Openbare prestatiegegevens van scholen; nuttigheid en validiteit

The immediate motive for this article is the recently started practice in the Netherlands to publicly report performance indicators on secondary schools. Three contexts of application of performance reporting are discussed: supporting school choice, school improvement and external accountability. Given the uncertainty and relatively small size of output differences between schools, incomplete knowledge about education production functions, and limited discretion of higher administrative levels over secondary schools in the Netherlands, performance reporting is seen as being of only limited relevance in each of these contexts of application. In a discussion on the meaning and measurement of 'value added', it is argued that any measure should start with a definition based on the degree of overachievement or underachievement of individual students. Parents, quite obviously, have a different kind of value added in mind than other stakeholders: they want to know what a school can mean for their child, whereas others want to have a 'clean' as possible measure for the true impact of the school (i.e. by efforts of the teachers). Next to this parents are interested in differential value added: the specific meaning a school can have for t heir own child given its cognitive and other relevant abilities. The article closes with a discussion of possible unintended consequences of publishing school performance reports. The final conclusion is, nevertheless, that the increased consciousness about output performance is likely to act as an achievement incentive to schools thus leading to increased performance of secondary schools

Differential effects of colleges on the labour market success of their graduates

This paper explores the effects of colleges for higher vocational education on the labour market success of their graduates. Using data about the labour market position of Dutch graduates from higher vocational education, and applying multi-level statistical modelling techniques it is shown that for four domains (finding a job, level of job, monthly wages, and wages per hour) the colleges did hardly differ substantially. Most of the institutional variation occured at the department level within the colleges, but these department effects appeared to be small as well and not always very stable over the years. The discussion focuses on the implication for using labour market data for the construction of institutional performance indicators. It is shown that the ranking of colleges on their labour market performance changes as soon as input variables are controlled for. It is therefore important to look at the ‘net'' outcomes or ‘added value'' rather than the ‘gross'' outcomes.labour market entry;

Mineralogy and Acid Neutralisation Mechanisms in Inland Acid Sulfate Environments

