Smith, Jennifer J.

English

Digital Commons @ Butler University

The North Meridian Review Volume 2 Issue 1 Article 37 2021 Thomas Sanfilip. Conversations with Mona Lisa. Des Plaines, IL: Bigio Marato, 2019. Jennifer J. Smith Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.butler.edu/thenorthmeridianreview Recommended Citation Smith, Jennifer J. (2021) "Thomas Sanfilip. Conversations with Mona Lisa. Des Plaines, IL: Bigio Marato, 2019.," The North Meridian Review: Vol. 2 : Iss. 1 , Article 37. Retrieved from: https://digitalcommons.butler.edu/thenorthmeridianreview/vol2/iss1/37 This Book Review is brought to you for free and open access by Digital Commons @ Butler University. It has been accepted for inclusion in The North Meridian Review by an authorized editor of Digital Commons @ Butler University. For more information, please contact digitalscholarship@butler.edu.  205    Thomas Sanfilip. Conversations with Mona Lisa. Des Plaines, IL: Bigio Marato, 2019.  Reviewed by Jennifer J. Smith  Reading Thomas Sanfilip’s Conversations with Mona Lisa is a bit like looking at a Marc Chagall painting: the pieces are dreamlike, often ethereal, yet tethered to everyday reality. Sanfilip’s volume of prose poems and poetry paint images and scenes that blur around the edges. The book is divided into untitled, numbered sections, and the prose poems within each section contain recurring images or settings. One section focuses on a hospital room where the speaker’s sister is close to death, while another section evokes a day spent at the seaside. Sanfilip wishes to capture poetic consciousness as the speaker moves through and bumps into the world. More than a few pieces are dedicated to surreal dream sequences where the speaker seems to have found human connection only to awake and have missed it. These fragmented poems capture consciousness at those moments when it pauses before rushing on to the next image; in doing so, the book attempts to mirror the human psyche in its wanderings. An early piece invokes the eponymous Mona Lisa as muse. Sanfilip begins by establishing the setting: “The crowd pushes forward, the rapid fire of cameras clicking, flashes of light bouncing off the Plexiglas that shields the Mona Lisa from every conceivable assault of hot breath…yet under fire she remains poised and gazes out with all her enigmatic wiles intact, tranquil, calm, patient and eternal.” The speakers often resemble Leonardo da Vinci’s subject: aloof and ever present. They seem to be looking at the world through thick glass. He ends this same piece by directly addressing the woman at the center of the painting: “Help me find my way to your side where I can speak without  206  fear and listening become one beyond the murder of your light, beyond the weight of your bones. Give me your last smile as the day wanes and the sky bursts in a flash of dying blue” (p. 9). For me, the most compelling pieces were those tethered to a grounded reality. In a prosaic vignette, the speaker visits a library giving away books that have not circulated in twenty years, and the speaker finds “a worn out biography of Cezanne,” implying that it was once well loved and now obsolete. He next stumbles upon a book called The Pleasures of Antiquity, which prompts the speaker to “laugh at the irony of old books left rotting” (p. 52). In one of the pieces set at the seashore, Sanfilip captures what it feels like to be at the beach, writing, “There are moments the air drops into absolute silence. The waves meekly run to shore without any noise. Even the drone of a small airplane is muffled… a stillness, coming and going as though something muting the energies” (p. 81). His language here mirrors the sense of suspension that comes with sitting where water meets land.  The sense of suspension is also present in a powerful piece on a life-altering diagnosis of the speaker’s sister. Here he uses em-dashes to show the way that time contracts and elongates at moments where the body waits to see what will become of it: “doctor questioning her—pressing her swollen abdomen—we study her chest x-ray from the back—enlarged heart I mistake for the left lung” (p. 100). In this piece, as in the one on the Mona Lisa, the speaker approaches enigmatic images and tries to discern meaning. In many ways, all the pieces echo the questions that arise when he looks at Da Vinci’s masterpiece and the x-ray. What is real? What can be counted upon? What slips away? These are the central questions of Sanfilip’s volume. Jennifer J. Smith is an associate professor and chair of English at North Central College in Naperville, Illinois.         

Thomas Sanfilip. Conversations with Mona Lisa. Des Plaines, IL: Bigio Marato, 2019.

https://digitalcommons.butler.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1073&context=thenorthmeridianreview

Thomas Sanfilip. Conversations with Mona Lisa. Des Plaines, IL: Bigio Marato, 2019.

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

Digital Commons @ Butler University