Entanglement entropy in de Sitter: no pure states for conformal matter

In this paper, we consider the entanglement entropy of conformal matter for finite and semi-infinite entangling regions, as well as the formation of entanglement islands in four-dimensional de Sitter spacetime partially reduced to two dimensions. We analyze complementarity and pure state condition of the entanglement entropy of pure states and show that they never hold in the given setup. We consider two different types of Cauchy surfaces in the extended static patch and flat coordinates, correspondingly. For former, we found that entanglement entropy of a pure state is always bounded from below by a constant and never becomes zero, as required by quantum mechanics. In turn, the difference between the entropies for some region and its complement, which should be zero for a pure state, in direct calculations essentially depends on how the boundaries of these regions evolve with time. Regarding the flat coordinates, it is impossible to regularize spacelike infinity in a way that would be compatible with complementarity and pure state condition, as opposed, for instance, to two-sided Schwarzschild black hole. Finally, we discuss the information paradox in de Sitter and show that the island formula does not resolve it. Namely, we give examples of a region with a time-limited growth of entanglement entropy, for which there is no island solution, and the region, for which entanglement entropy does not grow, but the island solution exists.Comment: v1: 25 pages, 10 figures; v2: 25 pages, 10 figures, references added, notation clarifie

Entanglement Islands and Infrared Anomalies in Schwarzschild Black Hole

In this paper, island formation for entangling regions of finite size in the asymptotically flat eternal Schwarzschild black hole is considered. We check the complementarity property of entanglement entropy which was implicitly assumed in previous studies for semi-infinite regions. This check reveals the emergence of infrared anomalies after regularization of a Cauchy surface. A naive infrared regularization based on ``mirror symmetry'' is considered and its failure is shown. We introduce an improved regularization that gives a correct limit agreed with the semi-infinite results from previous studies. As the time evolution goes, the endpoints of a finite region compatible with the improved regularization become separated by a timelike interval. We call this phenomenon the ``Cauchy surface breaking''. Shortly before the Cauchy surface breaking, finite size configurations generate asymmetric entanglement islands in contrast to the semi-infinite case. Depending on the size of the finite regions, qualitatively new behaviour arises, such as discontinuous evolution of the entanglement entropy and the absence of island formation. Finally, we show that the island prescription does not help us to solve the information paradox for certain finite size regions.Comment: v1: 55 pages, 19 figures; v2: 57 pages, 19 figures, references added, Sec. 5 presentation improve