Distinction between rhinovirus-induced acute asthma and asthma-augmented influenza infection

Abstract

Background: Rhinovirus (RV) is an established trigger of asthma attacks, whereas such a link is less consistent for influenza virus (IFV). Objective: In the context of precision medicine, we hypothesized that IFV infection may cause a condition essentially different from RV, and we investigated this by evaluating clinical characteristics of RV/IFV-positive and -negative children with respiratory symptoms and/or fever. Methods: One thousand two hundred and seven children, 6 months to 13 years old, hospitalized for flu-like illness were recruited in this cross-sectional study. Collected information included demographics, medical history, symptoms/physical findings/diagnosis at presentation and treatment. Nasal secretions were PCR-tested for IFV/RV. Associations were evaluated with adjusted logistic regression models. Results: Rhinovirus positivity was associated with an asthma-like presentation, including increased wheeze/effort of breathing/diagnosis of acute asthma, and decreased fever/vomiting. Conversely, IFV+ children presented with less wheeze/effort of breathing/diagnosis of acute asthma, while they were more frequently febrile. In those with previous asthma history, both viruses induced wheeze; however, IFV was uniquely associated with a more generalised and severe presentation including fever, rales, intercostal muscle retractions and lymphadenopathy. These symptoms were not seen in RV+ asthmatics, who had fewer systemic signs and more cough. Conclusions and Clinical relevance: In children with respiratory symptoms and/or fever, RV but not IFV is associated with wheeze and an asthma-like presentation. In those with an asthma history, IFV causes more generalised and severe disease that may be better described as “asthma-augmented influenza” rather than an “asthma attack.” Differences in the acute conditions caused by these viruses should be considered in the design of epidemiological studies. © 2018 John Wiley & Sons Lt