Lessons of spin and torsion: Reply to ``Consistent coupling to Dirac fields in teleparallelism"

In reply to the criticism made by Mielke in the pereceding Comment [Phys. Rev. D69 (2004) 128501] on our recent paper, we once again explicitly demonstrate the inconsistency of the coupling of a Dirac field to gravitation in the teleparallel equivalent of general relativity. Moreover, we stress that the mentioned inconsistency is generic for {\it all} sources with spin and is by no means restricted to the Dirac field. In this sense the $SL(4,R)$-covariant generalization of the spinor fields in the teleparallel gravity theory is irrelevant to the inconsistency problem.Comment: Revtex, 4 pages, no figure

Gravitation and Duality Symmetry

By generalizing the Hodge dual operator to the case of soldered bundles, and working in the context of the teleparallel equivalent of general relativity, an analysis of the duality symmetry in gravitation is performed. Although the basic conclusion is that, at least in the general case, gravitation is not dual symmetric, there is a particular theory in which this symmetry shows up. It is a self dual (or anti-self dual) teleparallel gravity in which, due to the fact that it does not contribute to the interaction of fermions with gravitation, the purely tensor part of torsion is assumed to vanish. The ensuing fermionic gravitational interaction is found to be chiral. Since duality is intimately related to renormalizability, this theory may eventually be more amenable to renormalization than teleparallel gravity or general relativity.Comment: 7 pages, no figures. Version 2: minor presentation changes, references added. Accepted for publication in Int. J. Mod. Phys.

Teleparallel origin of the Fierz picture for spin-2 particle

A new approach to the description of spin-2 particle in flat and curved spacetime is developed on the basis of the teleparallel gravity theory. We show that such an approach is in fact a true and natural framework for the Fierz representation proposed recently by Novello and Neves. More specifically, we demonstrate how the teleparallel theory fixes uniquely the structure of the Fierz tensor, discover the transparent origin of the gauge symmetry of the spin 2 model, and derive the linearized Einstein operator from the fundamental identity of the teleparallel gravity. In order to cope with the consistency problem on the curved spacetime, similarly to the usual Riemannian approach, one needs to include the non-minimal (torsion dependent) coupling terms.Comment: 5 pages, Revtex4, no figures. Accepted for publication in Phys. Rev.

Torsion Gravity: a Reappraisal

The role played by torsion in gravitation is critically reviewed. After a description of the problems and controversies involving the physics of torsion, a comprehensive presentation of the teleparallel equivalent of general relativity is made. According to this theory, curvature and torsion are alternative ways of describing the gravitational field, and consequently related to the same degrees of freedom of gravity. However, more general gravity theories, like for example Einstein-Cartan and gauge theories for the Poincare and the affine groups, consider curvature and torsion as representing independent degrees of freedom. By using an active version of the strong equivalence principle, a possible solution to this conceptual question is reviewed. This solution favors ultimately the teleparallel point of view, and consequently the completeness of general relativity. A discussion of the consequences for gravitation is presented.Comment: RevTeX, 34 pages. Review article to be published by Int. J. Mod. Phys.

Norway-UK comparative analysis of sustainability in design education

© 2018 Institution of Engineering Designers The Design Society. All Rights Reserved. Education for sustainability seeks to educate students in a manner that promotes sustainable development, acknowledging upcoming societal, economic, and technological changes and equipping learners to adapt to these developments. This preliminary exploratory study investigates British and Norwegian government strategies and visions that address these changes and compares them to curricula for design education. This study uses a hermeneutical approach to textual interpretation based on emerging topics from the strategies, and analyses the curricula in light of sustainable education and transformative theory. The findings show the similarities between the two countries; both favour technical skills, whereas issues of an aging society and practicing critical reflection are rarely addressed. Therefore, this paper calls for discussion on the formulation of design education curricula and the skills it prioritises

Dirac spinor fields in the teleparallel gravity: comment on "Metric-affine approach to teleparallel gravity"

We show that the coupling of a Dirac spinor field with the gravitational field in the teleparallel equivalent of general relativity is consistent. For an arbitrary SO(3,1) connection there are two possibilities for the coupling of the spinor field with the gravitational field. The problems of consistency raised by Y. N. Obukhov and J. G. Pereira in the paper {\it Metric-affine approach to teleparallel gravity} [gr-qc/0212080] take place only in the framework of one particular coupling. By adopting an alternative coupling the consistency problem disappears.Comment: 8 pages, Latex file, no figures, to appear in the Phys. Rev. D as a Commen

Modelling the Physics of Bubble Nucleation in Histotripsy

This work aims to establish a theoretical framework for the modeling of bubble nucleation in histotripsy. A phenomenological version of the classical nucleation theory was parametrized with histotripsy experimental data, fitting a temperature-dependent activity factor that harmonizes theoretical predictions and experimental data for bubble nucleation at both high and low temperatures. Simulations of histotripsy pressure and temperature fields are then used in order to understand spatial and temporal properties of bubble nucleation at varying sonication conditions. This modeling framework offers a thermodynamic understanding on the role of the ultrasound frequency, waveforms, peak focal pressures, and duty cycle on patterns of ultrasound-induced bubble nucleation. It was found that at temperatures lower than 50 °C, nucleation rates are more appreciable at very large negative pressures such as -30 MPa. For focal peak-negative pressures of -15 MPa, characteristic of boiling histotripsy, nucleation rates grow by 20 orders of magnitude in the temperature interval 60 °C-100 °C

Mechanisms of nuclei growth in ultrasound bubble nucleation

This paper interrogates the intersections between bubble dynamics and classical nucleation theory (CNT) towards constructing a model that describes intermediary nucleation events between the extrema of cavitation and boiling. We employ Zeldovich's hydrodynamic approach to obtain a description of bubble nuclei that grow simultaneously via hydrodynamic excitation by the acoustic field and vapour transport. By quantifying the relative dominance of both mechanisms, it is then possible to discern the extent to which viscosity, inertia, surface tension and vapour transport shape the growth of bubble nuclei through non-dimensional numbers that naturally arise within the theory. The first non-dimensional number Φ12/Φ2 is analogous to the Laplace number, representing the balance between surface tension and inertial constraints to viscous effects. The second non-dimensional number δ represents how enthalpy transport into the bubble can reduce nucleation rates by cooling the surrounding liquid. This formulation adds to the current understanding of ultrasound bubble nucleation by accounting for bubble dynamics during nucleation, quantifying the physical distinctions between “boiling” and “cavitation” bubbles through non-dimensional parameters, and outlining the characteristic timescales of nucleation according to the growth mechanism of bubbles throughout the histotripsy temperature range. We observed in our simulations that viscous effects control the process of ultrasound nucleation in water-like media throughout the 0–120 °C temperature range, although this dominance decreases with increasing temperatures. Enthalpy transport was found to reduce nucleation rates for increasing temperatures. This effect becomes significant at temperatures above 30 °C and favours the creation of fewer nuclei that are larger in size. Conversely, negligible enthalpy transport at lower temperatures can enable the nucleation of dense clusters of small nuclei, such as cavitation clouds. We find that nuclei growth as modelled by the Rayleigh-Plesset equation occurs over shorter timescales than as modelled by vapour-dominated growth. This suggests that the first stage of bubble nuclei growth is hydrodynamic, and vapour transport effects can only be observed over longer timescales. Finally, we propose that this framework can be used for comparison between different experiments in bubble nucleation, towards standardisation and dosimetry of protocols