Coupled effects of internal concentration polarization and fouling on flux behavior of forward osmosis membranes during humic acid filtration

Forward osmosis (FO) is attracting increasing interest for its potential applications in water and wastewater treatment and desalination. One of the major drawbacks of FO is internal concentration polarization (ICP), which significantly limits the FO flux efficiency. In addition, FO membrane flux can be adversely affected by membrane fouling. The effects of ICP and fouling on FO flux behavior were systematically investigated in the current study. Both theoretical model and experimental results demonstrated that the FO flux was highly non-linear with respect to the apparent driving force (the concentration difference between the draw solution and the feed water) as a result of ICP. ICP played a dominant role on FO flux behavior at greater draw solution concentrations and/or greater membrane fluxes due to the exponential dependence of ICP on flux level. Compared to the active layer facing draw solution (AL-facing-DS) configuration, more severe ICP was observed when the membrane active layer faced the feed water (AL-facing-FW) as a result of dilutive ICP in the FO support layer. Interestingly, the AL-facing-FW configuration showed remarkable flux stability against both dilution of the bulk draw solution and membrane fouling. In this configuration, any attempt to reduce membrane flux was compensated by a reduced level of ICP. The net result was only a marginal flux reduction. In addition, foulant deposition was insignificant in this configuration. Thus, the AL-facing-FW configuration enjoyed inherently stable flux, however, at the expense of severer initial ICP. In contrast, the AL-facing-DS configuration suffered severe flux reduction as porous membrane support faced the humic acid containing feed water. The flux loss in this configuration was likely due to the combined effects of (1) the internal clogging of the FO support structure as well as (2) the resulting enhanced ICP in the support layer. The latter was caused by reduced porosity and reduced mass transfer coefficient of the support. The pore clogging enhanced ICP mechanism probably played a dominant role in FO flux reduction at higher flux levels. To the authors' best knowledge, this is the first study to systematically demonstrate the coupled effects of ICP and fouling on the FO flux behavior. © 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.link_to_subscribed_fulltex

Fouling propensity of forward osmosis: Investigation of the slower flux decline phenomenon

Forward Osmosis (FO) is a membrane process that uses the natural osmotic pressure of a concentrated draw solution to extract pure water from a feed stream. The attraction of the FO process is that it uses dense membranes, while operating at ambient pressure. This means that the FO process could potentially produce high quality water with lower energy consumption, as compared to the other desalination or reclamation processes. As FO does not entail the use of hydraulic pressure, FO has been hypothesized to have lower fouling propensity than pressure driven membrane processes. Membrane fouling has significant impact on the operational sustainability and economics of the process. This study examines the possible contributing factors to the slower flux decline observed in FO experiments based on a combined experimental and modelling approach. It was found that these factors could include low water fluxes, use of hydrophilic and smooth membranes, and the effect of internal concentration polarisation that is inherent of FO. It was also found that the transmission of draw solutes from the draw solution into the feed can have significant effect on FO performance.link_to_subscribed_fulltex

Modeling salt accumulation in osmotic membrane bioreactors: Implications for FO membrane selection and system operation

Novel osmotic membrane bioreactors (OMBRs) have been recently reported in the literature. An OMBR uses a dense salt-rejecting forward osmosis (FO) membrane, which exhibits high retention of organic matter and various other contaminants. Meanwhile, the high rejection nature also leads to the accumulation of salts in the bioreactor, which can adversely affect the biological activities as well as the FO water flux. A salt accumulation model is developed in the current study. Our model suggests that both the bioreactor salt concentration and the FO water flux are controlled by membrane properties (water permeability A, salt permeability B, mass transfer coefficient K m, and membrane orientation relative to the draw solution) and the OMBR operational conditions (salt concentration of the influent wastewater, draw solution concentration, hydraulic retention time (HRT), and sludge retention time (SRT)). The salt accumulation is contributed by both the influent wastewater and the reverse diffusion of solutes from the draw solution, and is directly proportional to the volumetric concentration factor (i.e., the SRT/HRT ratio). The relative importance of reverse diffusion over contribution from influent solutes is governed by the membrane selectivity. For a relatively selective membrane (B/A ll;the osmotic pressure of the influent water), solute reverse diffusion has negligible effect on OMBR performance. In contrast, the salt accumulation and FO water flux reduction are governed by reverse diffusion for B/A greater than the osmotic pressure of the influent water. The current study reveals the critical importance of the B/A ratio and HRT/SRT ratio for optimized OMBR operation. © 2010 Elsevier B.V.link_to_subscribed_fulltex

