Two experiments were conducted to study the motion cue effects on human pilots during tracking tasks. The moving-base simulator of National Aerospace Laboratory was employed as the motion cue device, and the attitude director indicator or the projected visual field was employed as the visual cue device. The chosen controlled elements were second-order unstable systems. It was confirmed that with the aid of motion cues the pilot workload was lessened and consequently the human controllability limits were enlarged. In order to clarify the mechanism of these effects, the describing functions of the human pilots were identified by making use of the spectral and the time domain analyses. The results of these analyses suggest that the sensory system of the motion cues can yield the differential informations of the signal effectively, which coincides with the existing knowledges in the physiological area

Endo, S.

Itoko, T.

Tanaka, K.

Washizu, K.

English

NASA Technical Reports Server

https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19790009343 2020-03-20T18:08:23+00:00Z
o
f 
w
hi
ch
 h
ad
 t
w
o 
ge
nt
le
 c
u
to
ff
 g
re
qu
en
ci
ea
: 
TH
E 
FI
R
ST
 E
X
PE
RI
FE
RT
 
F
ur
po
se
s 
o
f 
th
e 
fi
rs
t 
e
x
p
er
im
n
t 
a
r
e
 
1
) T
o 
e
-m
lu
at
e 
th
e 
e
x
pe
ri
m
en
ta
l 
c
c
n
tr
o
ll
ab
il
it
y
 1
im
i:s
 
o
f 
th
e 
hu
m
an
 p
il
o
t 
c
o
n
- 
tm
ll
in
g
 s
c
c
o
n
d-
or
de
r 
=
,
s
ta
bl
e 
s
y
st
m
s 
w
it
h 
a
n
d 
w
it
ho
ut
 m
o
tio
n 
c
u
e
s
. 
a
n
d 
to
 
c
o
n
fi
rm
 t
he
 m
o
ti
on
 c
u
e
 
e
Y
ec
ts
 
o
n
 
th
e 
c
o
n
tr
o
ll
ab
il
it
y
 l
im
it
s;
 
ar
. 
d 
2
) 
To
 
in
v
es
ti
g
at
e 
th
e 
v
a
r
ia
ti
o
n
 o
f 
th
e 
d
es
x
ib
in
g
 f
un
ct
io
ns
 o
f 
hu
m
an
 
p
il
o
ts
 i
n
 
c
o
n
tr
o
ll
in
g
 u
r
x
ta
tl
e 
s
ys
te
m
s 
w
it
hi
n 
th
ei
r 
1
-i
d
ts
 by
 
th
e 
di
ff
er
en
ce
 c
f 
th
e 
ki
nd
s 
o
f 
c
o
n
tm
l 
c
u
e
s
. 
h
ce
ri
m
en
ta
l 
S
et
up
 (
Fi
g.
1)
 
In
 o
rd
er
 t
o
 c
lo
sd
 t
h
e 
n
a
n
-m
a
c
hi
ne
 f
ee
db
ac
k 
lo
op
, 
s
u
bj
ec
ts
 v
e
re
 
in
st
ru
ct
ed
 
to
 s
ta
b
il
iz
e 
th
e 
M
gu
la
r 
m
o
ti
on
 a
bo
ut
 t
h
e 
r
o
ll
ir
g
 -
is
, 
w
hi
le
 i
s
 s
im
il
ar
 t
o
 
th
e 
bs
n*
 
a
n
gl
e 
c
o
n
tr
o
l 
o
f 
m
1 
a
ir
cr
af
t.
 b
y 
m
o
v
in
g 
th
e 
m
n
tm
l 
s
ti
ck
 l
at
er
al
ly
. 
An
 e
x
te
rn
a
l 
I
-
M
~
O
~
 
fo
rc
in
g 
fu
nc
ti
on
 w
as
 
a
dd
ed
 i
n
to
 t
h?
 I
m
p
 t
o
 a
c
ti
v
at
e 
th
e 
s
ya
te
m
. 
A
X
 t
h
e 
s
ig
n
al
s 
in
 t
h
e 
s
ys
te
m
 w
e
re
 
re
c
o
rd
ed
 b
y 
a
n
 
a
n
a
lo
gu
e 
da
ta
 r
e
- 
c
o
rd
er
 t
o 
be
 u
s
e
d 
la
te
r 
fo
r 
th
e 
id
en
ti
fi
ca
ti
o
n
 o
f 
th
e 
de
sc
ri
bi
ng
 f
un
ct
io
ns
. 
E
q
u
ip
en
ts
 i
n 
F
ig
.1
 a
r
e
 n
o
v
 
de
sc
ri
be
d:
 
Cm
tro
ZL
ed
 e
le
tn
en
t. 
T
he
 t
ra
n
sf
er
 h
c
t!
o
n
 
o
f 
th
e 
c
o
n
tr
o
ll
ed
 e
le
m
en
t 
is
 
c
iv
en
 b
y 
w
he
re
 Y
 =
 
10
. 
20
. 
30
. 
'
1
0
, 
50
 (
ra
d2
/s
ec
2)
. 
X 
<
 
0
. 
a
n
d 
X 
w
a
s 
c
ha
ng
ed
 v
it
h
 t
h
e 
s
te
p
 s
iz
e 
o
f 
0.
1 
(r
ad
/s
ec
).
 
l%
is
 m
s
ta
b
ie
 s
e
c
c
n
d-
or
de
r 
c
o
n
tr
o
l?
.e
d 
e
ic
pc
nt
 
w
as
 
s
im
ul
at
ed
 o
n
 
M
 =
a
lo
gu
e 
c
a
p
u
te
r.
 
C
on
tlv
: 
m
e
8.
 
