Mid-air haptic technology can render a plethora of tactile sensations including points, lines, shapes, and textures. To do so, one requires increasingly complex haptic displays. Meanwhile, tactile illusions have had widespread success in the development of contact and wearable haptic displays. In this paper, we exploit the apparent tactile motion illusion to display mid-air haptic directional lines; a prerequisite for the rendering of shapes and icons. We present two pilot studies and a psychophysical study that contrasts a dynamic tactile pointer (DTP) to an apparent tactile pointer (ATP) in terms of direction recognition. To that end, we identify optimal duration and direction parameters for both DTP and ATP mid-air haptic lines and discuss the implications of our findings with respect to haptic feedback design, and device complexity
