Minnen, P. van

Worp, K.A.

NARCIS 

A New Edition of Ostraka from Akoris

Leiden University Scholary Publications

PETER VAN M I N N E N and KLAAS A. WORPA New Edition of Ostraka from AkorisIn a recently published report on Japanese excavations at Akoris1 some Greek andCoptic ostraka found at this site are presented. Their provenance gives these texts somespecial interest, as they come from a part of Egypt where ostraka are rare2. As we feelthat the transcripts are not satisfactory, we present our own (new) transcripts of the Greekostraka made on the basis of the plates accompanying the ed. princ.3. Given the numerousdivergences between our own texts and the ed. princ. it would be tedious to indicate thesesystematically; therefore, we refrain from doing so. Judging by palaeographical criteriathese ostraka all date from the late Byzantine or early Arab period4.1. A Receipt for Poll-Tax and Another Tax (?)(p. 52, first text, pi. 18, 9)\ t £ói<5> uióq 'Evoix 'Avouq>(iou) (öjtèp) dvS(piauoG) T|2 tcsp(ÓTia) SeKarcévTE, y(tveiai) K(Epdtta) IE nó(va).3 t ó(ioi(tü5) (ÓTtèp) TEtpaK(epaTiou) KEp(ÓTia) 5óo fjfiici),4 y(ivETai) K(epdTta) Pi. (jó(va). èyp(dipt)) riaoö(vi) iv5(iKtitovoi;) ópx(tj)iy8(iKTicovoi;) TJ.5 'Iaxïv(vr|i;) Pon.(9ó<;) CJTOIX(EÏ). t2. ïe Ostr. 5. ïüwvtvTjc,) aroïx(eO Ostr.! Preliminary Report Sixlh Seas&n of the Excavations at the Site of Akoris. Egypt, 1986. Ed. by HiroyukiKawanishi and Sumiyo Tsujimura, The Paleological Association of Japan., Inc., Kyoto 1988. The present stateof our knowledge regarding Akoris is conveniently suramed up by E. Bemand in the introduction to hisInscriptions grecques et lalines d'Akoris. Le Caire 1988, vii —xxv. (Bibliothèque d'Etude 103).2 In Orientalia 54 (1985) plate xxvi, fig. 38 there is an unpublished demoüc ostrakon from Akoris. InASAE 6 (1905) 142 one finds an announcemenl of the discovery of Coptic ostraka at Akoris; as far as weknow, they have not been published.3 No transcript is given for the (barely legible) ostrakon illustrated on pi. 20, I.4 When we showed a draft of this article lo Prof. R. S. Bagnall (New York) in November 1989 hè pointedout to us thal hè had rough transcripts of nos. 1-4 made by Worp and him in June 1987, on the basis ofphotographs received from J. Jarry through the intermediary of Th. Drew-Bear (Lyon). The substance, bulnot transcripts. had been comraunicated to Jarry at that time. These transcripts accord closely with teMs nos.I -4 as published in our article. We are grateful to Prof. Bagnall for his informations and for his kind readinessto correct our 'Englutch'. We are also grateful to Prof J. Gascou (Strasbourg), to whom we owe suggestionsfor our better understanding of texts l and 5.96 Peter van Minnen and Klaas A. Worp"Soi(s), son of Henoch, the son of Anouphios, (has paid) for andrismos of the 8thindiction fifteen carats, i. e. 15 c. in total. Likewise, for tetrakeration two and a half carats,i. e. 2.5 c. in total. This (receipt) was written in Pauni at the start of the 8'h indiction. I,John, assistant. arn satisfied."1. One may prefer to regard lói as an undeclined Egyptian name, i. e. as a nominative without an endingon -c,; for this question and the problems involved cf. P. J. Sijpesteijn, ZPE 64 (1986) 119- 120; cf. also infraleut 3, 2 n.Henoch, son of Anouphis, also occurs in the following text.2. For the tai called èv5pia|ió; (the poll-tax in the early Arab period) cf. Wilcken, Griauküge, pp 235 - 2363. J. Gascou points out to us that a payment for TeipaKEp(aTiou) refers to a supplementary tax of 4 caratsto the solidus. making a supplementary payment of 2.5 carats to the 15 carats mentioned in line 2. He identifiesthe same tax in O.Edfou I 211, l - 2 (cf. the new editton of O.Edfou UI 322 by B. Pahne, ZPE 64 [1986] 92f,note to 1. 