Heated greenhouse cultivation in southern Tunisia constitutes a very important axis of agricultural development. Among the problems that are prejudicial to glasshouse tomato crops heated by geothermal waters, the newly introduced Tuta absoluta insect remains little studied in this agro-ecosystem. Biological means in the context of an integrated fight against this formidable pest to better understand the geothermal sector and contribute to the study of this new problem. The monitoring of a population of a native strain of Nesidiocoris tenuis installed naturally in the geothermal greenhouse and a population of one strain introduced into another greenhouse, showed the performance of the indigenous strain which multiplied rapidly and remained until the end of cultivation with a large population arriving at the total elimination of Tuta absoluta

Refki Ettaib

Directory of Open Access Journals

Journal of Oasis Agriculture and Sustainable Development 1 (1), 2019, 23-26 23    JOURNAL OF OASIS AGRICULTURE AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT www.joasdjournal.org  Comparison of strains of Nesidiocoris tenuis against Tuta absoluta (Meyrick) (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae) under geothermal greenhouses in southern Tunisia Refki Ettaib1, 2*, Faouzi Aoun1, Besma Assadi1,2,  Ali Ben Belgacem1 , Sabrine Chouikhi1,  Mohamed Sadok BelKadhi1,2 1 Arid and Oases Cropping Laboratory, Arid Area Institute Medenine 4119, Tunisia. 2Technical Center for Protected and Geothermal Crops (CTCPG), El Manara, 6011, BP 65 Gabes (Tunisia)  Article info  Abstract Article history: Received 22 June 2019 Accepted 25 July 2019 Heated greenhouse cultivation in southern Tunisia constitutes a very important axis of agricultural development. Among the problems that are prejudicial to glasshouse tomato crops heated by geothermal waters, the newly introduced Tuta absoluta insect remains little studied in this agro-ecosystem. Biological means in the context of an integrated fight against this formidable pest to better understand the geothermal sector and contribute to the study of this new problem. The monitoring of a population of a native strain of Nesidiocoris tenuis installed naturally in the geothermal greenhouse and a population of one strain introduced into another greenhouse, showed the performance of the indigenous strain which multiplied rapidly and remained until the end of cultivation with a large population arriving at the total elimination of Tuta absoluta. Keywords: Greenhouse, Tuta absoluta, native, Nesidiocoris tenuis.   Copyrightⓒ2019 JOASD  * Corresponding author Refki.ettaib1985@gmail.com  Conflict of Interest : The authors declare no conflict of interest  1. INTRODUCTION   The heated greenhouses sector has grown very rapidly. It has helped to promote production, create jobs and export to European markets in winter. This technique started in 1984 for the production of melon and tomato off season. The creation of of geothermal drilling aquifer to fill the deficit of irrigation water in the oases and to allow the development of irrigated perimeters was exploited to develop a new agricultural sector in the oasis regions; it is the production of greenhouses under glass heated by geothermal waters. Indeed, from its beginning  in the 80s, the sector has experienced  a rapid development. However, in order to prepare a sector development strategy, the latter stagnated from 1994 to resume a few years later, currently reaching 251.80 ha exploited. This area is distributed over the three main geoserricultural regions namely; the region of Gabes represented by 24652.1 (t) is 82% of the total production, followed by the region of Kebili represented by 3868.75 (t) is 13% of the total production, and finally the region of Tozeur with 1561 (t) representing 5% of the total production (CTCPG, 2019). Greenhouse crops are more vulnerable to fungal and viral diseases and pest attacks due to humidity and ambient temperature. Infestation can occur on aerial organs (stems, leaves, flowers, fruits) and / or on roots in an isolated or generalized manner. The main pests that develop on tomatoes are nematodes, insects or other arthropods (LANGE & BRONSON, 