Milota, Michael R.

Reeb, James E.

Western Dry Kiln Association

Western Dry Kiln Association. Meeting (50th : 1999 : Portland, Or.)

Undetermined

ScholarsArchive@OSU

MOISTURE CONTENT BY THE OVEN-DRYMETHOD FOR INDUSTRIAL TESTINGJim ReebMike MilotaOregon State UniversityCorvallis, ORThe oven-dry test, combined with the prong or stress test, is a very useful toolfor the kiln operator to have at his or her disposal. Often the kiln operator is asked todefend the accuracy of moisture meter measurements or a customer simply does notbelieve moisture meter readings. In other situations, the operator may want to verifymeter readings for his own piece of mind. For situations in which moisture meters willgive the same information more quickly and with little effort, then they are the tools ofchoice. However, it is important to always rememberthat the oven-dry moisture contentis what the meters are trying to estimate.Various methods for measuring the moisture content of wood are described bythe American Society for Testing and Materials in publication ASTM D4442. Theseinclude two oven-dry methods, a distillation, and what the standard calls other methods.In the solid wood products industry, we most often define moisture content ona dry basis. This means that the moisture content is defined asWeight of water MC -		 x 100%	 (1)Weight of woodThe weight of the wood does not include any water. It is the weight of the piece after itis oven-dry and all water has been removed. The weight of the water is the differencein the weight of the piece before and after drying. Therefore, when the test is done weuse the following formula to calculate moisture content.Initial weight - Oven - dry weight MC -		 x 100%	 (2)Oven - dry weightFormulae one and two are the same, one is conceptual, two is what you put into thecalculator or spreadsheet.Equipment Needed for the Oven-dry TestTo do the oven-dry test one needs a saw, oven, and scale. The total cost ofthese items can vary and the size and quality purchased should be dependent on howmuch they will be used. If the test is to be a regular part of quality control, goodequipment will have a short payback in accuracy, time, and ease of use. The selectionWDKA	 66	 May, 1999MC =126 - 109x 100 = 15.6%109of the equipment needs to be thought out carefully because the cost will be $500 to$2000, depending on what is purchased.Oven RequirementsOvens used for the test are usually electrically heated and sit on a counter top.The outside dimensions vary in size from 1'w x 1'd x 2'h on up. At the university, ourlargest oven is about 6' x 4' x 4' and when we need something larger we set ourlaboratory kiln to the correct conditions to create an "oven" in which we can oven-drywhole boards. Companies such as VWR, Blue-M, and Fischer Scientific sell ovens. Theoven needs to be able to attain and hold a temperature of 217°F (103°C). This is ratherimportant for an accurate test. A single hole or vent in the oven provides a way formoisture to get out and fresh air to get in. The size of the hole is usually adjustable. Theset-point dials on most ovens are not very accurate, so it is a good idea to have anthermometer mounted in the oven to assure that 217°F is reached and held. Someovens have a second hole for mounting a thermometer so it can be read without openingthe oven door.Scale RequirementsThe accuracy required for the scale depends on the size of the samples to bedried and accuracy to which moisture content is to be determined. It is easiest to seethis by example. Let's suppose that a piece of wood weighs 125.6 grams initially and109.4 grams after being oven-dried. If a scale is only accurate the nearest gram, theIf the scale is accurate to the nearest 0.1 g, thenMC = 125.6 - 109.4 x 100 = 14.8%109.4In general, the scale should read to 1 part in 1000 for the oven-dry weight of the sampleto give accuracy to the nearest 0.1% moisture content. This should be adequate for anymill measurement and, in fact, is as accurate as we ever try to get at the university. So,if the oven-dry sample weight will always be more than 1000 g (2.2 Ibs), the a scale thatreads to 1 gram is very adequate. In general, we have found that a scale that reads tothe nearest 0.1 g is what a mill needs for small samples.The range or weighing capacity of the scale needs to be adequate to hold thesample. This often creates a problem because scales with range large enough for bigsamples do not have the required accuracy to do small samples. For mills that need toweigh large (3' long) samples and small samples (1" to 4" long), it is often cheaper to buytwo scales rather than to try to find a high capacity scale with high resolution. A scalewill cost from $50 for a manual triple beam balance, $200 to $1500 for an electronicWDKA	 67	 May, 1999balance with adequate resolution. Beware