F
or
 t
h
e 
in
pu
t 
to
 t
h
e 
p
il
o
t 
in
 t
h
e 
c
o
m
pe
ns
at
or
y 
tr
a
c
ki
ng
 
ta
sk
. 
th
e 
e
r
r
o
r
 s
ig
na
.: 
in
 F
ig
.1
 w
as
 
pr
ov
id
ed
 b
y 
th
e 
fo
ll
ov
in
g 
tw
 d
ev
ic
es
: 
(a
) 
Vi
ou
nt
 s
ys
te
m
. 
T
he
 r
o
ll
 a
n
gl
e 
w
as
 
di
sp
la
ye
d 
o
n
 
th
e 
a
tt
it
u
d
e 
d
ir
ec
to
r 
in
d
ic
at
o
r 
in
st
al
le
d
 i
n
 t
h
e 
c
o
c
kp
it
. 
(b
) 
k
t&
 
s
ys
ta
*.
 
A 
s
in
g
le
 s
e
a
te
d 
'
Pr
OL
 
c
o
c
kp
it
 w
a
s
 
in
st
al
le
d
 o
n
 
th
e 
m
v
- 
in
q 
ba
se
 o
f 
th
e 
s
il
u
la
to
r,
 t
t
i 
n
a
ri
m
~
m
 op
er
at
in
g 
ra
n
ge
 o
f 
w
hi
ch
 w
as
 
t1
0
 
&
eg
re
es
 f
o
r 
bo
th
 s
id
es
 (
Fi
g.
2)
. 
T
he
 r
o
ll
 a
x
is
 l
ay
 b
et
w
ee
n 
th
e 
su
b-
 
;e
c
t'
s 
fe
et
; 
h
is
 b
od
y 
u
a
6 
s
u
bJ
ec
t 
to
 b
ot
h 
li
n
ea
r 
a
n
d 
a
n
gu
la
r 
a
c
c
e
le
ra
ti
on
s.
 
C
on
tm
l 
s
ti
lk
. 
A 
s
in
g
le
 s
ti
ck
-t
yp
e 
c
o
n
tr
o
ll
er
 w
it
ho
ut
 r
e
s
to
ri
n
g
 f
or
ce
 
w
a
s 
u
s
e
d.
 
ge
ne
ra
ti
rg
 l
at
er
al
 m
o
v
e
m
e
n
ts
 o
f 
th
e 
c
o
n
tr
o
l 
o
u
tp
ut
. 
Fo
m
?im
; 
fu
nc
ti
on
. 
A 
v
h
it
c 
n
o
is
e 
s
ig
n
al
 w
as
 
fi
lt
er
ed
 b
y 
th
e 
fo
Il
ov
in
g 
s
ha
pi
ng
 f
il
te
r 
to
 g
en
er
at
e 
th
e 
r
m
dc
n 
fo
rc
in
g 
fu
nc
ti
on
, 
th
e 
po
ve
r 
s
p
e
c
tn
r 
M
 a
u
b
j~
w
ts
 pa
rt
ic
ip
at
ed
 i
n
 t
b
e 
fi
rs
t 
u
p
c
rl
ra
t;
 a
 
s
tu
de
nt
 w
ho
 b
.d
 
m
 
e
x
pe
ri
en
ce
 o
f 
c
o
n
tm
ll
in
#
 a
ir
cr
af
t 
(P
il
ot
 A
). 
m
d
 a
 t
ea
t 
p
il
o
t 
o
f 
IA
L 
(P
ilo
t 
B
). 
T
he
 e
x
p
ri
rn
ta
l 
d
at
a 
w
er
e 
o
bt
ai
ne
d 
a
ft
er
 
th
ey
 h
ad
 k
e
o
r 
s
k
il
le
d
 i
n
 t
he
 
e
iv
en
 t
ra
c
ki
ng
 t
a
sk
s.
 
M
ec
uu
rr
rm
ta
 a
n
d 
R
es
ul
t?
 
fh
m
 
ki
n&
 
o
f 
e
x
pe
ri
m
en
ta
l 
s
it
u
at
io
n
s 
w
e
re
 
r
e
a
li
ze
d
 b
y 
c
ha
ng
in
g 
th
e 
c
u
e
s
 
gi
ve
n 
to
 t
h
e 
s
U
bJ
ec
t: 
(a
) 
&
t
h
 ~
Z
W
 
v
is
ua
l. 
Th
e 
lo
ti
o
n
 s
y
s
ta
 v
a
s
 
M
v
e
d
, 
a
n
d 
a
ls
o
 t
h
e 
in
st
ru
n
t 
in
fo
ra
nt
io
n 
u
ra
 r
v
a
il
ab
le
. 
(b
) &
tio
n 
on
ly
. 
th
e 
m
ti
o
n
 8
y
s
ts
 UM
 
d
ri
rr
d
, 
w
hi
le
 t
h
e 
ro
c
r 
li
&
ht
s 
v
e
r
e
 
tu
n
e
d
 o
ff
. 
T
he
 a
u
bj
ec
t m
s
 r
e
qu
es
te
d 
to
 c
lc
sc
 h
is
 e
ye
r,
 s
od
 v
u
 
o
bl
ig
ed
 t
o
 u
ti
li
z
e
 v
ti
m
 c
u
e
s
 
rm
ly
. 
(c
) 
V
h
m
Z
 a
ly
. 
b
 f
ix
in
g
 t
h
e 
ba
se
. 
o
n
ly
 t
h
e 
im
t-t
 
in
lo
rr
ti
o
n
 v
u
 
r
n
il
a
b
le
. 
C
o
at
ro
ll
ab
il
it
y
 1
W
ta
 v
it
b
o
u
t 
th
e 
fo
re
la
g
 f
nn
et
io
n 
w
er
e 
o
bt
ai
ne
d 
fo
r 
P
il
o
t 
A. 
'Ib
e 
li
ri
ts
 u
e
r
e
 
te
n
ta
ti
v
el
y
 d
ef
ll
vd
 b
y 
th
e 
p
u
n
et
em
 X
 X
 Y
 s
u
c
h 
th
at
 t
h
e 
s
u
bj
ec
t 
c
o
u
ld
 m
a
rg
in
al
ly
 m
a
in
ta
in
 t
h
e 
r
o
ll
 a
n
gl
e 
w
it
b
in
Z
1
0
 d
eg
re
s 
fo
r 
o
n
e
 m
in
ut
e.
 
