Element testing of soft soils is challenging due to the large strains attained in the pre-failure range. Besides the
heterogeneity of natural samples, the set-up configuration is the main driving factor for non-homogenous response. Stress, strain and pore pressure non-uniformities induced by the loading system affect the observed behaviour and complicate proper interpretation of the results. Among the difficulties encountered in the interpretation of laboratory data, the unexpected decrease of the stress ratio frequently observed on Dutch organic soft clays on the wet side of critical state is investigated by numerically back-analysing the triaxial test set-up. A 3D finite element simulation using an advanced constitutive model for soft clays developed at TU Delft was performed to clarify the nature of the response. The results indicate that a decrease in the deviatoric stress up to critical state may be interpreted as a true feature of the soil response. However, the response at large strains is very much influenced by the triaxial shear apparatus, in particular, by the rotation of the top cap which triggers geometrical instability. Practical recommendations are given to limit the effects of the set-up configuration on the determination of the undrained shear strength to be used for field applications