of good deals. We have one scale at the labwith great specifications in the catalog, but very poor stability.Two other points about scales. Lock them down so the drug dealers don't stealthem. Be careful about overloading them, especially electronic scales when they are notplugged in.SawA radial arm saw is needed to cross cut the samples to an appropriate length forthe oven and scale. In the short-term, a hand-held circular saw can be used. A bandsaw may also be needed if shell-core or prong tests are to be done.Performing the TestIt is simple to do an oven-dry test, but the devil is in the details. The test isperformed by cutting the sample to be tested, weighing it, drying it to a constant weight,reweighing, and doing the calculation. Now the details.Sample SelectionThe samples need to be representative of the lot of wood from which they aretaken. Thus, they should come from throughout a pile or shipment, not just the top orsides. After a board is chosen, the sample should be cut at least 2 feet from the end ofthe board because wood picks up and loses moisture very rapidly through the end grain.The samples should either be weighed immediately after cutting or each sampleshould be stored in a separate plastic bag. After the initial weight is obtained, noparticular precautions for storage need to be observed and the sample can be oven-driedat your convenience.WeighingEither a data sheet with sample numbers should be used or sometimes theweight can be written directly on the sample. Once the initial weight is taken and thesample begins to dry, there is no going back so it's important to keep a good record.DryingThe time to dry is typically about 24 hours for a one- to two-inch sample cut fromdimension lumber or boards. The correct method is to dry to a constant weight, meaningthat the weight change over a four-hour period is less than twice the sensitivity of thescale. This means less than about 0.2 grams for a 100 gram sample.Do not add wet samples to the oven when other samples are almost dry. Waterwill evaporate from the wet samples and be picked up by the drier ones causing an errorwhen they are weighed due to a temporary increase in moisture content.WDKA	 68	 May, 1999If the oven temperature is too low, the relative humidity in the oven will not below enough. The ambient air contains moisture and raising its temperature simply lowersits relative humidity causing a lower equilibrium moisture content. For example, if theambient air is at 70°F and 50% relative humidity, the relative humidity in the oven willbe about 1% with an equilibrium moisture content of about 0.1 to 0.2%. On a humid daythe samples won't dry as much, but at 217°F the variability due to ambient conditionsis minimal. An oven in a humid tropical country will give results that are within 0.3 or0.4% moisture content of and oven in a cold dry climate as long as 217°F is used.If the oven temperature is too high, some of the wood components can be drivenoff. When these are counted as moisture, the indicated moisture content is too high.Do not overload an oven. Good air circulation around the samples is needed toreduce the risk of fire.CalculationIf there are a number of samples, I prefer to use a spreadsheet to calculatemoisture content rather than a calculator. It is easy to go back and check for errors indata entry. After calculating a value, make sure it sense compared to what youmeasured. If using a spread sheet, put in some simple known values to check thecalculation. For example, if you enter an initial weight of 150 grams and a final weightof 100 grams, your calculation should give a 50% moisture content.Other variations on the oven-dry testThe oven-dry test works well for obtaining the moisture content of a sample, butit can also be used to obtain information about the moisture distribution within a pieceof wood. For example, samples can be cut every foot along the length of a board todetermine how moisture content changes or a piece of wood can be sliced to determinethe moisture profile through the thickness. A shell / core moisture content test is avariation on the latter. Here, the outer shell of the sample is sawn away from the innercore and the two parts are weighed and dried separately (Figure 1). This might be usefulfor export lumber when a customer specifies a certain moisture content at the center ofa piece.FIGURE 1. End grain view of wood ovendried to measure shell and core moisturecontent.WDKA	69	May, 1999Practical Examples of the Oven-dry TestEach year the Forest Research Laboratory at Oregon State University fieldsthousands of questions from the general public on all aspects of wood productsmanufacturing. The answer to many of these comes back to moisture content. For theremainder of the presentation we would like to share some of the problems we