Th
e 
c
o
n
tm
ll
a
b
~
li
ty
 li
m
it
s 
th
na
 o
bt
ai
ne
d 
a
r
c
 
s
bo
vn
 i
n
 P
ig
.3
. 
R
a
 t
h
is
 f
ig
w
e,
 i
t 
is
 e
v
id
en
t 
th
at
 m
ti
o
n
 c
u
e
s
 h
ar
e 
e
n
l-e
d 
th
e 
li
m
it
s.
 
T
hi
s 
a
gr
ee
s 
w
it
h 
th
e 
e
x
is
ti
n
g
 k
no
w
le
ds
ea
 c
o
n
c
e
rn
il
y(
 t
h
e
 c
o
n
tr
o
ll
ab
il
it
y
 l
W
ts
 
a
n
d 
th
e 
e
ff
ec
ti
ve
ne
aa
 o
f 
m
o
ti
on
 c
u
e
s.
 
n
e
x
t.
 
th
e 
d
es
cr
ib
iw
 f
im
ct
io
na
 o
f 
h- 
p
il
o
ts
 w
er
e 
id
en
ti
fi
ed
 b
y 
th
z 
fo
ll
ow
in
g 
pr
oc
ed
ur
es
. 
Ib
e 
a
n
a
lo
gt
ar
 a
i
m
s
 if
t)
. 
d
t)
, 
c
(t
) 
In
 3
6
.1
 w
e
r
e
 
c
o
n
v
e
rt
ed
 i
n
to
 d
ig
it
al
 &
ta
 w
it
h 
s
a
~
p
l-
ia
g
 in
te
rr
al
 A
 =
 
0.
05
(a
ec
), 
v
it
h
 t
h
c 
d
at
a 
le
ng
th
 b
ei
ng
 w
e
 
m
in
ut
e.
 
On
 t
h
e 
ba
si
s 
o
f 
th
es
e 
d
i
t
i
w
 d
at
a,
 t
he
 p
il
o
t 
d
es
cr
ib
iw
 h
\a
ct
ia
ns
 
w
e
re
 
o
bt
ai
ne
d 
a
a
;
 
In
 E
g.
(3
) 
th
e 
c
m
a
s
 s
pr
ct
m
 )
 
(a
),
 
.
a
d 
@ 
(j
w
) 
w
er
e 
c
o
r
pl
te
d 
by
 B
ln
ch
n
n
- 
Tu
ke
y 
w
tw
. 
C
or
re
la
ti
dn
 &
ct
io
ns
 
w
e
re
 
C& 
o
ff
 t
o 
a
 
le
-h
 
o
f 
6C
se
c)
. 
a
n
d 
8.
ri
m
g 
v
in
do
w
 w
as
 u
s
e
d.
 
A
t 
tb
e 
a
g
e
 t
ir
. 
th
e
 c
lo
se
d-
lo
g,
 
If
Z
Ie
u
-~
o
m
lI
It
i~
n
 
c
o
e
ff
ic
ie
n
t 
f
m
 i(
t)
 t
o
 c
(t
) 
w
aa
 
c
d
cn
la
te
d
 M
 l
o
ll
w
a
: 
U
IT
A
C 
50
20
 M
p
u
te
r 
w
aa
 u
s
e
d 
lo
r 
th
e 
c
a
lc
ul
at
io
n.
 
An
 e
m
m
pl
e 
c
f 
tb
c 
o
b-
 
ta
in
ed
 r
e
s
u
lt
s 
is
 s
bo
vn
 i
n
 ~
l6
a.
b-
a 
a
n
d 
b-
b,
 
o
f 
v
hi
ch
 t
?i
e 
v
a
lu
es
 o
f 
(X
.r)
 
o
f 
th
e 
c
o
n
tr
o
ll
ed
 e
le
m
en
t 
c
o
rr
e
s
po
nd
 t
o
 @
 i
n
 F
ig
.3
. 
D
is
ti
n
ct
 f
ea
tu
re
s 
e
a
s
il
y
 
n
o
ti
ce
d 
fr
m
 t
h
e 
Fi
g.
b-
b 
a
r
e
 s
w
r
w
iz
e
d
 a
s
 
fo
ll
w
s:
 
F
or
 t
h
e 
c
a
s
e
 o
f 
m
o
ti
on
 p
lu
s 
v
is
ua
l.
 
ga
in
s 
a
r
e
 g
en
er
ai
u
 h
ig
he
r 
th
an
 o
th
er
 
c
a
s
e
s
. 
a
n
d 
bo
th
 g
ai
ns
 a
n
d 
ph
as
es
 a
r
e
 l
ea
st
 
f l
uc
tu
an
t ;
 i
 .e
 .
 ,
 li
ne
n;
--
 
c
e
r
r
e
lh
ti
o
n
 c
o
e
ff
ic
ie
n
ts
 s
ho
w
 h
ig
h 
v
a
lu
es
 o
v
e
r
 w
id
e 
fr
eq
ue
nc
y 
ba
nd
. 
T
hu
s 
tb
e 
p
il
o
t 
tr
a
n
sf
er
 f
un
ct
io
n 
o
f 
th
is
 c
a
s
e
 
se
e
m
s 
t
o
 b
e 
a
pp
ro
pr
ia
te
ly
 e
x
pr
es
se
d 
by
 i
 
w
he
re
 T
 
?O
.Q
:(s
ec
). 
T
t!
z0
.2
 
-
0.
5(
se
c)
. 
r
e
s
pe
ct
iv
el
y.
 
