Bourgeois queens and high stakes games in the ant Aphaenogaster senilis

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>Many animals face some form of conflict over reproductive opportunities. Queen selection in social insect colonies represents a high-stakes conflict where competition occurs among multiple queens for a few or a single reproductive role(s). The outcome of the contest is critical to the fitness of all colony individuals as most are sterile, and thus represents a conflict at multiple levels. <it>Aphaenogaster senilis </it>is a monogynous, monandrous, fission performing ant, in which queen selection occurs during colony fission and when replacement queens are produced to overcome orphaning. First-born queens are usually behaviourally dominant over subsequent queens, and eventually inherit the colony. We investigated the importance of physical dominance in queen selection in orphaned groups by manipulating the fighting ability of first-born queens via mandibular ablation.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>First emerged queens were heavier than second emerged queens, performed almost all aggression, were behaviourally dominant 92% of the time, and prevailed in 76% of groups after co-existing for 16 days on average. Mandibular ablation had no effect on queen behaviour or contest outcome.</p> <p>Conclusion</p> <p>Aggression is probably ritualised and contests are decided by workers based on relative queen fertility. First-born queens thus have an inherent advantage over second-born queens as they have more time to develop ovaries. Subordinates never retaliated against aggression from dominants and this lack of retaliation can be interpreted as a form of bourgeois strategy as dominants were almost always first-born. However, the lack of alternative reproductive options makes not-fighting effectively a form of suicide. High relatedness between full-sister queens means that subordinates may be better off sacrificing themselves than risking injury to both queens by fighting.</p

Self-sacrifice in 'desperado' contests between relatives

Intra-specific competition occurs in all animal species and can lead to escalated conflict. Overt fighting entails the risk of injury or death, and is usually avoided through the use of conventions or pre-fight assessments. However, overt fighting can be expected when value of the contest outweighs the value of the future, as contestants have little or nothing to lose. In these situations, respect for conventions and asymmetries between contestants can break down, and overt fighting becomes more likely (the desperado effect). Such conditions can arise in contests between queens over colony ownership in social insects, because the value of inheriting a colony of potentially thousands of helpers is huge and queens may have very limited alternative reproductive options. However, in social species the balance of possible outcomes may be influenced by inclusive fitness, as contestants are often relatives. Here we present a simple model based on social insects, which demonstrates that not fighting can be selectively advantageous when there is a risk posed by fighting to inclusive fitness, even when not fighting is likely to result in death. If contestants are related, a loser can still gain indirect fitness through the winner, whereas fighting introduces a risk that both queens will die and thereby obtain zero inclusive fitness. When relatedness is high and fighting poses a risk of all contestants dying, it can be advantageous to cede the contest and be killed, rather than risk everything by fighting

Chemical recognition of reproductive status in social insects

International audienc

Dominance hierarchy and reproductive conflicts among subordinates in a monogynous queenless ant

International audienc

Reproduction versus work in queenless ants: when to join a hierarchy of hopeful reproductives?

International audienc

Functional morphology of the Dufour gland in the queenless ant Dinoponera quadriceps

International audienceColonies of the queenless ponerine ant Dinoponera quadriceps are characterized by a social hierarchy among the workers, in which the gamergate occupies the alpha rank. She may be challenged, however, by a beta worker in an attempt to take over reproductive control in the colony. The gamergate does not engage in a direct conflict, however, but only smears secretion from her Dufour gland onto the beta worker. This secretion then stimulates the low-ranked workers to immobilize the beta worker and thus prevent it from overthrowing the gamergate. Our histological and ultrastructural examination of the Dufour gland in gamergates, one-week-old workers that still have reproductive potential and low-ranked foragers clearly shows that the gamergate has the most developed gland containing secretory cells displaying abundant smooth endoplasmic reticulum and an obvious microvillar differentiation of the apical cell membrane. These findings are in line with the already existing chemical and behavioral observations of the peculiar pretender punishment in this species

How many gamergates is an ant queen worth?

International audienc