A note on Dolby and Gull on radar time and the twin "paradox"

Recently a suggestion has been made that standard textbook representations of hypersurfaces of simultaneity for the travelling twin in the twin "paradox" are incorrect. This suggestion is false: the standard textbooks are in agreement with a proper understanding of the relativity of simultaneity.Comment: LaTeX, 3 pages, 2 figures. Update: added new section V and updated reference

Spherically symmetric spacetimes in f(R) gravity theories

We study both analytically and numerically the gravitational fields of stars in f(R) gravity theories. We derive the generalized Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkov equations for these theories and show that in metric f(R) models the Parameterized Post-Newtonian parameter $\gamma_{\rm PPN} = 1/2$ is a robust outcome for a large class of boundary conditions set at the center of the star. This result is also unchanged by introduction of dark matter in the Solar System. We find also a class of solutions with $\gamma_{\rm PPN} \approx 1$ in the metric $f(R)=R-\mu^4/R$ model, but these solutions turn out to be unstable and decay in time. On the other hand, the Palatini version of the theory is found to satisfy the Solar System constraints. We also consider compact stars in the Palatini formalism, and show that these models are not inconsistent with polytropic equations of state. Finally, we comment on the equivalence between f(R) gravity and scalar-tensor theories and show that many interesting Palatini f(R) gravity models can not be understood as a limiting case of a Jordan-Brans-Dicke theory with $\omega \to -3/2$.Comment: Published version, 12 pages, 7 figure

Birkhoff Theorem and Matter

Birkhoff's theorem for spherically symmetric vacuum spacetimes is a key theorem in studying local systems in general relativity theory. However realistic local systems are only approximately spherically symmetric and only approximately vacuum. In a previous paper, we showed the theorem remains approximately true in an approximately spherically symmetric vacuum space time. In this paper we prove the converse case: the theorem remains approximately true in a spherically symmetric, approximately vacuum space time.Comment: 7 pages, Revtex

Pound-Rebka experiment and torsion in the Schwarzschild spacetime

We develop some ideas discussed by E. Schucking [arXiv:0803.4128] concerning the geometry of the gravitational field. First, we address the concept according to which the gravitational acceleration is a manifestation of the spacetime torsion, not of the curvature tensor. It is possible to show that there are situations in which the geodesic acceleration of a particle may acquire arbitrary values, whereas the curvature tensor approaches zero. We conclude that the spacetime curvature does not affect the geodesic acceleration. Then we consider the the Pound-Rebka experiment, which relates the time interval $\Delta \tau_1$ of two light signals emitted at a position $r_1$, to the time interval $\Delta \tau_2$ of the signals received at a position $r_2$, in a Schwarzschild type gravitational field. The experiment is determined by four spacetime events. The infinitesimal vectors formed by these events do not form a parallelogram in the (t,r) plane. The failure in the closure of the parallelogram implies that the spacetime has torsion. We find the explicit form of the torsion tensor that explains the nonclosure of the parallelogram.Comment: 16 pages, two figures, one typo fixed, one paragraph added in section

Redshifts and Killing Vectors

Courses in introductory special and general relativity have increasingly become part of the curriculum for upper-level undergraduate physics majors and master's degree candidates. One of the topics rarely discussed is symmetry, particularly in the theory of general relativity. The principal tool for its study is the Killing vector. We provide an elementary introduction to the concept of a Killing vector field, its properties, and as an example of its utility apply these ideas to the rigorous determination of gravitational and cosmological redshifts.Comment: 16 Latex pages, 6 postscript figures, submitted to Am. J. Phy

A Radiation Scalar for Numerical Relativity

This letter describes a scalar curvature invariant for general relativity with a certain, distinctive feature. While many such invariants exist, this one vanishes in regions of space-time which can be said unambiguously to contain no gravitational radiation. In more general regions which incontrovertibly support non-trivial radiation fields, it can be used to extract local, coordinate-independent information partially characterizing that radiation. While a clear, physical interpretation is possible only in such radiation zones, a simple algorithm can be given to extend the definition smoothly to generic regions of space-time.Comment: 4 pages, 1 EPS figur

Metric of a tidally perturbed spinning black hole

We explicitly construct the metric of a Kerr black hole that is tidally perturbed by the external universe in the slow-motion approximation. This approximation assumes that the external universe changes slowly relative to the rotation rate of the hole, thus allowing the parameterization of the Newman-Penrose scalar $\psi_0$ by time-dependent electric and magnetic tidal tensors. This approximation, however, does not constrain how big the spin of the background hole can be and, in principle, the perturbed metric can model rapidly spinning holes. We first generate a potential by acting with a differential operator on $\psi_0$. From this potential we arrive at the metric perturbation by use of the Chrzanowski procedure in the ingoing radiation gauge. We provide explicit analytic formulae for this metric perturbation in spherical Kerr-Schild coordinates, where the perturbation is finite at the horizon. This perturbation is parametrized by the mass and Kerr spin parameter of the background hole together with the electric and magnetic tidal tensors that describe the time evolution of the perturbation produced by the external universe. In order to take the metric accurate far away from the hole, these tidal tensors should be determined by asymptotically matching this metric to another one valid far from the hole. The tidally perturbed metric constructed here could be useful in initial data constructions to describe the metric near the horizons of a binary system of spinning holes. This perturbed metric could also be used to construct waveforms and study the absorption of mass and angular momentum by a Kerr black hole when external processes generate gravitational radiation.Comment: 17 pages, 3 figures. Final PRD version, minor typos, etc corrected. v3: corrected typo in Eq. (35) and (57

Numerical treatment of the hyperboloidal initial value problem for the vacuum Einstein equations. I. The conformal field equations

This is the first in a series of articles on the numerical solution of Friedrich's conformal field equations for Einstein's theory of gravity. We will discuss in this paper why one should be interested in applying the conformal method to physical problems and why there is good hope that this might even be a good idea from the numerical point of view. We describe in detail the derivation of the conformal field equations in the spinor formalism which we use for the implementation of the equations, and present all the equations as a reference for future work. Finally, we discuss the implications of the assumptions of a continuous symmetry.Comment: 19 pages, LaTeX2