Fo
r 
th
eL
ce
jc
 o
f 
lo
ti
o
n
 o
n
ly
. 
th
e 
fr
eq
ue
nc
y 
re
s
po
ns
e 
is
 s
im
il
ar
 t
o
 t
h
at
 o
f 
*
.h
e 
e
n
s
- 
o
f 
=
ti
on
 
pl
us
 v
is
u
al
 o
v
e
r
 t
h
e 
fr
eq
ue
nc
y 
hi
gh
er
 t
hn
n 
a
bo
ut
 1
.5
-3
 
(r
ed
ls
ec
).
 w
he
re
 l
in
ea
r-
co
rr
el
at
io
n 
c
o
e
ff
ic
ie
n
ts
 a
r
e
 l
ar
ge
. 
F
or
 t
h
e 
fi
e-
 
qu
en
cy
 l
ov
er
 t
ha
n 
h
u
t
 1
.5
(r
ad
/s
ec
l. 
o
n
 
th
e 
o
th
er
 h
an
d,
 l
in
ea
r-
co
rr
el
at
io
n 
c
o
e
ff
ic
ie
n
ts
 a
r
e
 
m
a
ll
. 
w
hi
ch
 
im
pl
ie
s 
th
e 
ir
re
g
u
la
ri
ty
 o
f 
th
e 
c
o
n
tr
o
l 
s
tr
a
te
g
y
 i
n
 t
h
is
 f
re
qu
en
cy
 b
an
d.
 
F
or
 t
h
e 
c
r
s
e
 c
f 
v
is
u
al
 o
n
ly
. 
th
e 
r
e
s
u
lt
 i
s
 j
us
t 
c
o
n
tr
a
ry
 t
o
 t
h
e 
c
a
s
e
 o
f 
m
ti
o
n
 c
n
iy
. 
n
w
ly
. 
u
e
 
c
s
n
 
s
e
e
 h
ig
h 
li
ne
ar
-c
or
re
la
ti
on
 
c
o
e
ff
ic
ie
at
s 
in
 
lo
ve
r 
fr
eq
ue
nc
y 
ba
nd
; 
w
hi
le
 i
n
 h
i~
h
e
r fr
eq
ue
nc
y 
ba
nd
 t
h
e 
re
s
po
ns
e 
a
r
e
 d
is
- 
pe
rs
ed
 m
d 
li
ne
ar
-c
or
re
la
ti
on
 
c
o
e
ff
ic
ie
n
ts
 a
r
e
 m
a
ll
. 
Th
t 
in
cr
en
se
 o
f 
ga
in
s,
 w
hi
ch
 1
; 
o
bv
io
us
 i
n
 h
i.g
he
r 
fr
eq
ue
nc
y 
ba
nd
 o
f 
bo
th
 
m
o
ti
on
 c
a
s
e
s
, 
c
o
rr
e
s
po
nd
s 
to
 t
he
 r
a
th
er
 r
a
pi
d 
c
o
n
tr
o
l 
s
ti
ck
 p
o
v
ae
n
ts
 
o
bs
er
ve
d 
in
 F
ig
-L
a.
 
7
h
is
 p
he
no
m
en
on
 c
a
n
 b
e 
s
e
e
n
 
o
ft
en
 i
n
 t
ra
c
ki
ng
 w
he
n 
a
 
c
o
n
tr
o
ll
ed
 e
la
ne
nt
 i
s 
o
s
c
il
la
to
ry
. 
In
 s
w
h
 a
 
c
a
s
e
, 
h- 
p
il
o
t 
se
e
m
s 
t
o
 
o
bt
ai
n 
qu
ic
kn
es
s.
 
w
hi
ch
 i
s
 c
s
pc
ci
nl
ly
 i
m
po
rt
an
t 
fo
r 
th
e 
s
ys
te
m
 s
ta
b
il
it
y
. 
by
 o
s
c
il
la
ti
n
g
 t
he
 s
ti
ck
 v
it
h
 t
h
e 
fr
eq
ue
nc
y 
th
at
 i
s 
s
u
it
ed
 t
o
 h
im
 a
n
d 
is
 
bi
gh
er
 t
ha
n 
th
e 
n
a
tu
ra
l 
fr
eq
ue
nc
y 
o
f 
th
e 
c
o
n
tr
o
ll
e3
 e
le
m
en
t.
 
