This study examines methods of geographic features recognition from historic maps using CNN and OBIA. These two methods are compared to reveal which one is most suitable to be applied to the historic maps dataset of the Banda Islands, Indonesia. The characteristics of cartographic images become the main challenge in this study. The geographic features are divided into buildings, coastline, and fortress. The results show that CNN is superior to OBIA in terms of statistical performance. Buildings and coastline give excellent results for CNN analysis, while fortress is harder to be interpreted by the model. On the other hand, OBIA reveals a very satisfying result is very depending on the maps’ scales. In the aspect of technical procedure, OBIA offers easier steps in pre-processing, in-process and post-processing/finalisation which can be an advantage for a wide range of users over CNN