2; ed. pr.: T£TpaK£p(autov)] and compares the supplementary tax of 6 carats to the solidus occurringin some late Byzantine texts, cf. R. Rémondon, CdE 40 (1%5) 425-426 (add to the attestations cited there:P.Laur. III 112,6; 113,8; 116,10; 122,9; P.Strasb. 660,3). For the word terpaKtpaTiov cf. also the inscriptionfrom Caesarea (Palaestina) published by B. Lifshitz, REG 70 (1957) 119- 132, esp. 120, n 7 and 124-125 (notentered into the SEG; reference courtesy of J. Gascou).4. It is remarkable that the scribe would have omicted the numeral for the day in Pauni. Did hè commitsome form of haplography, and was Pauni 10 intended? Likewise, the repetition of the (abbreviated) wordtvSucriravoi; is remarkable. For indictions starting m Pauni cf. R. S. Bagnall. K. A. Worp, Cfironological Systemso/Byzanline Egypl, Appendix A, I, pp. 56-57 and ZPE 56 (1984) 135- 136.5. The assistant John occurs also in the following text.2. A Receipt for Some Money Payment(p. 52, second text, pi. 19, upper)1 t 'Evröx 'Avoixpiou (Cutèp) [ ]2 S(iii) W>(you) ®£o8o>(pou) 'Avou(p(iou) KeK(£pdna) - uó(va).]3 Eyp(dq>r|) M£a<op>f| ór5(ÓTj). 'Io>d(wn<;)"Henoch, son of Anouphios, (has paid) for - - - through the account of Theodoros,son of Anouphios, four + ? (or: forty + ?) carats, i. e. - carats in total. This (receipt)was written on Mesore the eighth. I, John, assistant, am satisfied."1. For Henoch, son of Anouphis, cf. the precedmg text. The man occurring in 1. 2, Theodore, son ofAnouphios, may have been bis brother.3. An Order for Oil(p. 52, third text, pi. 18, 7)1 f 'AyEvfj éXaioupy(a)- napddx(ou) IlauXri2 (xai) Mooi (üntÊp) f}oeX( ) èX(aiou) 4(écrTa?) S, (yivovtai) TéoxraXa;.3 ] XoidK // £ tvStncTiawo?) a.1. 'AYEVEÏ 2. uouï Ostr. tteoapE?"To Agenes, oil-manufacturer. Deliver to Paule and Moui(s) for ox-drivers 4 sextariiof oil, i. e. four. Choiak 7 of the l" indiction."A New Edition of Ostraka from Akoris 971. The same oil-manufacturer Agenes occurs in the foliowing text 4. The name Agenes occurs also in anumber of Christian inscriptions from Tehneh/ Akoris, cf. Lef. 118 and 164 as well as BIFAO 3 (1903) 92-93,nos. 43 and 45. But its use is not restricted 1o Middle Egypt (as was supposed by W. E. Crum, P.Ryl. copt. p.90 n. 4), cf. O.Mich. I 269, l and BGU VII 1587,7 (both from the Fayum); furthermore, there may be aconnection with comparable names like 'Ayévioc;/ 'Ayévit;, which are attested in the Arsinoite and OxyrhynchiteNomes (BGU VII 1630, B, 31; P.Flor. I 65) For other Coptic occurrences of this name cf. G. Heuser,Prosopographie von Agypten, IV: Die Kopten, Heidelberg 1938 (Quellen und Studiën zur Geschichte und Kui t urdes Altertums und des Mittelalters, Reihe C: Hilfsbücher, 2), 15, s. n.We consider ITauXïi as a variant forra of the well-known name FlaüXoi; (FlaüXe), cf. F. Preisigke, Namenbuch,s n. Though a female variant of this name, se. naüXn, is listed there, we do not think that we are dealing herewith a female person. Apparently one is dealing in this text with au undeclined form of the name, as one needsa dative form. We assume that this man is not the same person as the yeast-maker Paule occurring in text 4,3, cf. our note ad loc and below. our note to \. 