fe
at
ur
es
 l
is
te
d
 a
bo
ve
 a
r
e
 c
o
n
s
is
te
nt
ly
 o
bs
er
ve
d 
r
e
ga
rd
le
ss
 o
f 
s
u
bJ
ec
ts
 o
r
 
c
o
n
tr
o
ll
ed
 e
le
m
en
ts
. 
'Ih
us
. 
it
 v
a
s
 
c
o
n
fi
rr
ed
 t
h
at
 m
o
ti
on
 c
u
e
s
 
im
pr
ov
ed
 t
h
e 
h- 
c
o
n
tr
o
i 
c
h
ar
ac
te
ri
st
ic
s 
in
 h
ig
h 
f.-
eq
:rr
nc
y 
ra
n
ge
 w
hi
ch
 w
a
s
 
im
po
rt
hn
t 
fo
r 
th
e 
s
y
s
ta
 s
tn
b
il
it
y
, 
a
n
d 
th
at
 v
is
ua
l 
c
u
e
s
 g
iv
en
 b
y 
th
e 
in
st
n
m
en
t 
w
e
re
 
e
ff
ec
- 
ti
re
 t
o
 t
h
e 
pr
ec
is
e 
c
o
n
tr
o
l 
in
 r
a
th
er
 l
o
r 
fr
eq
ue
nc
y 
ra
n
u
e
; 
i.
e.
 
v
is
-a
l 
c
u
e
s
 
br
in
g 
h
u
t
 su
c
h 
a
n
 
ile
pr
uv
em
en
t 
o
f 
c
o
n
tr
o
l 
a
s
 
c
n
n
c
e
ll
in
g 
th
e 
s
te
a
dy
-s
ta
te
 
de
vi
at
io
ns
 . 
m
 
SE
CO
ND
 E
XP
ER
1)r
ER
T 
In
 t
h
e 
fi
rs
t 
e
x
pe
ri
m
en
t,
 t
h
e 
c
~
n
tr
o
l fo
r 
th
e 
c
a
s
e
 o
f 
v
is
ua
l 
o
n
ly
 c
o
rr
e
- 
s
po
nd
s 
to
 t
h
e 
il
lg
ht
 i
n
 t
in
e 
in
st
ru
m
en
t 
m
e
te
o
m
lo
gi
ca
l 
c
o
n
di
ti
on
 (
IM
C)
 w
it
hc
ut
 
m
o
ti
on
 c
u
e
s
. 
O
r. 
th
e 
o
th
er
 h
an
d.
 
in
 t
he
 c
a
s
e
 o
f 
m
o
ti
on
 p
lu
s 
v
is
ua
l.
 
s
u
bJ
ec
ts
 
c
o
u
ld
 u
s
e
 
n
o
t 
o
n
ly
 i
n
st
cm
en
t 
in
fo
rm
at
io
n 
bu
t 
a
ls
o
 t
h
e 
pe
ri
ph
er
al
 v
is
ua
l 
in
fo
r-
 
m
a
ti
on
; 
n
a
m
e
ly
 t
he
 s
it
u
at
io
n
 i
s
 e
qu
iv
al
en
t 
t
o
 t
h
e 
fl
ig
h
t 
in
 t
h
e 
v
ls
u
al
 
n
e
tf
fi
ro
lo
gi
ca
l 
c
o
n
di
ti
on
 (
W
) w
.th
 
a
t
io
n
 c
u
-s
. 
C
on
se
qu
en
ti
y 
th
er
e 
w
as
 
th
e 
di
ff
er
en
ce
 o
f 
v
is
u
al
 i
n
f
o
~
t
i
o
o
 
be
tw
ee
n 
th
e 
a
bo
ve
 t
w
 c
o
n
di
ti
on
s.
 
lb
e
 r
e
c
e
n
t 
p
q
er
 b
y 
Ju
nk
er
 e
t.
 n
l.
 
[R
ef
.lc
] 
d
m
 p
oi
nt
s 
o
u
t 
th
a
t 
th
e 
pe
ri
ph
er
al
 r
is
m
l 
in
fo
ru
ti
o
n
 h
a
 th
e 
s
a
p
 e
ff
ec
t 
o
n
 t
be
 h
- 
p
il
o
t 
c
o
n
tr
o
l 
s
tr
rt
c
g
 M
 m
u
ti
on
 
c
u
e
s
. 
T
he
 s
e
c
o
n
d 
e
x
p
er
iw
n
t 
u
ps
 r
e
n
r
e
d
 d
te
r 
1D
di
m
iu
g 
th
e 
r
in
n
l 
s
y
st
a
 s
o
 
u
 
t
o
 e
qu
al
iz
e 
th
e 
v
is
u
al
 i
n
ro
lr
at
io
n
 f
o
r 
th
e 
c
u
e
s
 o
r
 v
is
u
al
 o
n
ly
 t
o
 m
u
ti
on
 p
lu
s 
ri
su
al
 o
n
ly
: 
th
e 
v
is
u
al
 i
n
fo
lv
rt
io
n
 v
s
s
 
pr
ov
id
ed
 b
y 
th
e 
s
im
ul
at
ed
 v
is
u
al
 f
ie
ld
 
pr
oj
ec
te
d 
t
o
 t
h
e 
s
c
r
e
e
n
 i
n
 f
ro
nt
 o
f 
th
e 
c
o
c
kp
it
 t
o
 v
id
en
 t
be
 p
il
o
ts
' 
u
t#
le
 o
f 
v
is
io
n.
 
Il
or
eo
m
r,
 
to
 p
ut
 a
 s
tr
e
ss
 o
n
 t
h
c 
st
*
 
o
f 
th
e 
de
sc
ri
b-
 
fm
ct
:a
m
, 
s
li
g
h
tl
y
 m
s
ta
b
le
 c
o
n
tr
o
ll
ed
 e
le
m
en
ts
 w
e
re
 
.
do
pt
ed
. 
In
 n
dd
it
io
n,
 
th
e 
t
i
r
 d
b
 
r
r
in
 a
n
a
ly
si
s,
 v
hi
ch
 h
ns
 r
e
c
e
w
 c
a
e
 i
n
to
 p
lr
ct
ic
n
l 
u
se
. 
iu
a 
r
e
v
e
a
le
d 
tb
e 
p
o
ss
ib
il
it
y
 o
f 
id
en
ti
fy
lu
g
 p
re
ci
se
ly
 b
ot
h 
s
ys
te
m
 d
y
an
d
cs
 n
nd
 n
o
is
e 
cb
-te
r- 
is
ti
ce
. 
We
 
ha
ve
 a
p
lo
y
ed
 t
h
fs
 t
ec
hn
iq
ue
 i
n
 o
r
de
r 
to
 i
m
-%
tig
at
e 
th
e 
h- 
s
e
n
s
o
q
 c
h
ar
ac
te
ri
st
ic
s.
 