Modeling double-skinned FO membranes

Forward osmosis (FO) has attracted wide interest for its many potential applications. Recent developments suggest that double-skinned FO membranes may perform superiorly over conventional single-skinned ones. In this design, a dense rejection skin facing the draw solution is responsible for the separation, while a second skin facing the feed solution is designed to prevent foulants entering into the porous support layer sandwiched between the two skins. For the first time, an analytical model is developed for double-skinned FO membranes and is verified experimentally. Model simulations suggest that an optimal double-skinned membrane shall have a feed skin similar to that of a low rejection nanofiltration membrane to minimize the overall hydraulic resistant and to reduce internal concentration polarization. On the other hand, the optimization of the draw skin calls for a compromise between its water permeability and solute rejection. FO water flux is greater for support layers with higher mass transfer coefficients. In addition, it decreases with decreasing draw solution concentration and increasing feed solution concentration. While membrane orientation plays an important role for applications with low feed solution concentrations (with the denser skin preferentially facing the draw solution), this effect becomes negligible at high feed solution concentrations. © 2011 Elsevier B.V

Characterization of forward osmosis membranes by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy

Forward osmosis (FO) has a potential role in desalination and water reclamation. However, the efficiency of FO processes is significantly limited by internal concentration polarization (ICP), which is difficult to detect by conventional characterization methods. In this work, we aimed to apply electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) to FO systems, and to develop a methodology for interpreting the interplay between the membrane structure and the polarization phenomena. Three commercial FO membranes with different substrate structures were characterized by an EIS system that was modified to accommodate FO processes, and the impedance spectra were analyzed based on their equivalent circuits. In the static tests (without osmosis), the limit behaviors of the impedance spectra were exploited to resolve the structural information of the FO membranes from the electrolyte background, which was in turn compared with the characterization results via scanning electron microscope (SEM). Associated with the different membrane orientations, the dynamic tests (with osmosis) were implemented to verify the ability of the EIS system to detect the variation of the developed concentration profiles within the membrane structure. The characterization results indicate that EIS is promising to be a handy tool to investigate the polarization phenomena during the FO processes. © 2012 Elsevier B.V.link_to_subscribed_fulltex

Study of integration of forward osmosis and biological process: Membrane performance under elevated salt environment

There has been an increasing interest in the novel integration of forward osmosis (FO) and biological process known as the osmotic membrane bioreactor (OMBR). However, little operating experience is available to adequately assess the feasibility of the technology for larger scale application. The goal of this study is to provide fundamental information on the technology. In this study, an OMBR system was continuously operated for 73 days. It was found that the high retention property of the FO membrane and salt transmission from the draw solution resulted in increasing mixed liquor salinity until a stable state was reached. In spite of the elevated salinity, the water flux was relatively stable at around 3 L m-2 h-1. Post-experiment analyses indicated mild membrane fouling, and its effect on water permeability was insignificant. An ion analysis check indicated that scaling did not occur. The SEM examination detected a thin gel-like secondary layer on the membrane surface. It was deduced that this secondary layer could have an influencing role on salt transmission during the experiment, and moderated salt concentration in the bioreactor

Effect of Pharmaceuticals on the Performance of a Novel Osmotic Membrane Bioreactor (OMBR)

The integration of forward osmosis (FO) and biological process, known as the osmotic membrane bioreactor (OMBR), may be viewed as beyond the state of the art for used water treatment and water reclamation. While it is known that the OMBR is able to produce good product water quality in terms of total organic carbon (TOC) removal, limited information is available on the removal of organic micro-pollutants in relation to process performance under the concentrated environment. In this study, a novel OMBR system was continuously operated over 73 days, during which pharmaceuticals were dosed on two occasions into the system. It was found that while pharmaceutical removal was high (>96%), other process parameters in the form of TOC, mixed liquor suspended solids (MLSS) and extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) were unmistakably affected. The major portion of TOC that permeated the FO membrane was found to be low-molecular weight neutral compounds which were associated with the impaired biological process. Microbiological analysis confirmed shifts in microbial populations occurred due to the increased salinity and dosage of the pharmaceuticals. The study demonstrated the importance of the biological process for optimal OMBR system performance, and paves the way for further research in this direction. © 2012 Copyright Taylor and Francis Group, LLC