79 research outputs found
Herd Behavior, Bank Runs and Information Disclosure
I develop a dynamic model of bank runs that allows me to study important phenomena such as the role of information externalities and herd behavior of depositors as a source of bank runs. I show that eliminating bank runs completely, even they can be generated by herd behavior of depositors, has costs. Furthermore, a deposit contract that allows for runs can achieve higher levels of depositor welfare than a contract that completely eliminates them. Since early liquidation of bank's assets is costly, a central bank that acts as a lender of last resort alleviates some of the costs associated with bank runs. Yet it cannot prevent runs on healthy banks in the absence of perfect information about the bank's asset quality. In those cases, a deposit contract, even with liquidity support from the central bank, cannot achieve the first-best efficient outcome. As a policy measure, any efforts to give market discipline a stronger role in achieving financial stability should be accompanied by transparency and disclosure of information on banksâ soundness and management of the crisis.
Herd Behavior, Bank Runs and Information Disclosure
I develop a dynamic model of bank runs that allows me to study important phenomena such as the role of information externalities and herd behavior of depositors as a source of bank runs. I show that eliminating bank runs completely, even they can be generated by herd behavior of depositors, has costs. Furthermore, a deposit contract that allows for runs can achieve higher levels of depositor welfare than a contract that completely eliminates them. Since early liquidation of bank's assets is costly, a central bank that acts as a lender of last resort alleviates some of the costs associated with bank runs. Yet it cannot prevent runs on healthy banks in the absence of perfect information about the bank's asset quality. In those cases, a deposit contract, even with liquidity support from the central bank, cannot achieve the first-best efficient outcome. As a policy measure, any efforts to give market discipline a stronger role in achieving financial stability should be accompanied
by transparency and disclosure of information on banksâ
soundness and management of the crisis
Imperfect Competition in the Interbank Market for Liquidity as a Rationale for Central Banking
We study liquidity transfers between banks through the interbank
borrowing and asset sale markets when(i)surplus banks providing
liquidity have market power, ii)there are frictions in the lending
market due to moral hazard, and(iii)assets are bank-specific. We show
that when the outside options of needy banks are weak, surplus banks may
strategically under-provide lending, thereby inducing inefficient sales
of bank-specific assets. A central bank can ameliorate this inefficiency
by standing ready to lend to needy banks, provided it has greater
information about banks(e.g.,through supervision) compared to outside
markets, or is prepared to extend potentially loss-making loans. The
public provision of liquidity to banks, in fact its mere credibility,
can thus improve the private allocation of liquidity among banks. This
rationale for central banking funds support in historical episodes
preceding the modern era of central banking and has implications for
recent debates on the supervisory and lender-of-last-resort roles of
central banks
Herd Behavior, Bank Runs and Information Disclosure
I develop a dynamic model of bank runs that allows me to study important phenomena such as the role of information externalities and herd behavior of depositors as a source of bank runs. I show that eliminating bank runs completely, even they can be generated by herd behavior of depositors, has costs. Furthermore, a deposit contract that allows for runs can achieve higher levels of depositor welfare than a contract that completely eliminates them. Since early liquidation of bank's assets is costly, a central bank that acts as a lender of last resort alleviates some of the costs associated with bank runs. Yet it cannot prevent runs on healthy banks in the absence of perfect information about the bank's asset quality. In those cases, a deposit contract, even with liquidity support from the central bank, cannot achieve the first-best efficient outcome. As a policy measure, any efforts to give market discipline a stronger role in achieving financial stability should be accompanied
by transparency and disclosure of information on banksâ
soundness and management of the crisis
Rollover Risk and Market Freezes
The sub-prime crisis of 2007 and 2008 has been characterized by a sudden freeze in the market for short-term, secured borrowing. We present a model that can explain a sudden collapse in the amount that can be borrowed against assets with little credit risk. The borrowing in this model takes the form of asset-backed commercial paper that has to be rolled over several times before the underlying assets mature and their true value is revealed. In the event of default, the creditors (holders of commercial paper) can seize the collateral. We assume that there is a small cost of liquidating the assets. The debt capacity of the assets (the maximum amount that can be borrowed using the assets as collateral) depends on how information about the quality of the asset