T
hu
s 
th
e 
s-d 
e
x
p
er
in
rn
t 
bu
r 
th
e 
fo
llc
*r
ill
(( 
t
r
o
 o
bj
ec
tiv
es
: 
1
) 
T
o 
ge
t 
th
e 
di
ff
er
en
ce
s 
b
e
tm
a
 p
il
o
t 
dy
na
dc
s 
v
it
b
 a
n
d 
w
ith
ou
t 
&
io
n 
e
rr
s
 
by
 p
ro
w
id
in
# 
th
e 
p
il
o
t 
v
it
h
 t
b
e 
r
is
p
.1
 c
u
e
s
 a
ir
il
u
 t
o 
+
-t 
o
f 
W
C
;
 
a
n
d 2)
 T
o 
e
s
ti
m
te
 t
b
e 
v
c
h
u
u
m
 o
f 
th
e 
m
o
tio
n 
an
d 
th
e 
r
is
p
.1
 s
e
n
so
ry
 o
rg
ru
. 
ba
re
d 
o
n
 
de
sc
ri
bi
ng
 r
.~
 
!e
th
o
s 
.
o
d
 t
h
e
 -5
. 
On
ly
 
th
e 
D
d
if
ic
at
io
n
s 
o
f 
th
e 
fi
m
 a
p
ir
iw
n
t 
n
r
e
 
d
u
cr
ik
d
. 
'Zb
c 
bl
oc
k 
di
qp
7m
 v
u
 
th
e 
en
m
e 
n
a
 P
ig
.1
. 
S
ta
ti
c 
ga
in
 w
as
 
s
e
t 
c
o
n
s
ta
n
i,
 
s
o
d 
th
e
 p
v
rr
tu
r 
v
c
rc
 
T 
=
 
10
, 
30
 a
rr
d 
I
 =
 
0
, 
-
0.
3.
 
r
e
s
pe
ct
ir
el
y.
 
C
'd
Q
it 
an
d 
a
cm
t2
vL
Lo
r. 
B
ot
h 
w
e
re
 t
he
 .
.
r
 
as
 t
ho
ce
 o
r 
tb
a 
ii
rs
t 
u
p
er
i-
 
m
t 
.
 
C
on
tr
ot
 c
ue
s.
 
(a
) 
Vi
su
al
 s
y
e
ta
: 
S
ir
u
la
te
d
 v
in
rl
 f
ie
ld
 v
u
 
m
e
d,
 w
hi
ch
 v
u
 t
b
e 
sc
e
n
e
 o
f 
th
e 
P
-&
le
d 
n
m
w
a
y 
W
e
n
 b
y 
a
 v
id
eo
 c
.
~
c
r
n
,
 a
n
d 
v
u
 
pr
oJ
ec
te
d 
o
n
 
th
e
 
v
a
ll 
s
c
z
 ?e
n 
in
 i
m
n
t 
o
f 
th
e 
c
o
c
kp
it
 b
y 
di
do
ph
or
 (1
Li1
.5)
. 
T
he
 p
il
r 
v
is
u
al
 a
~
q
le
 
v
a
s
 w
id
en
ed
 t
o
 
32
 d
e-s
 
la
te
rd
ly
 b
y 
tb
es
e 
e
q
n
ip
a
. 
Fo
r 
th
e 
c
r
s
e
 o
f 
m
ti
o
n
 p
lu
s 
ri
su
n
l 
tb
e 
ir
y
e
 v
u
 
fi
xe
d,
 r
b
il
e
 f
o
r 
tb
r 
c
n
s
e
 o
f 
ii
.r
un
l 
o
n
ly
 
it
 W
M 
r
o
ta
te
d 
t
o
 p
ro
ri
de
 p
il
o
t#
 v
it
h
 t
he
 r
is
p
.1
 
in
fo
rn
at
ia
 o
f 
r
o
ll
in
g
, 
b~
 c
o
o
r
di
na
te
dl
y 
r
o
ta
ti
u
g
 t
he
 v
id
eo
 c
o
m
e
rn
. 
(b
) 
C
b
h
 S
y
8
h
~
: T
ht
 S
a
t
 C
oe
lr
pi
t 
9
.d
. 
Fo
rc
in
g 
fw
e
th
. 
.
?b
e 
ra
n
dm
 s
iQ
dl
 o
f 
li
d
t@
d
 ba
nd
-w
id
tb
 w
a
s 
'
Jt
il
is
ed
, 
th
e 
s
ha
pi
ng
 f
ii
te
r 
o
f 
w
hi
ch
 u
a
s
 
s
im
pl
if
ie
d 
to
; 

s
ys
ta
a.
 
n
is
 th
er
e?
nr
e 
iz
y
ll
cs
 t
h
at
 :
he
 
d
it
fe
re
n
ti
d
 o
r
 t
h
e 
a
c
c
o
n
d-
or
de
r 
di
ff
er
en
ti
m
i 
fe
at
u
re
s 
In
 x
S0
s 
In
 m
i?
ti,
,n
 
c
a
s
e
s
 
r
e
fl
ec
t 
th
e 
d
p
sa
ic
s 
o
f 
th
e 
m
tl
m
 s
e
n
s
x
 o
r&
sn
s.
 
