Chemical substitution is commonly used to explore new ground states in
materials, yet the role of disorder is often overlooked. In Mn-substituted
BaFe2As2 (MnBFA), superconductivity (SC) is absent, despite being
observed for nominal hole-doped phases. Instead, a glassy magnetic phase
emerges, associated with the S=5/2 Mn local spins. In this work, we present a
comprehensive investigation of the electronic structure of MnBFA using
angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES). We find that Mn causes
electron pockets to shrink, disrupting the nesting condition in MnBFA. Notably,
we propose that electronic disorder, along with magnetic scattering, primarily
contributes to suppressing the itinerant magnetic order in MnBFA. This finding
connects the MnBFA electronic band structure properties to the glassy magnetic
behavior observed in these materials and suggests that SC is absent because of
the collective magnetic impurity behavior that scatters the Fe-derived
excitations. Moreover, we suggest that Mn tunes MnBFA to a phase in between the
correlated metal in BaFe2As2 and the Hund insulator phase in
BaMn2As2.Comment: main 7 pages, 3 figures + supp 5 pages, 5 figure