describe the entire significant factor thatassociated to Dengue severity. The authors should describe it more depth. Itmean the authors should revise the manuscript.Comments from Reviewer 2:In this paper, the authors have performed a very extensive systematic literaturereview and meta-analysis on risk factors for severe dengue fever in childrenusing appropriate methodologies. However, it is unfortunate that the results ofthis study are not very different from the contents of previous similar studies orguidelines, so there is little new content.In addition, the following areas are of particular concern:1. Some studies included in the meta-analysis have too wide a 95% CI forspecific factors, which raises doubts about the quality and validity of thestudies.2. Some risk factors, particularly test findings, are too vague or highlyheterogeneous among the included studies.In conclusion, I recommend that the authors reselect the studies based onclearer and more restrictive criteria and proceed with the analysis.Man Yong Han, M.D.Editor-in-ChiefClinical and Experimental Pediatrics Editorial Office#1606, Seocho World Officetel, 19 Seoun-ro, Seocho-gu, Seoul 06732, KoreaTEL : +82-2-3473-7305FAX : +82-2-3473-7307E-mail : office@e-cep.orgWebsite : http://submit.e-cep.org/#1606, Seocho World Officetel, 19 Seoun-ro, Seocho-gu, Seoul 06732, KoreaCopyright© The Korean Pediatric Society.

Evaluating the importance of clinical manifestation and laboratory parameters

associated with progression to severe dengue in children: a systematic review

and meta-analysis

https://repository.unair.ac.id/125790/1/Reviewer_Clinical%20and%20Experimental%20Pediatrics%20Journal_Prastiya%20Indra%20Gunawan.pdf

Evaluating the importance of clinical manifestation and laboratory parameters associated with progression to severe dengue in children: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

Universitas Airlangga Repository