haveseen over the past year and discuss solutions.Comparison of MC by the Oven Dry and Desiccant Methods for ShavingsMoisture content of wood shavings was determined for three western species:Douglas-fir, western red cedar and western juniper. According to ASTM D4442, ovendrying can drive volatile compounds out of some species of wood. When this occurs,the wood weighs less than if just the water had been removed. When the moisturecontent is calculated, the value is too high.Usually, the more odorous the wood, the more volatile compounds are present.Extractives give wood its color. Generally speaking, the darker or richer the color of thewood, the more extractives are in the wood. Some of these extractive compounds canalso be volatile and therefore driven from the wood when oven drying.Moisture content of Douglas-fir, western red cedar, and western juniper shavingswere calculated after samples were equalized at 9% and 12% equilibrium moisturecontent (EMC) conditions. Shaving samples were dried in an oven at 103°C + 3 ° andshaving samples were dried over a desiccant (calcium sulfate). Results are charted inFigures 2 and 3.FIGURE 2. Results of % MCcalculations for three Northwest speciesusing the OD and desiccant methods.Samples were equalized at EMCconditions of 9%.FIGURE 3. Results of % MCcalculations for three Northwest speciesusing the OD and desiccant methods.Samples were equalized at EMCconditions of 12%.WDKA	 70	 May, 1999For all samples the oven dry method resulted in a higher calculated moisture content.This varied from a low difference of 2.3% for Douglas-fir equalized at 12% EMCconditions to a high difference of 5.6% for Douglas-fir equalized at 9% EMC conditions.Since there was no pattern to the data, about the only conclusion we can makeis that the oven dry method may at times drive volatile compounds out of samples andtherefore cause too high of a moisture content to be calculated. This is probably not asmuch of a problem with lumber samples since they are many times thicker thanshavings.Importance of Understanding the Basis for MCA mill asked us to determine the moisture content of Douglas-fir sawmill andplaner mill wood chips. We did this by weighing samples and oven drying the samplesat a temperature of 103°C + 3 degrees and calculating the moisture content usingformula 2. Based on this we reported the values in the first line of Table 1.TABLE 1. Values of MC reported for wood residue. Each value is an average of threemeasurements.Sawmill Chips Planer Shavings% Moisture content 92.7 88.6% Bone dry 51.9 53.0After reporting the MC results the mill manager called and said we were way offwith these calculations. We told him how we calculated them and that's when We foundout what they really wanted to know. They wanted us to determine the % bone dry (BD)because that is how the pulp mill pays them for their chips. It was easy to recalculatebecause we use the same weights as when calculating moisture content:BD = Oven - dryweight • (100%)Green weightThe recalculated values are shown in the second line of Table 1. A chip van cancarry about 70 green tons of chips. At 50% BD, the pulp mill will pay for 35 BD tons ofchips. At 40% BD the pulp mill will only pay for 28 BD tons of chips. Chips are about$60/BD ton so the difference would be $420 for the van load of chips.These are reasonable values for Douglas-fir sawmill and planer mill chips. It isimportant to understand what people are asking. Sometimes they are not very clear onwhat they want or we hear something different than what they are really asking.Compare to moisture meter readingsMoisture meters are, of course, calibrated to the oven-dry standard. Whensomeone doubts their readings, we often get a few samples to oven-dry.(3)WDKA	 71	 May, 1999Radiata pine: A few years ago we used the oven-dry test to determine themoisture content of kiln-dried radiata pine in at a mill in New Zealand, at the port in NewZealand, at the port in the U.S., and at the secondary manufacturer in central Oregon.Because the test is so reproducible, we had high confidence that labs on both sides ofthe Pacific could obtain comparable results. A moisture meter could have been used,but then there are the questions of the calibration and usage by different people indifferent parts of the world. The was no substantial change in moisture content betweenNew Zealand and the U.S.In another small project with radiata pine we made the measurements shown inTable 2. The wood had been equilibrated long enough that one would not expect amoisture content difference from one side to the other. Yet, on ever piece but one,the pin-type meter read higher on the bark side of the board.TABLE 2. Moisture meter measurements on radiata pine.SamplePin-type Meter ReceivedWeightOven-dryWeightOven-dryMCPith side Bark side% % 9 g ok1 