2. Again, Lef. 164 provides us with a direct parallel from Akorisfor the name riuuXiT2. For the undeclined form of the name Moois (gen. MOÓÏTO^) cf. supra, text l, l n. If the name weredeclined, a dative form Moóm would be needed here.With the resolution of the word jJoeX( ) as fk)eX(aTft)v), there is no indication of how many ox-dnvers wereto be the recipients of these 4 sextani. One may also consider a resolution of the abbreviation as fioe^axriat;),i. e. in that case Paul and Mouis would be the two ox-dnvers concerned. Daily allowances could vary pret tvcoosiderably, cf. J. Gascou, K. A. Worp, Un dossier dostraca du VF siècle, les archivesdes huiliers d'Aphrodite(in La Charta Borgtana. Miscellanea Papyroiogicaper il bicentenario deliedizione di Niels Schow, ed. R. Pintaudi,Firenze 1990, 217-244 [Papyroiogica Horentina 19]).3. There are some ink traces at the start of this line which we have not been able to read. One might thinkof, e. g., some form of èyp(6«pn), but we cannot read this and in the following text 4, also addressed to Agenes,it is also lacking.4. An Order for Oil(p. 53, first text, pi. 19, lower)1 t 'AyevfJ2 Jtapdcrx(ou) Kup(iot<;)3 IlauXri (Kai) OoiOdnuxovt) £o|i(oupyoï<;)4 èX(aiou) ^(éaTai;) y, ipsti;.5 Töpi // K£ tv8(iKna>vo<;) q..6 t t t"To Agenes, oil-manufacturer. Deliver to Messrs. Paule and Phoibammon the yeast-makers (?) 3 sextarii of oil, i. e. three. Tubi 27 of the l" (?) indiction."1. The oil-manufacturcr Agenes occurs also in the preceding text 3.2. There is in the center part of this line a certain amount of ink which we cannot read/ interpret withconfidence. This may be onty a rather long diagonal stroke sloping downwards from to the hght hand upperpart of the y_ and indicating the abbreviation.3. Probably not the same Paule as in the preceding text 3,1, since hè is labelled here icüpio; (cf. E. Rom,H. Harrauer, ZPE 63 [1983] 111-115); cf. also above, text 3, 2 n.The word ^U^OUPYÓC has not yet occurred in Byzantine papyri or ostraka, but CUHTJ is found in someByzantme documents. Cf. E. Battaglia, 'ARTOS'. Il lessico della panificazione nei papiri greci, Milano 1989^185.98 Peter van Minnen and Klaas A. Worp5. A Receipt for 30 Dipla of Some Commodity(p. 54, first text, pi. 22, lower)1 f ^anCevtoje 5 18 l[v]5(iKti<avo?)-2 d-fia Mapia ji( ) 6(iitXa) X <pop(d)5(o<;) ÖEv[té-] */ *3 pa?, f 2evr\po<; aroixeï. t2. MJ Ostr."Phamenoth 4 of the 14th indiction. The Holy Mary (church/ monastery?), 30 diplaof (or: for?) the 2nd instalment. I, Severus, am satisfied."2. This line is problematical. The words &fia Mapia suggest to us that one is dealing with a monasteryor a church dedicated to the Holy Mary; we do nol expect a living woman Maria lo be labelled óyio. andfor that reason an interpretation of u( ) as n(ovü£ou<ra) vel sim. is excluded. On the other hand. we do notexpect the Greek to read dyia Mapia u(ova<rrf|piov); we would rather expect novaonipiov rr^i; a-yiac. Mapiui;or at least f\ dyia Mapia (cf. P.Bad. IV 95, 169. 171 and 180: elq rrjv oyiav Map(iav), but. as J. Gascou kindlypoints out to us, there are no Greek papyrus documents referring to a uovaoTfjpiov Tfjt; uylai; Mapia<; in theHermopolite Nome; this name is found only in connection with a church in Hermopolis itself. For a religieusestablishment dedicated to the Holy Virgin in this Northern part of the Hermopolite Nome see S. Timm, Daschristlich-koptische Agypten in arabischer Zeil, Wiesbaden 1984. II 817-823 s. n. Der at-'Adra; it is also knownas Der al-Tayr (10 kilometers to the north of Akoris); cf. also M. Martin, La province d'Ashnünayn: historiquede sa configuration religieuse, Annales Islamologiques 23 (1987) 1-29, esp. 10.The rest of this line yields problems as well. We reckon with the possibility that u( ) should be taken asan abbreviation of a product packed in 5(mXa); though we can devise expansions