Design of a new type of balance drum to reduce axial loading in centrifugal pumps

In centrifugal pumps, axial thrust bearings are required to compensate for the axial loading on the pump impeller(s). These forces are mainly the result of unequal distributions of pressure on projected areas at both sides of the impeller(s). Axial loading tends to be highest in multistage pumps in which all impellers face the same direction. Balancing devices are often used to reduce the loading of the axial bearings. Common types of balancing devices are the balance drum and the balance disc. Both of them have their advantages and disadvantages. A stepped balance drum is a new concept for a balancing device that can be used in any type of turbomachinery. It combines the benefits of the balance drum and the balance disk without the drawbacks of both. In this paper, the new concept is presented along with a semi-empirical model of its performance. A CFD analysis is also presented which serves to verify the analytical model. An optimization procedure of a stepped balance drum is given using a multistage centrifugal pump as an example

Axial thrust prediction for a multi-stage centrifugal pump

The prediction of axial thrust for centrifugal pumps has been an important topic for many years. This is especially the case for multi-stage pumps with opposed or inline impellers, as the correct selection of balancing device(s) and bearings depends highly on the accuracy of the calculated thrust. Up till now, many investigations regarding axial thrust have focused on fully analytical or (semi-)empirical relations while others have tried to predict the axial thrust using CFD simulations. Full analytical or empirical methods tend to give poor results or need tuning for each specific pump, while the full CFD methods are costly in both setup time and computer resources. This paper presents a hybrid method to calculate the axial thrust of a multi-stage pump with an inline impeller design. The hybrid method combines analytical methods and CFD to reduce the required setup time and computation costs. The CFD calculation of the main flow is used as a boundary condition for the semi-empirical models for the side chambers and the inter-stage seals, such that these tight regions can be excluded from the CFD calculation. To verify and validate the hybrid method, results are compared with measurements and with full CFD calculations that include the side chambers and seals. These results show that the hybrid method and the full CFD method give comparable results, but there is still some difference with the measurements