Soils and sediments containing iron sulfides or the products of sulfide oxidation are known as acid sulfate soils (ASS). These soils possess significant environmental risks due to their potential capacity to produce copious amounts of sulfuric acid (H2SO4) on their exposure to atmosphere. The accumulation of large deposits of sulfidic material has been identified in the past 10 to 12 years in saline-inland wetlands in Australia. Extended periods of natural as well as human-induced drying events in many of these wetlands have resulted in highly saline conditions (e.g. dominated by NaCl and sulfate containing salts) and the exposure (oxidation) of sulfidic material. The oxidation of sulfidic material results in the release of H2SO4 and the precipitation of a range of secondary iron minerals (e.g. goethite, ferrihydrite, schwertmannite. Under highly acidic conditions (pH < 4) found in sulfuric material of the ASS, dissolution of layer silicates or phyllosilicate minerals is the only realistic process that can provide a long-term acid neutralisation in these soils; particularly in many Australian soils which have small quantities of weatherable primary minerals and carbonates. It is vital to investigate the mineralogical composition and dissolution mechanisms of layer silicates or phyllosilicate minerals existing in these ASS environments to develop effective management strategies for these soils. The dissolution rate of illite, a common phyllosilicate mineral in Australian soil, was determined using flow-through reactors at 25 ± 1°C, in solutions with two different ionic strengths of 0.25 M and 0.01 M (maintained using NaCl), and pH ranging from 1–4.25 (H2SO4). The results from the illite dissolution experiments showed a rapid release of cations at the onset of the experiments and a relatively slower release at the steady state. Close to stoichiometric dissolution of illite was obtained at pH 1–4 in the higher ionic strength solutions and at pH 1–3 in the lower ionic strength solutions. The experiment at pH 4.25 in the lower ionic strength solution exhibited RAl < RSi, resulting from a possible adsorption of dissolved Al on the illite surface. Illite dissolution rates showed strong pH dependence, with decreased dissolution rates with increasing pH. The proton reaction orders obtained for dissolution in the higher and lower ionic strength solutions were 0.32 and 0.36, respectively. From the relative cation release data, it was concluded that the dissolution of illite proceeded with the removal of interlayer K followed by the dissolution of octahedral cations, whereas the dissolution of Si was the rate limiting step in the dissolution process. The dissolution rate of illite, kaolinite and montmorillonite was compared in flow-through reactors at 25 ± 1°C and at the two ionic strengths, as described earlier. Kaolinite dissolution rates were close to stoichiometric at pH 1 and 2 in the higher ionic strength solutions and at pH 1–4 in the lower ionic strength solutions. RAl values greater than RSi were obtained for kaolinite dissolution experiments at pH 3 and 4 in the higher ionic strength solutions. Kaolinite dissolution rates were strongly dependent on pH at pH ≤ 3, whereas kaolinite rates showed a little pH dependence at pH 3–4.25, and the point of zero charge (PZC) of the mineral appears to have affected the dissolution rate at these pH values. Kaolinite dissolution rates at pH 1 and 2 (H2SO4) in this study were greater than the previously reported rates in HCl and HClO4 solutions, which was ascribed to the complexation of Al by sulfate ions in the solutions. For montmorillonite dissolution, RAl values greater than RSi were obtained in the higher ionic strength solutions at pH 1–4, whereas an opposite trend was observed in the lower ionic strength solutions at pH 2–4. A reduced RAl in the lower ionic strength solutions from montmorillonite dissolution resulted from (apparent) adsorption of dissolved Al on mineral exchange sites, possibly due to the availability of more interlayer exchange sites for Al re-adsorption and a decreased cation (Na+) competition for exchange sites in these systems. The dissolution rate of the clay fraction of soil cores from an inland ASS at Bottle Bend (BB) in south-western New South Wales (NSW, Australia) was determined under similar experimental conditions to pure minerals described earlier. Clay dissolution experiments were also conducted at 35 and 45°C at pH 1 and 4 to determine the effect of temperature on dissolution rates. The clay sample comprised of smectite (40 %), illite (27 %), kaolinite (26 %) and quartz (6 %), with a minor impurity of anatase (1 %). Clay dissolution rates decreased with an increasing pH and a decreasing temperature. A strong reduction in the initial Al release resulted from clay dissolution in the lower ionic strength solutions at pH 2 to 4, whereas a preferential initial Al release was obtained in the higher ionic strength solutions. A slight increase in the RSi values was observed at the lower ionic strength across the pH range investigated, whereas a significant decrease in RAl was found at pH 4 with a decrease in the ionic strength, at all temperatures. An apparent activation energy value of 18.3 kcal mol–1 was calculated at pH 1 that decreased to 9.0 kcal mol–1 at pH 4. The individual mineral dissolution rates estimated from bulk release rate of Al and Si showed fastest dissolution rates for kaolinite followed by illite and smectite. Smectite dissolution rates obtained for soil clay showed close similarity to pure montmorillonite rates obtained under similar conditions. The acid neutralisation capacity (ANC) of the clay sample was calculated from the release rates of cations (Al, Fe, K, Mg). The ANC values of 44.4 and 13.1 kg H2SO4/tonne of clay sample were estimated from the cation release over a period of 22 and 62 days at pH 1 and 4, respectively. An enhanced release of Al from phyllosilicate dissolution in the highly saline-acidic systems could possibly be a contributing factor to the ecological disturbance caused by increased Al concentrations in the soil and water systems. Morphology of the oxidised surface (5 cm) sediments collected from a highly saline inland ASS at the BB site was characterised by X-ray diffraction (XRD), transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and scanning transmission electron microscopy combined with energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (STEM-EDS). Halite (NaCl), gypsum (CaSO4.2H2O) and akaganéite (β-FeOOH) were identified as the major phases with minor amounts of K-jarosite in some sediment samples. Akaganéite is rarely found in the soil environments and mainly forms as a product of corrosion of iron in chloride-rich environment. The precipitation of akaganéite at the study site resulted from the natural occurrence of the unique solution conditions (in situ pH as low as 2 and EC as high as 216 dS/m) at the site. The chemical analysis of the akaganéite found in these sediments revealed an average Fe/Cl mole ratio of 6.7 and a structural formula of Fe8O8(OH)6.8(Cl)1.2 which is consistent with the composition of pure akaganéite. Saline-acidic conditions with significantly higher chloride over sulfate levels provided the necessary conditions for akaganéite formation at the study site. The precipitation of akaganéite in the ASS environment necessitates detailed investigation to determine the competitive formation and stability of this mineral relative to stable secondary iron minerals commonly precipitated in ASS environments