1981). Tomato growers in Tunisia are confronted with a new and formidable pest, known as Tuta absoluta (MEYRICK 1917), because of the considerable damage done to this greenhouse crop and in the open field (BADAOUI & BERKANI, 2010). The low efficiency of the chemical pesticides used (LIETTI et al., 2005, SANTOS et al., 2011). This pest is p-ISSN: 2724 – 699X e-ISSN: 2724-7007 Journal of Oasis Agriculture and Sustainable Development 1 (1), 2019, 23-26 24  considered a big obstacle to tomato production, due to its life cycle modeled on the cycle of tomato cultivation and the resulting losses that can reach 100% (LOURENÇÃO et al., 1985). The newly introduced pest finds Mediterranean coasts as a new habitat favorable for its multiplication (DESNEUX et al., 2010). It was discovered for the first time in the province of Castellon in Spain in 2006. This pest was quickly established in all Mediterranean and European countries (HARIZANOVA et al., 2009, STRATEN et al., 2011). In Tunisia, the first observations were noted in October 2008.    The appearance of Tuta absoluta has led to the involvement of the agricultural and scientific sector in research aimed at controlling it by various appropriate methods. Various means of protection against this pest have been reported (DESNEUX et al 2010). Prophylaxis and good management of this pest are essential. Chemical control is often doomed because of the resistance of Tuta absoluta to many pesticides but also because much of its development takes place inside the plant or in the soil, outside of the soil. treatment attainment. In terms of biological protection, several auxiliaries are reported and have proved effective. It is within this framework that we undertook this study which aims to highlight the performance of a predator chosen against Tuta absoluta, Mainly found in tropical regions N. tenuis is a small green bugs, appearing spontaneously in greenhouses or tunnels where few insecticides are applied. It has long legs with which she moves quickly, even on the hairy leaves of the tomato.    Fig.1.Life cycle of N. tenuis (El Dessouki, et al, 1976).  The life cycle of N. tenuis comprises three stages: egg, nymph and adult (El Dessouki El I, et al, 1976),(Fig 1) .The eggs are oval concave and transparent in color. The female lays its eggs in the plant tissue of the leaf. After about ten days, the nymphs release eggs. There are five nymphal stages. In the early stages, nymphs are yellow-green, but older nymphs turn bright green, and look like adults, but without wings (El Dessouki et al., 1976). In the last two stages, we see the beginning of wing development. The five nymphal stages last a total of twenty days at a temperature of 25 ° C. Females live about 40 days, but males can live a little longer. A female lays in total between 100 and 250 eggs, depending on the temperature and the food. The purpose of this experiment is to compare the efficacy of two strains of N. tenuis, a predator of T. absoluta, one native to naturally established geothermal greenhouses at the El Khbayett site, and the other is introduced into a greenhouse in the Bazma geothermal site.  2. MATERIAL AND METHODS  1000 adult N. tenuis individuals were introduced into a 500 m2 greenhouse at the Bazma geothermal site at Kebili. This greenhouse is grown continuously tomato with 1200 plants spread over 8 lines twinned. The adults of the predator are distributed in the greenhouse in a homogeneous way. Follow-up began three days after the introduction of N. tenuis. Each line was divided into 4 identical micro plots, from each micro plot a plant was selected for sampling where 3 leaves were pulled out at the 3 levels of the plant (low, medium and high). The samples of each plant are put in a plastic bag bearing all the necessary indications. In total there are 48 samples to be analyzed in the laboratory under a binocular loupe. The analysis consists of counting T. absoluta larvae present in the leaves as well as lymphocytes and adults of N. tenuis. In parallel with this monitoring, the same sampling protocol was applied in the greenhouse of the El Khbayet geothermal site. But in this case the predator has been already installed naturally. For this reason, the evaluation of the population at the start of the follow-up was carried out in order to compare it with the strain introduced. Journal of Oasis Agriculture and Sustainable Development 1 (1), 2019, 23-26 25    3. RESULTS Two strains of N. tenuis, predator of T. absoluta, one of which is indigenous naturally established in the geothermal greenhouses at  Khbayett site, and the other introduced into a greenhouse at Bazma geothermal site, have object of the follow-up for the comparison of their potential of control of the population of Tuta absoluta.  