We quantitatively compare a particle implementation of the adhesion
approximation to fully non--linear, numerical nbody simulations. Our primary
tool, cross--correlation of nbody simulations with the adhesion approximation,
indicates good agreement, better than that found by the same test performed
with the Zel'dovich approximation (hereafter ZA). However, the
cross--correlation is not as good as that of the truncated Zel'dovich
approximation (TZA), obtained by applying the Zel'dovich approximation after
smoothing the initial density field with a Gaussian filter. We confirm that the
adhesion approximation produces an excessively filamentary distribution.
Relative to the nbody results, we also find that: (a) the power spectrum
obtained from the adhesion approximation is more accurate than that from ZA or
TZA, (b) the error in the phase angle of Fourier components is worse than that
from TZA, and (c) the mass distribution function is more accurate than that
from ZA or TZA. It appears that adhesion performs well statistically, but that
TZA is more accurate dynamically, in the sense of moving mass to the right
place.
Subject Heading: Galaxies, formation, clustering--large--scale structure of
the UniverseComment: TeX, 7 pages excluding figures (contact
[email protected]). submitted to Ap
