636 research outputs found
Seventh Amendment Right to Jury Trial in Non-Article III Proceedings: A Study in Dysfunctional Constitutional Theory
The right to a jury trial in civil cases, as enumerated in the Seventh Amendment to the United States Constitution, is an integral part of the Bill of Rights. Nevertheless, in this Article, Professor Redish and Mr. La Fave argue that the Supreme Court has failed to preserve this right when Congress has relegated claims to a non-Article III forum. Furthermore, they argue, the Court has done so without providing any basis in constitutional theory to justify such a relinquishment.
Professor Redish and Mr. La Fave first examine the Supreme Court\u27s interpretation of the Seventh Amendment in instances where Congress has remained silent on the issue of the availability of a jury trial. They proceed to examine the Court\u27s contrasting response when Congress has explicitly directed that adjudication be held in a non-Article III forum, without a jury. In an effort to explain the Court\u27s approach to Seventh Amendment interpretation, they advance several possible doctrinal models, none of which, in their view, satisfactorily explains the Court\u27s apparent deference to Congress\u27s decision not to allow a jury trial. They suggest that the only rational explanation for the Court\u27s current Seventh Amendment jurisprudence is functionalism: deferring to Congress\u27s determination that some social or political objective outweighs constitutional considerations. They conclude that such deference by the Court, as the guardian of the Constitution, is not only unprincipled, but that such a practice actually endangers the supremacy of the Constitution and undermines the judiciary as the countermajoritarian check on the majoritarian branches of government
Symbolic Manipulators Affect Mathematical Mindsets
Symbolic calculators like Mathematica are becoming more commonplace among
upper level physics students. The presence of such a powerful calculator can
couple strongly to the type of mathematical reasoning students employ. It does
not merely offer a convenient way to perform the computations students would
have otherwise wanted to do by hand. This paper presents examples from the work
of upper level physics majors where Mathematica plays an active role in
focusing and sustaining their thought around calculation. These students still
engage in powerful mathematical reasoning while they calculate but struggle
because of the narrowed breadth of their thinking. Their reasoning is drawn
into local attractors where they look to calculation schemes to resolve
questions instead of, for example, mapping the mathematics to the physical
system at hand. We model the influence of Mathematica as an integral part of
the constant feedback that occurs in how students frame, and hence focus, their
work
Emerging technologies in physics education
Three emerging technologies in physics education are evaluated from the
interdisciplinary perspective of cognitive science and physics education
research. The technologies - Physlet Physics, the Andes Intelligent Tutoring
System (ITS), and Microcomputer-Based Laboratory (MBL) Tools - are assessed
particularly in terms of their potential at promoting conceptual change,
developing expert-like problem-solving skills, and achieving the goals of the
traditional physics laboratory. Pedagogical methods to maximize the potential
of each educational technology are suggested.Comment: Accepted for publication in the Journal of Science Education and
Technology; 20 page
Addressing student models of energy loss in quantum tunnelling
We report on a multi-year, multi-institution study to investigate student
reasoning about energy in the context of quantum tunnelling. We use ungraded
surveys, graded examination questions, individual clinical interviews, and
multiple-choice exams to build a picture of the types of responses that
students typically give. We find that two descriptions of tunnelling through a
square barrier are particularly common. Students often state that tunnelling
particles lose energy while tunnelling. When sketching wave functions, students
also show a shift in the axis of oscillation, as if the height of the axis of
oscillation indicated the energy of the particle. We find inconsistencies
between students' conceptual, mathematical, and graphical models of quantum
tunnelling. As part of a curriculum in quantum physics, we have developed
instructional materials to help students develop a more robust and less
inconsistent picture of tunnelling, and present data suggesting that we have
succeeded in doing so.Comment: Originally submitted to the European Journal of Physics on 2005 Feb
10. Pages: 14. References: 11. Figures: 9. Tables: 1. Resubmitted May 18 with
revisions that include an appendix with the curriculum materials discussed in
the paper (4 page small group UW-style tutorial
Epistemic Complexity and the Journeyman-Expert Transition
Physics students can encounter difficulties in physics problem solving as a
result of failing to use knowledge that they have but do not perceive as
relevant or appropriate. In previous work the authors have demonstrated that
some of these difficulties may be epistemological. Students may limit the kinds
of knowledge that they use. For example, they may use formal manipulations and
ignore physical sense making or vice versa. Both beginning (novice) and
intermediate (journeymen) students demonstrate these difficulties. Learning
both to switch one's epistemological lens on a problem and to integrate
different kinds of knowledge is a critical component of learning to solve
problems in physics effectively. In this paper, we present two case studies in
which journeyman students (upper-division physics majors) demonstrate switching
between epistemological resources in approaching a complex problem. We
conjecture that mastering these epistemological skills is an essential
component of learning complex problem solving in physics.Comment: 12 page
Learning physics in context: a study of student learning about electricity and magnetism
This paper re-centres the discussion of student learning in physics to focus
on context. In order to do so, a theoretically-motivated understanding of
context is developed. Given a well-defined notion of context, data from a novel
university class in electricity and magnetism are analyzed to demonstrate the
central and inextricable role of context in student learning. This work sits
within a broader effort to create and analyze environments which support
student learning in the sciencesComment: 36 pages, 4 Figure
Making Sense of the Legendre Transform
The Legendre transform is an important tool in theoretical physics, playing a
critical role in classical mechanics, statistical mechanics, and
thermodynamics. Yet, in typical undergraduate or graduate courses, the power of
motivation and elegance of the method are often missing, unlike the treatments
frequently enjoyed by Fourier transforms. We review and modify the presentation
of Legendre transforms in a way that explicates the formal mathematics,
resulting in manifestly symmetric equations, thereby clarifying the structure
of the transform algebraically and geometrically. Then we bring in the physics
to motivate the transform as a way of choosing independent variables that are
more easily controlled. We demonstrate how the Legendre transform arises
naturally from statistical mechanics and show how the use of dimensionless
thermodynamic potentials leads to more natural and symmetric relations.Comment: 11 pages, 3 figure
- âŠ