Fig.2.Evolution of adult populations of T. absoluta and N. tenuis introduced. Concerning the introduced strain of the predator, the analysis of the evolution curve of its population following its introduction into the greenhouse grown tomato infested by Tuta absoluta, shows a total disappearance of the whole population introduced during a week. Moreover, despite the presence of different stages of development of Tuta absoluta on which N. tenuis can multiply, no descendant of the introduced population has been encountered.(Fig 2) This shows that the introduced adults suffered a shock as soon as they were placed in the greenhouse before they even started egg-laying. The rapid disappearance of individuals introduced from N. tenuis could be the consequence of factors inherent in the strain itself (sensitivity to one of the abiotic factors, lack of adaptability, etc.).  Fig.3.Evolution of adult populations of T. absoluta and native N. tenuis According to the evolution curve of T. absoluta populations, we also note that the introduction of this strain of N. tenuis coincided with a population of T. absoluta represented almost completely by the egg stage. Indeed, the emergence of adults of Tuta absoluta was brutal after about a month, enough time to go from the egg to the adult, the date of introduction of the predator, (Fig 3). The dominance of the egg stage in the population of Tuta absoluta during the introduction of N. tenuis, could also be at the origin of its abrupt and total disappearance. In the case of the local strain of N. tenuis, the analysis of evolution of its population dice of its appearance in the greenhouse, shows that the population of the latter increases rapidly with the increase of the population of Tuta absoluta. From the fourth week, the pest population decreases rapidly, while that of the predator increases remarkably 4. Discussion Nesidiocoris tenuis is an important predator of the three main pests of tobacco crops: Trialeuro desvaporariorum, Bemisia tabaci and Myzuspersicae (Valderrama et al, 2007).The effectiveness of the use of native N. tenuis at various stages of development, was evaluated, indeed; adults and nymphs of N. tenuis placed in all stages of development of T. absoluta, feed with a high preference on eggs (total eggs and L1 were 17.75 ± 0.95 and 3, 25 ± 0.50, respectively p = 0.019 <0.05, as evidenced by the drastic decrease in predation in the advance of pest development. On the other hand, the third nymph of the predator presented the largest effect on larval L1 and L2 larvae, (1.5 ± 0.57 and 1.25 ± 0.50 predated individuals, respectively) compared to other nymphs and adults of N. tenuis (Ettaib et al 2016). The native strain of Nesidiocoris tenuis, predator of T. absoluta, naturally installed in the geothermal greenhouse, showed its performance to multiply rapidly and to maintain itself until the end of the crop. During its life cycle, an N. tenuis is able to attack about 25 individuals (Ettaib et al, 2016), regardless of the stage of development of Tuta absoluta. Indeed, the study of the biotic potential of T. absoluta has shown that the descendants of a T. absoluta couple are on average 250 adults. We can deduce that 10 Journal of Oasis Agriculture and Sustainable Development 1 (1), 2019, 23-26 26  individuals of N. tenuis are sufficient to completely destroy the descendants of a couple of this pest. Noting that a couple of N. tenuis gives about 200 individuals,(El Dessouki, et al, 1976) they are able to attack 5000 individuals of T. absoluta, which are the descendants of 20 pairs. According to these results the introduction of N. tenuis as a predator in the context of