Reversibility revisited: Stimulus-dependent stability of filial preference in the chick

The reversibility of filial preferences was studied in domestic chicks, Gallus gallus domesticus, using an artificial as well as a more naturalistic imprinting stimulus. Day-old chicks were exposed for 2 h to either a rotating stuffed jungle fowl or a rotating red box. Two hours later their preferences were tested in a simultaneous choice test (test I), involving the box and the fowl. The next day, the chicks were trained and tested (test II) as before, except box-trained chicks were now exposed to the fowl and vice versa. In three different experimental groups, the relative attractiveness of the two stimuli (as measured in test I) was varied by altering the light intensity of the red box. In the chicks trained with the box and subsequently exposed to the fowl, there was a significant decrease in mean preference for the box from test I to test II. In contrast, the preference of the chicks trained with the stuffed fowl were not affected by subsequent exposure to the red box. This differential reversibility was also found when, in test I, the preference for the box was significantly higher than the preference for the fowl. These results support a model of the formation of filial preference as an interaction between acquired preference and a developing predisposition for a particular class of stimuli