Understanding analogical reasoning : viewpoints from psychology and related disciplines

Analogy and metaphor have a long history of study in linguistics, education, philosophy and psychology. Consensus over what analogy is or how analogy functions in language and thought, however, has been elusive. This paper, the first in a two part series, examines these various research traditions, attempting to bring out major lines of agreement over the role of analogy in individual human experience. As well as being a general literature review which may be helpful for newcomers to the study of analogy, this paper attempts to extract from these literatures existing theories, models and concepts which may be interesting or useful for computational studies of analogical reasoning

Instability of time-periodic flows

The instabilities of some spatially and/or time-periodic flows are discussed, in particular, flows with curved streamlines which can support Taylor-Gortler vortices are described in detail. The simplest flow where this type of instability can occur is that due to the torsional oscillations of an infinitely long circular cylinder. For more complicated spatially varying time-periodic flows, a similar type of instability can occur and is spatially localized near the most unstable positions. When nonlinear effects are considered it is found that the instability modifies the steady streaming boundary layer induced by the oscillatory motion. It is shown that a rapidly rotating cylinder in a uniform flow is susceptible to a related type of instability; the appropriate stability equations are shown to be identical to those which govern the instability of a boussinesq fluid of Prandtl number unity heated time periodically from below

The evolution equations for Taylor vortices in the small gap limit

The centrifugal instability of the viscous fluid flow between concentric circular cylinders in the small gap limit is considered. The amplitude of the Taylor vortex is allowed to depend on a slow time variable, a slow axial variable, and the polar angle. It is shown that the amplitude of the vortex cannot in general be described by a single amplitude equation. However, if the axial variations are periodic a single amplitude equation can be derived. In the absence of any slow axial variations it is shown that a Taylor vortex remains stable to wavy vortex perturbations. Furthermore, in this situation, stable nonaxisymmetric modes can occur but do not bifurcate from the Taylor vortex state. The stability of these modes is shown to be governed by a modified form of the Eckhaus criterion

Taylor-Goertler instabilities of Tollmien-Schlichting waves and other flows governed by the interactive boundary layer equations

The Taylor-Gortler vortex instability equations are formulated for steady and unsteady interacting boundary layer flows of the type which arise in triple-deck theory. The effective Gortler number is shown to be a function of the all shape in the boundary layer and the possibility of both steady and unsteady Taylor-Gortler modes exists. As an example the steady flow in a symmetrically constricted channel is considered and it is shown that unstable Gortler vortices exist before the boundary layers at the wall develop the Goldstein singularity. As an example of an unsteady spatially varying basic state the instability of high frequency large amplitude Tollmien-Schlichting waves in a curved channel were considered. It is shown that they are unstable in the first Stokes layer stage of the hierarchy of nonlinear states. The Tollmien-Schlichting waves are shown to be unstable in the presence of both convex and concave curvature

An asymptotic investigation of the stationary modes of instability of the boundary layer on a rotating disc

An investigation of high Reynolds number stationary instabilities in the boundary layer on a rotating disc is given. It is shown that in addition to the inviscid mode at high Reynolds numbers, there is a stationary short wavelength mode. This mode has its structure fixed by a balance between viscous and Coriolis forces and cannot be described by an inviscid theory. The asymptotic structure of the wavenumber and orientation of this mode is obtained. A similar analysis is given for the inviscid mode, the expansion procedure used is capable of taking nonparallel effects into account in a self consistent manner. The results are compared to numerical calculations and experimental observations

Can Thomas Kuhn's paradigms help us understand software engineering

Peer reviewe

The impact of using pair programming on system evolution a simulation-based study

In this paper we investigate the impact of pair--programming on the long term evolution of software systems. We use system dynamics to build simulation models which predict the trend in system growth with and without pair programming. Initial results suggest that the extra effort needed for two people to code together may generate sufficient benefit to justify pair programming.Peer reviewe

On the interaction of Tollmien-Schlichting waves in axisymmetric supersonic flows

Two-dimensional lower branch Tollmien-Schlichting waves described by triple-deck theory are always stable for planar supersonic flows. The possible occurrence of axisymmetric unstable modes in the supersonic flow around an axisymmetric body is investigated. In particular flows around bodies with typical radii comparable with the thickness of the upper deck are considered. It is shown that such unstable modes exist below a critical nondimensional radius of the body a sub 0. At values of the radius above a sub 0 all the modes are stable while if unstable modes exist they are found to occur in pairs. The interaction of these modes in the nonlinear regime is investigated using a weakly nonlinear approach and it is found that, dependent on the frequencies of the imposed Tollmien-Schlichting waves, either of the modes can be set up

A three dimensional finite element model of wind effects upon higher harmonics of the internal tide.

A non-linear three dimensional unstructured grid model of the M2 tide in the shelf edge area off the west coast of Scotland is used to examine the spatial distribution of the M2 internal tide and its higher harmonics in the region. In addition the spatial variability of the tidally induced turbulent kinetic energy and associated mixing in the area are considered. Initial calculations involve only tidal forcing, although subsequent calculations are performed with up-welling and down-welling favourable winds in order to examine how these influence the tidal distribution (particularly the higher harmonics) and mixing in the region. Both short and long duration winds are used in these calculations. Tidal calculations show that there is significant small scale spatial variability particularly in the higher harmonics of the internal tide in the region. In addition turbulence energy and mixing exhibit appreciable spatial variability in regions of rapidly changing topography, with increased mixing occurring above seamounts. Wind effects significantly change the distribution of the M2 internal tide and its higher harmonics, with appreciable differences found between up- and down-welling winds, and long and short duration winds due to differences in mixing and the presence of wind induced flows. The implications for model validation, particularly in terms of energy transfer to higher harmonics, and mixing are briefly discussed

Early Implementation of Pre-Existing Condition Insurance Plans: Providing an Interim Safety Net for the Uninsurable

Outlines enrollment trends and enrollee traits in a temporary program designed to provide affordable coverage to the uninsured with preexisting conditions, changes to structures and premiums, and estimated out-of-pocket costs by utilization and plan type