Pattern of locoregional failure in postoperative cases of locally advanced carcinoma of buccal mucosa treated with unilateral versus bilateral neck radiation: lesson learned from a basic practice setup

Background: Carcinoma of buccal mucosa forms a sizeable percentage of the diagnosed oral cavity cancers in India. There is limited data on elective treatment of the contralateral neck for well-lateralized carcinoma with no involved nodes in the contralateral neck. We conducted this study to compare locoregional control in patients treated with unilateral vs. bilateral neck irradiation. Materials and methods: 48 patients with carcinoma of buccal mucosa were selected. Patients were divided into unilateral and bilateral arms based on radiation treatment of the ipsilateral or bilateral neck. All patients received adjuvant radiation with Cobalt 60 unit. Patient-specific and follow-up data were collected from records and dosimetric data from TPS. Chi-square and unpaired t-test was used to compare data between arms and Kaplan Meier plot; Cox regression was used for survival analysis. Results: After a median follow-up of 23 months, 15 (31.3%) patients had developed disease recurrence, 8 and 7 in the unilateral and bilateral arms, respectively (p = 0.591). There was no contralateral neck failure during the follow-up period. The 2-year disease-free survival was 68.2% and 72.2% in the unilateral and bilateral arms, respectively. Among risk factors for disease recurrence, Depth of Invasion, delay in starting radiation and PTV coverage were significant contributing factors. Cox multivariate regression suggested DOI and delay in starting radiation to be significant prognostic factors for DFS. Conclusion: Bilateral neck radiation does not provide any advantage over ipsilateral neck radiation for properly selected well lateralized buccal mucosal squamous cell carcinoma. Ipsilateral neck radiation facilitates better sparing of organs at risk