Mind the (synthesis) gap: examining where academic FPGA tools lag behind industry

Firstly, we present VTR-to-Bitstream v2.0, the latest version of our open-source toolchain that takes Verilog input and produces a packed, placed— and now routed—solution that can be programmed onto the Xilinx commercial FPGA architecture. Secondly, we apply this updated tool to measure the gap between academic and industrial FPGA tools by examining the quality of results at each of the three main compilation stages: synthesis, packing & placement, routing. Our findings indicate that the delay gap (according to Xilinx static timing analysis) for academic tools breaks down into a 31% degradation with synthesis, 10% with packing & placement, and 15% with routing. This leads us to believe that opportunities for improvement exist not only within VPR, but also in the front-end tools that lie upstream

Packing Topological Minors Half-Integrally

The packing problem and the covering problem are two of the most general questions in graph theory. The Erd\H{o}s-P\'{o}sa property characterizes the cases when the optimal solutions of these two problems are bounded by functions of each other. Robertson and Seymour proved that when packing and covering $H$-minors for any fixed graph $H$, the planarity of $H$ is equivalent with the Erd\H{o}s-P\'{o}sa property. Thomas conjectured that the planarity is no longer required if the solution of the packing problem is allowed to be half-integral. In this paper, we prove that this half-integral version of Erd\H{o}s-P\'{o}sa property holds with respect to the topological minor containment, which easily implies Thomas' conjecture. Indeed, we prove an even stronger statement in which those subdivisions are rooted at any choice of prescribed subsets of vertices. Precisely, we prove that for every graph $H$, there exists a function $f$ such that for every graph $G$, every sequence $(R_v: v \in V(H))$ of subsets of $V(G)$ and every integer $k$, either there exist $k$ subgraphs $G_1,G_2,...,G_k$ of $G$ such that every vertex of $G$ belongs to at most two of $G_1,...,G_k$ and each $G_i$ is isomorphic to a subdivision of $H$ whose branch vertex corresponding to $v$ belongs to $R_v$ for each $v \in V(H)$, or there exists a set $Z \subseteq V(G)$ with size at most $f(k)$ intersecting all subgraphs of $G$ isomorphic to a subdivision of $H$ whose branch vertex corresponding to $v$ belongs to $R_v$ for each $v \in V(H)$. Applications of this theorem include generalizations of algorithmic meta-theorems and structure theorems for $H$-topological minor free (or $H$-minor free) graphs to graphs that do not half-integrally pack many $H$-topological minors (or $H$-minors)