Ue
 
cm
a 
a
c
e
 t
h
at
 r
o
ti
o
n
 c
ir
es
 c
-u
ld
 
be
 e
ff
ec
ti
v
el
y
 
u
ti
L
ic
ed
 v
it
h 
a
 
I
o
v
 l
ev
el
 r
e
m
n
a
n
t.
 
3n
 t
h
e 
o
th
er
 b
an
d.
 
p
il
o
t 
Q
ns
ri
cs
 b
a
ed
 
c
n
 
th
e 
d
sr
u
l 
c
u
e
s
 
pr
ov
eB
 t
o
 h
ar
e 
s
m
a
ll
er
 g
ai
n
 a
n
d 
th
e 
v
is
ua
l 
c
u
e
s
 
n
re
 .
o
r
e
 
in
se
n
si
ti
v
e 
th
an
 t
h
e 
n
o
ti
on
 c
u
e
s
. 
U
th
ou
gh
 a
n
 
e
s
rM
Ip
ti
on
 
c
o
n
c
e
rn
ia
g 
th
e 
r
s
w
a
o
t 
s
o
u
rc
e
 f
it
s 
w
m
e
 
r
e
n
tr
ie
- 
ti
6n
s 
o
n
 
th
e 
pr
ev
io
us
 d
is
cu
ss
io
n.
 
th
e 
Ii
n
d
i~
g
s a
e
u
ti
on
ed
 a
bo
ve
 b
as
ic
al
u
 s
gr
 
.
 
u
it
h
 t
b
a
 p
h
y
si
o
l!
x
i~
al
 kn
w
le
dg
es
 a
bo
ut
 t
h
e 
v
e
s
ti
b
u
la
r 
o
rg
an
s.
 
I
t 
sh
ou
ld
 b
e 
n
o
te
d 
th
at
 t
fr
e 
s
e
n
s
o
r 
o
r
gu
ns
 i
n
re
st
i~
st
e
d
 in
 t
h
is
 e
x
pe
r5
ne
n'
. 
ar
e.
 e
q
a
id
e
n
t 
to
 
th
e 
in
te
gr
at
ed
 m
ti
w
 s
e
e
s
o
r
 
s
ys
te
m
 i
nc
lb
dh
ag
 n
o
t 
o
n
ly
 t
he
 v
e
s
t5
b
u
i~
 or
ga
ns
 
bu
t 
a
ls
o 
th
e 
s
ki
n 
s
e
n
s
a
ti
o
n
s 
a
n
d 
th
e 
de
ep
 s
e
n
s
a
ti
on
s.
 
To
 a
k
c
 t
h
e 
o
bt
ai
ee
d 
r
e
s
u
lt
s 
5
x
-e
 p
rx
cf
1c
r.
l. 
m
e 
s
ho
ul
4 
c
o
n
ti
nu
e 
r
iv
th
er
 e
v
a
lu
at
io
n 
o
f 
th
es
e 
tin
d-
 
in
(js
 b
y 
c
a
r
e
r
tJ
~
y
 cc
n
n
pa
rin
# 
th
es
e 
v
it
h
 t
h
e 
to
o
w
le
jg
es
 a
b
m
t 
th
e 
hr
sl
an
 a
-n
s
o
r 
d
y
n
ai
cs
. 
6.
 
fi
ai
k-
.H
. 
-
 
ku
to
le
gr
es
st
ne
 I
bb
cl
 P
it
ti
g
 t
or
 r
lw
tm
:. 
la
p
. 
Ta
wt
. 
S
ta
ti
st
. 
M
at
h.
. 
Yo
1.
23
. 
19
71
, 
pp
.1
63
-1
80
. 
&
hr
.D
.T
. 
;
 m
ad
 K
re
nd
el 
.
S.P
. 
:
 
h
tb
a
ti
c.
1
 
Ib
h
ls
 a
l 
d
u
~
a
 
Pi
lo
t 
B
eh
av
io
r.
 
hG
A
Fl
%
A
C
l68
. 
19
74
. 
F
m
 t
h
e 
e
x
pr
ir
cc
nt
s 
de
sc
ri
be
d 
a
v
e
,
 u
e
 
c
o
z
c
lu
de
 a
s 
fo
ll
~
u
s:
 
1
) W
ti
o
n
 c
u
e
s
 
e
m
 
e
n
la
rg
e 
th
e 
tu
ur
. 
pi
19
ts
e 
m
tr
o
ll
a
b
il
it
y
 l
im
it
s 
fo
r 
th
e 
s
-c
x
d-
or
de
r 
u
n
s
ta
bl
e 
C
on
tr
oL
le
d 
e
le
rn
ts
. 
7
) k
ti
o
r,
 w
r
s
 Im
pr
ov
e 
th
e 
b
u
r
n
 c
o
n
tr
o
l 
c
h
ar
ac
te
ri
st
ic
s 
in
 r
a
th
er
 h
fg
h 
fr
c-
 
qu
m
cy
 r
a
n
ge
. 
w
hi
le
 t
h
e 
v
is
ua
l 
c
u
e
s
 
\r
e 
e
ff
ec
ti
v
e 
ta
r 
th
e 
pr
ec
is
e 
c
o
n
t.
n
l 
in
 r
a
th
er
 l
ow
 r
m
qu
en
c?
. 
3)
 P
m
 tb
c 
di
sc
w
si
on
a 
s
bo
ut
 h
um
n 
de
sc
ri
bi
ng
 C
un
ct
io
ns
 ~
m
d
 tr
re
 