15.5 14.5 871.10 742.86 17.32 13.5 14.0 805.10 717.22 12.33 14.0 15.0 965.10 827.00 16.74 13.0 14.5 740.50 634.98 16.65 15.0 16.0 969.70 832.20 16.56 12.0 12.0 707.90 630.88 12.27 12.5 13.5 956.70 853.70 12.1Average 13.6 14.2 14.8Ponderosa pine: We often are asked to verify in-line moisture meter readingsby doing an oven-dry test. The mill will pass boards across the in-line meter, cut a two-foot sample out of the board from over the meter pad. This two-foot sample getswrapped in plastic and sent to OSU. It's very important that the piece not change weightor lose moisture from the time it crosses the pad until it is weighed. About 20 to 30samples make a good test. After receiving the samples, we weigh, oven-dry, andreweigh them. We usually use a hand-held meter on each piece as the pieces are beingweighed. In one case, the average of 30 samples was 14% for the in-line meter and18% by the oven-dry test. A customer who receives wood at a moisture content 4%higher (or lower for that matter) than ordered can expect problems if the wood ismanufactured into components such as furniture, door or window parts, and mill work.Conversely, if the meter error had been the other way, the mill is drying too much andit costs dryer time, energy, and wood degrade.Oregon white oak: Oregon white oak was being dried in a small kiln nearCorvallis. The kiln operators were having trouble believing that it could dry so slowly.The wood had been air dried to 20 to 25% moisture content prior to kiln drying and byday 13 of the schedule, they felt it should be dry. We suggested they use their meter ona few samples and bring them over to be oven dried. The results are shown in Table 3.WDKA	 72	 May, 199916014041 12042 100 -o 80 -a)1- 60 -a4020 -We repeated this test a week later and the meter reading were much closer to the oven-dry moisture content (in both cases meter correction factors were applied). Becausetheir target moisture content is seven percent, they decided not to worry about the meteraccuracy at higher moisture contents and recognize that the meter reading, evencorrected, may be just a little high at the target moisture content.TABLE 3. Moisture meter and oven-dry results for Oregon white oak.Day 13 Day 20Meter Oven-dry Difference Meter Oven Difference11.6 13.3 1.7 6.8 6.8 0.011.8 13.6 1.8 9.4 9.0 0.411.4 12.9 1.5 7.1 6.4 0.710.3 11.4 1.1 9.9 9.9 0.2Moisture Content of HemlockEach year at the Oregon State Lumber Drying Workshop we dry a charge oflumber and do moisture contents by the oven-dry method. In one of our undergraduateclasses we went one step further and cut shell-core moisture contents as a charge ofhemlock dried. These results are shown in Figure 4.20Time40, HoursFIGURE 4. Shell (broken line) and core moisture contents for 2x6 western hemlockduring drying at 190°F.60WDKA	73	May, 1999Notice that the shell started at a slightly lower moisture content than the core.This is probably due to moisture losses between the time the board was sawed and thetime of the test. During the early part of drying the shell lost moisture a little faster thanthe core, but at the end of drying the wet core caught up. During equalizing andconditioning, the core continued to lose moisture while the shell quit drying and evengained a little. Because the moisture contents at different times in Figure 4 come fromdifferent boards, there is some scatter in the data that makes this hard to see. When thesame boards are weighed (instead of shell and core samples) throughout the dryingprocess, it's easy to see that the dry boards quit losing moisture during equalizing andall boards except the wettest ones gain moisture during conditioning. This moisture gainis necessary for stress relief. If stress tests show sporadic results, it's probably theboards that were wettest at the beginning of conditioning that contain stress while theboards dried to at least three percent below the conditioning EMC are stress free. Thus,equalizing to a uniform moisture content at least three percent below the conditioningEMC is important if the conditioning process is to result in stress free-lumber.ConclusionsThe oven-dry test can be a useful tool not only for verifying the readings fromelectronic moisture meters, but also for understanding what is happening inside of thewood as it dries. In some cases, even the oven-dry test can be in error if the woodcontains a high concentration of volatile compounds other than water. The correctmoisture content is important for product quality and the oven-dry test is an importantQC tool.WDKA	 74	 May, 1999

Moisture content by the oven-dry method for industrial testing

https://ir.library.oregonstate.edu/downloads/jm214q048

Moisture content by the oven-dry method for industrial testing

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

ScholarsArchive@OSU