OBJECTIVES: The Management Of Myelomeningocele Study (MOMS) trial demonstrated the safety and efficacy of open fetal surgery for spina bifida (SB). Recently developed alternative techniques may reduce maternal risks yet should do without compromising on fetal neuroprotective effects. We aimed to assess the learning curve of different fetal SB closure techniques. METHODS: We searched Medline, Web of Science, Embase, Scopus and Cochrane databases and the grey literature to identify relevant articles without language restriction from January 1980 until October 2018. We systematically reviewed and selected studies reporting all consecutive procedures and with a postnatal follow-up ≥12 months. They also had to report outcome variables necessary to measure the learning curve defined by fetal safety and efficacy. Two independent authors retrieved the data, assessed the quality of the studies and categorized observations into blocks of 30 patients. For meta-analysis, data were pooled using a random-effect model when heterogeneous. To measure the learning curve, we used two complementary methods. With the group splitting method, competency was defined when the procedure provided comparable results to the MOMS trial for 12 outcome variables representative for (1) the immediate surgical outcome, (2) short-term neonatal neuroprotection and (3) long-term neuroprotection at ≥12 months. Then, when the patients' raw data were available, we performed cumulative sum (CUSUM) analysis based on a composite binary outcome defining a successful surgery. It combined four clinically relevant variables for safety (fetal death within 7 days) and for efficacy (neuroprotection at birth). RESULTS: We included 17/6024 (0.3%) studies with low and moderate risks of bias. Fetal SB closure was performed via standard-hysterotomy (n=11), mini-hysterotomy (n=1) or fetoscopy [exteriorized-uterus single-layer (n=1), percutaneous single-layer (n=3) or percutaneous two-layer closure (n=1)]. Only outcomes for the standard-hysterotomy could be meta-analyzed. Overall, outcomes significantly improved with experience. Competency was reached after 35 consecutive cases for standard-hysterotomy and was predicted to be achieved after ≥57 cases for mini-hysterotomy and ≥56 for percutaneous two-layer fetoscopy. For percutaneous and uterus-exteriorized single-layer fetoscopy, competency was not respectively reached by cases 81 and 28 available for analysis. CONCLUSIONS: The number of cases operated correlates with the outcome of SB fetal closure and ranges from 35 cases for standard-hysterotomy to ≥56-57 cases for minimally invasive modifications. Our observations provide important information for institutions eager to establish a new fetal center, develop a new technique or train their team, and inform referring clinicians, potential patients and third-parties
