Quantum-classical correspondence in spin-boson equilibrium states at arbitrary coupling

Abstract

It is known that the equilibrium properties of nanoscale systems can deviate significantly from standard thermodynamics due to their coupling to an environment. For the generalized $\theta$-angled spin-boson model, here we derive an explicit form of the classical mean force equilibrium state. Taking the large spin limit of the quantum spin-boson model, we demonstrate that the quantum-classical correspondence is maintained at arbitrary coupling strength. This correspondence gives insight into the conditions for a quantum system to be well-approximated by its classical counterpart. We further demonstrate that, counterintuitively, previously identified environment-induced 'coherences' in the equilibrium state of weakly coupled quantum spins, do not disappear in the classical case. Finally, we categorise various coupling regimes, from ultra-weak to ultra-strong, and find that the same value of coupling strength can either be 'weak' or 'strong', depending on whether the system is quantum or classical. Our results shed light on the interplay of quantum and mean force corrections in equilibrium states of the spin-boson model, and will help draw the quantum to classical boundary in a range of fields, such as magnetism and exciton dynamics