rc
rp
aa
nt
. 
it
 
ra
a
 
su
&
gc
stt
d 
th
at
 t
he
 m
ti
o
n
 s
e
n
s
o
r 
s
ys
te
m 
c
.r
 
y
ie
ld
 t
h
e 
d
if
fe
re
n
ti
al
 c
r
 
;h@
 
st
cm
n
-o
n
lc
r 
d
it
fc
m
:t
lr
l 
in
fo
rr
at
in
n
s 
o
f 
tt
d
 i
np
ut
. 
'E
ar
 a
u
th
nr
r 
r
r
e
 
d
e
e
~
lg
 in
de
bt
ed
 t
o
 M
?. 
T.
 T
er
ui
. 
a
 
te
s
t 
pi
:o
r 
o
l 
iU
L.
 
TO
T 
h
is
 :
a
r
ti
ci
p
at
io
n
 6
s 
th
e 
s
u
?l
le
ct
. 
m
d
 a
ls
o
 t
o
 P
ro
f.
 
II.
 
Co
t0
 o
f 
U
uG
hu
 W
niV
eT
- 
s
it
y
 f
cr
 h
is
 c
-ts
 
c
n
 
th
is
 p
ap
er
. 
2.
 
S
ta
~1
zf
or
d.
R
.L
. ;
 P
et
er
- 
3
.L
. 
;
 a
n
d 
A
1l
ex
.F
.R
. 
:
 
E
xp
el
-i
se
:.t
s 
a
n
d 
s
 X
rx
l-1
 
fo
r 
A
PP
Em
IX
: 
OR
 T
BE
 S
W
IN
G
 F
IL
TE
R 
OF
 T
BB
 E
W
AM
 R
IW
lA
RP
 
We
 
ge
ne
ra
ll
y 
de
fi
ne
 t
he
 r
e
a
n
a
n
t 
r
(t
) 
a
s
 a
 p
or
ti
on
 o
f 
c
(t
) 
ir
re
le
va
nt
 t
o
 
e
(t
;;
 -
ly
 
w
he
re
 y
 (
T)
 i
s 
th
e 
w
e
ig
ht
in
g 
fu
nc
ti
on
 o
f 
Y
p(
ju
). 
R
oo
 P
ig
.7
, 
w
e 
c
a
n
 d
er
iv
e 
th
e 
fo
8o
vi
ng
 r
e
la
ti
on
: 
B
es
t,
 
v
e
 
in
tr
od
uc
e 
a
n
o
th
e:
 
m
y 
to
 o
bt
ai
n 
IS
 i
m
 t
be
 m
to
ra
ga
ss
ir
c 
m
d
d
 
de
fi
ne
d 
in
 t
he
 t
ir
e
 -i
n.
 
We
 
a
W
 
re
v
ri
*,
e 
th
e 
P
is
t 
c
pu
rt
io
ll
 o
f 
%.
(a) 
U
; 
w
he
re
 y
E
(1
) 
is
 t
he
 w
e
ig
ht
in
g 
fu
nc
ti
on
 o
f 
IE
(J
o)
. 
R
O
B
 Eq
.1
 a
n
d 
1
1
, 
r
(t
) 
is
 
c
o
n
s
id
er
ed
 t
o
 b
e 
a
 
s
ha
pe
d 
o
u
tp
ut
 o
f 
Yp
, 
a
c
ti
va
te
d 
by
 t
he
 w
hi
te
 n
o
is
e 
d
t)
; 
th
er
ef
or
e 
th
e 
sh
a?
iro
g 
fi
lt
er
 o
f 
r
(t
) 
is
 Y
E.
 
T
hu
s 
n
 b
ar
e 
YS
 a
s;
 
h
rs
o
g
ln
g
 I
X
. 
w
e 
o
bt
ri
n 
v
he
re
 t
he
 s
e
c
o
n
d 
te
rm
 o
f 
th
e 
r
ig
h
t 
.
t
 s
id
e 
c
a
r
ts
- 
to
 t
he
 o
pe
n-
lo
op
 
c
o
n
tr
ib
ut
io
n 
o
f 
w
(t)
 t
o
 c
(t
);
 
P
 
We
 
s
ha
ll
 b
eg
in
 h
er
e 
by
 i
nt
ro
du
ci
ng
 t
h
e 
w
ay
 t
o
 e
e
t 
Yg
 
by
 I
nn
ki
ng
 u
s
e
 o
f 
0
 
w
 
th
e 
s
pe
ct
ra
l 
m
e
th
od
. 
It
 i
s 
w
e
ll
 L
no
vn
 t
ha
t 
th
+
 c
o
he
re
nc
y 
bc
tv
ee
n 
i(
t )
 a
n
d 
c
(t
) 
is
 
If
 b
e
 d
en
ot
e 
th
e 
po
ve
r 
sp
ec
L,
nm
 a
f 
c
lo
se
d-
lo
op
 c
o
n
a
;r
ib
ut
io
~ o
f 
th
e 
re
m
n
a
n
t 
a
s
 
W
hi
le
 t
he
 h
uw
u~
 de
sc
ri
bi
ng
 f
un
ct
io
n 
ir
, 
w
e 
c
a
n
 
u
r
it
e 
F
r
a
 E
qs
.V
 
a
n
d 
YT
. 
w
e 
o
bt
ai
n 
th
e 
e
s
i
h
t
 o
f 
th
e 
po
w
er
 s
pe
ct
ru
m
 o
f 
th
e 
re
m
m
m
t 
by
; 







Motion cue effects on human pilot dynamics in manual control

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

NASA Technical Reports Server