integrated control can be effective with well-defined doses in relation to the population of T. absoluta occupying the geothermal greenhouse. Indeed, the application of the necessary dose of N. tenuis protects greenhouse culture from the phytophage effect of our predator. At the end of cultivation, the population of T. absoluta became nil, while that of the predator, became very important so that it began to feed on the different parts of the culture thus becoming phytophagous and causing damage on tomato fruit on leaves and stems. This phytophagous behavior of N. tenuis was observed when the population of the latter has exceeded 18 adults per plant. CONCLUSION The monitoring of a population of a native strain naturally installed in the geothermal greenhouse and a population of a strain introduced into another greenhouse, showed the performance of the indigenous strain which multiplied rapidly and remained at the end of cultivation with a strong population arriving at the total elimination of Tuta absoluta.   « This project is carried out under the MOBIDOC scheme, funded by the EU through the EMORI program and managed by the ANPR » REFERENCES   Badaoui M.I., Berkani A .(2010). Morphologie et comparaison des appareils génitaux de     deux espèces invasive Tuta absoluta Meyrick 1917 et Phthorimaeaoperculella Zeller 1873 (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae). Faunistic Entomology 63(3): 191-194. CTCPG ,(2019),Le Centre Technique des Cultures Protégées et Géothermiques. Desneux N, Wajnberg E, Wyckhuys K, Burgio G, Arpaia S, Narvaez- Vasquez C, Gonzalez-Cabrera J, Catalan Ruescas D, Tabone E, Frandon J, Pizzol J, Poncet C, Cabello T, Urbaneja A .2010.Biological invasion of European tomato crops by Tuta absoluta: ecology, geographic expansion and prospects for biological control. J Pest Sci 83:197–215. El-Dessouki, S.A., El-Kifl, A.H., Helal, H.A. (1976) Life cicle, hosts plants and symptoms of damage of the tomato bug, Nesidiocoris tenuis Reut. (Heteroptera: Miridae), in Egypt. Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection 83,204–220. Ettaib Refki, Belkadhi Mohamed Sadok and Ben Belgacem Ali; (2016) Study of the biotic potential of indigenous predator Nesidiocoris tenuis on Tuta absoluta pest of geothermal culture in the south of Tunisia journal of entomology and zoology studies 4(6):692-695. Harizanova V., Stoeva A. & Mohamedova M. (2009). Tomato leaf miner, Tuta absoluta (Povolny) (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae) first record in Bulgaria. Agricultural Science and Technology 1(3): 95-98. Lange W.H. & Bronson L. (1981). Insect Pests of Tomatoes. Annual Review of Entomology 26: 345-371 Lietti M.M.M., Botto E. & Alzogaray R.A.( 2005). Insecticide resistance in Argentine populations of Tuta absoluta (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae). Neotropical Entomology 34(1): 113–119. Lourenção A.L., Nagai H., Siqueira W.J. & Fonseca M.I.S.(1985). Seleção de linhagens de tomateiro resistentes a Scrobipalpula absoluta (Meyrick). Horticultura Brasileira 3: 77. Santos dos A.C., Bueno R.C.O. de F., Vieira S.S. &Bueno A. de F.(2011). Efficacy of insecticides on Tuta absoluta (Meyrick) and other pests in pole tomato. BioAssay 6(4): 1-6. Straten van der M.J., Potting R.P.J. & Linden van der A. (2011). Introduction of the tomato leafminer Tuta absoluta into Europe pages 23-30. In: Proceedings of the Netherlands Entomological Society Meeting 22, Netherlands. Valderarama Katrine, Jaime Granobles, Edison Valencia , Manuel Sanchez5 (2007); Nesidiocoris tenuis (Hemiptera: Miridae) depredador en el cultivo de tabaco (Nicotiana tabacum); Revistacolom biana de entomologıá 33(2):141-145.    

Comparison of strains of Nesidiocoris tenuis against Tuta absoluta (Meyrick) (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae) under geothermal greenhouses in southern Tunisia

https://www.joasdjournal.org/index.php/joasd/article/download/15/19

Comparison of strains of Nesidiocoris tenuis against Tuta absoluta (Meyrick) (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae) under geothermal greenhouses in southern Tunisia

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

Directory of Open Access Journals