Mining masculinities in the Canadian military

Gender is a contested category of analysis, generally understood to describe the characteristics and practices of its end products, men and women. Alternatively, this interdisciplinary study of changing masculinity in the Canadian Forces conceptualizes gender as characterizing the social worlds that people inhabit, worlds through which they are constructed and reconstructed as gendered beings, and which they negotiate, change or resist. The military has been selected as the investigative terrain because military technology--a social system comprising human and material resources--has been under-researched as a matrix of gender in the West. The conceptual framework for this study draws on linkages between gender constructs and warfare practices in various small-scale societies, and on comparisons between the organization and practice of warfare in pre-state versus archaic state societies. The result of this comparative framework is the problematization of certain structural features of the contemporary Forces, features which address one of it core preoccupations: engendering and sustaining bellicosity in its combatants, and obviating their resistance. These technologically rationalized features, shown to be historically anomalous, are designed to control how soldiers think about and carry out their deadly work. The study employs a triangulated methodology to gather data from interviews, written texts, and participant observation. Narrative analysis of this data affords a gendered mapping of military social practice and thought, culminating in the military gendering of human lives and deaths. Women, in their multiple feminine incarnations, are revealed for the threats which they pose to the Forces' 'operational effectiveness'--constructed as homogeneously masculine. Herein lie the ideological and practical reasons why 'gender integration' in the Forces--ordered in a 1989 Canadian Human Rights Tribunal ruling--may be an oxymoron, and why women more readily resist military authoritarianism than men

Women soldiers: the enemy within

Die Integration von Frauen in die bewaffneten Streitkraefte ist eine viel diskutierte Frage in fast allen fortgeschrittenen Industriegesellschaften. Der vorliegende Beitrag rekonstruiert die Debatten um diese Frage und die verschiedenen Loesungsversuche fuer dieses Problem in der kanadischen Gesellschaft seit Anfang der 90er Jahre. Die Studie ist Teil eines Projekts, dass sich mit der militaerischen Konstruktion des Geschlechterverhaeltnisses und insbesondere den Vorstellungen ueber Maennlichkeit befasst. Der ideologische Kernkomplex liegt dabei in der Sphaere des Kampfes und in den Bildern vom Sterben und Tod auf dem Schlachtfeld. Die Rolle der Frau wird dabei antithetisch und komplementaer der Sphaere des 'Lebens' zugeschlagen. Die Studie zeigt insgesamt am Selbstverstaendnis des (maennlichen) kanadischen Militaers, wie stark solche Ideologeme bzw. Vorstellungen das Geschlechterverhaeltnis praegen und wie sie Versuche der Gleichberechtigung blockieren. (ICA)German title: Weibliche Soldaten: der innere FeindAvailable from UuStB Koeln(38)-20010106530 / FIZ - Fachinformationszzentrum Karlsruhe / TIB - Technische InformationsbibliothekSIGLEDEGerman