is revealed. In one scenario, there is a constant probability that "bad news" is revealed each period and, in the absence of bad news, the value of the assets is high. We call this the "optimistic" scenario because, in the absence of bad news, the expected value of the assets is increasing over time. By contrast, in another scenario, there is a constant probability that "good news" is revealed each period and, in the absence of good news, the value of the assets is low. We call this the
"pessimistic" scenario because, in the absence of good news, the expected value of the assets is decreasing over time. In the optimistic scenario, the debt capacity of the assets is equal to the fundamental value (the expected NPV), whereas in the pessimistic scenario, the debt capacity is
below the fundamental value and is decreasing in the liquidation cost and frequency of rollovers. In the limit, as the number of rollovers becomes unbounded, the debt capacity goes to zero even
for an arbitrarily small default risk. Our model explains why markets for rollover debt, such as asset-backed commercial paper, may experience sudden freezes. The model also provides an explicit formula for the haircut in secured borrowing or repo transactions
Fire-Sale FDI
Financial crises are often accompanied by an outflow of foreign
portfolio investment and an inflow of foreign direct investment(FDI). We
provide an agency-theoretic framework that explains this phenomenon. We
show that during crises, agency problems affecting domestic firms are
exacerbated, and, in turn, external financing constrained. Transfer of
control in the form of direct ownership of failedfirms' assets by
alternate users can circumvent agency problems, but during crises,
efficient owners (e.g.other domestic firms) face similar financing
constraints. The result is a transfer of ownership to foreignfirms,
including inefficient ones, at fire-sale prices. Suchre-sale FDI is
associated with a flipping of acquired firms back to domestic owners
once the crisis abates. These features of re-sale FDI find empirical support
Crisis Resolution and Bank Liquidity
What is the effect of financial crises and the irresolution on banks'
choice of liquidity? When banks have relative expertise in employing
risky assets, the market for these assets clears only atre-sale prices
following a large number of bank failures. The gains from acquiring
assets atre-sale prices make it attractive for banks to hold liquid
assets. The resulting choice of bank liquidity is counter-cyclical,
inefficiently low during economic booms but excessively high during
crises. We present evidence consistent with these predictions. While
interventions to resolve banking crises may be desirable ex post, they
affect bank liquidity in subtle ways: liquidity support to failed banks
or unconditional support to surviving banks reduces incentives to hold
liquidity, whereas support to surviving banks conditional on their
liquid asset holdings has the opposite effect
Fire Sales, Foreign Entry and Bank Liquidity
Bank liquidity is a crucial determinant of the severity of banking crises. We consider the effect of fire sales and foreign entry during crises on banks' ex-ante choice of liquid asset holdings. In a setting with limited pledgeability of risky cash flows and differential expertise between banks and outsiders in employing banking assets, the market for assets clears only at fire-sale prices following the onset of a crisis - and outsiders may enter the market if prices
fall sufficiently low. While fire sales make it attractive for banks to hold liquid assets, foreign entry reduces this incentive. We show that in this setting, bank liquidity is counter-cyclical
whereas bank capital measured as bank profits is pro-cyclical. We derive conditions under which privately optimal levels of bank liquidity are higher or lower than benchmark levels that maximize total output of the banking sector. We present and discuss evidence on bank liquidity that is consistent with model predictions
Contagion Effects of the Silicon Valley Bank Run
This paper analyzes the contagion effects associated with the failure of
Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) and identifies bank-specific vulnerabilities
contributing to the subsequent declines in banks' stock returns. We find that
uninsured deposits, unrealized losses in held-to-maturity securities, bank
size, and cash holdings had a significant impact, while better-quality assets
or holdings of liquid securities did not help mitigate the negative spillovers.
Interestingly, banks whose stocks performed worse post SVB also had lower
returns in the previous year following Federal Reserve interest rate hikes. The
stock market partially anticipated risks associated with uninsured deposit
reliance, but did not price in unrealized losses due to interest rate hikes nor
risks linked to bank size. While mid-sized banks experienced particular stress
immediately after the SVB failure, over time negative spillovers became
widespread except for the largest banks
- âŠ