of the abbreviation likeu(sXitoi;) = "honey"5 or U(OUCTTOU) (se. otvou) = "must", we have not found any instance of these productspacked in or measured by 5tni.a6 and if the produce were must, the lack of the noun oivou would be disturbing.as in other documents the adjective uouo-roi) is not found without it. In all cases, moreover, one must assuraethat the name of the product in question has been abbreviated very radically and this may form an argumentagainst this line of thinking.We have also considered the possibility that u$S~ stands for (i(o)S(ioui;), but thts solution should probablybe rejected, as it is norma] to find uoSiou<;abbreviatedasu.os. Moreover, one would expect the product measuredin modii (or, for that matter, in Sin^d) to have been indicated expressis verbis.To sum up: whether one takes us as an abbreviation of rtovdCouoa) / u(ovaciTii piov), u.(éXtToi;), u(ouorou lor (together with the followimï delta) as representing u(o)5(iou!;), there remain problems with each of theseinterpretations.One may also wish to read ï, i. e. prolong the abbreviation marking of S~ to the right.For (pope = "instalment" cf. H. I. Bell, Wadt Sarga. Coptic and Greek Texts edited by W E. Crum andH. 1. Bell, Copenhagen 1922, 1 05 ff. Cf. also H. C. Youtie, Scriptiunculae posteriores I 299 - 300; II 517 Giventhe delta wntten in superposition we must read (pop(ó)o(O(;) here. It remains to be seen, whether in all comparablecases, where an abbreviation cpop( ) has been resolved as <pop(a<;), a resolution tpop(döot;) (for this word formcf SPP Vin 1257) should be substituted.6. A Receipt ^>^ « 9 'hé} J(p. 54, second text, pi. 22, upper)1 f e p M I N C T7M1TOI2 fl>aw(pi c TEuöépai;5 For honey in the papyri cf. now H. Chouhara-Raïos, L'abeille ft Ie miei en Egypte d'après les papyrus.loannina 1989.6 Usually one finds SiitXö used for packing meat, wine or fish, cf. R. Fleischer, Measures and Containersm Greek and Roman Egypt, Diss. New York 1956, 12.r A New Edition of Ostraka from Akoris 993 iv{i}5(iKTicovoq) TEKo6r|ou,4 (yivETav) £( ) t|3 uó(va) t-2. SEUTEpac, 3. ïviö/ Ostr., &£Ka5óo."Hermine the soldier. Phaophi 6 of the second indiction. He (delivered / received)twelve — — , i. e. 12 in total."l. This line is in Coptic. The errors in the following unes (for interchange of T/ 8 cf. F. T. Gignac. GrammarI 80 (T.) show that the scribe was not very fiuent in Greek4. We are not quite certain about our reading of a zeta written in ligature with a preceding diagonal.representing an abbreviated (yivEtat) / (yivovrai). If our reading is correct, one may solve the abbreviation as,e. g.. ^(eCyn)- this would mean that 12 pairs of some commodity (e. g. loaves of bread?) could be involved. Itwould seem more likely, then. that Ihe soldier Herminos received these, than that hè delivered these. One wouldexpect the commodity to have been mentioned already earhcr on in thïs text. i. e. in I. 3 before TEKaSrjou. butapparently the scribe omitted this.7. A Fragment(p. 53, middle, pi. 18, 8) *>fy 1^ / <? épfJóScopoi;The editor restores the name as 0£]ó8copo;, but in itself there is no objection againstanother name ending on -óScapoc;, e. g. Aiovuo]ó5<opoi;.Peter van Minnen Klaas A. WorpPapyrologisch Instituut Archaeologisch-historisch InstituutRijksuniversiteit te Leiden Universiteit van AmsterdamWitte Singel 27 Oude Turfmarkt 129NL-2311 BG Leiden NL-1012 GC Amsterdam

https://scholarlypublications.universiteitleiden.nl/access/item%3A2864205/download

A New Edition of Ostraka from Akoris

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

NARCIS

Leiden University Scholary Publications