The Origin and Shaping of Planetary Nebulae: Putting the Binary Hypothesis to the Test

Planetary nebulae (PNe) are circumstellar gas ejected during an intense mass-losing phase in the the lives of asymptotic giant branch stars. PNe have a stunning variety of shapes, most of which are not spherically symmetric. The debate over what makes and shapes the circumstellar gas of these evolved, intermediate mass stars has raged for two decades. Today the community is reaching a consensus that single stars cannot trivially manufacture PNe and impart to them non spherical shapes and that a binary companion, possibly even a sub-stellar one, might be needed in a majority of cases. This theoretical conjecture has however not been tested observationally. In this review we discuss the problem both from the theoretical and observational standpoints, explaining the obstacles that stand in the way of a clean observational test and ways to ameliorate the situation. We also discuss indirect tests of this hypothesis and its implications for stellar and galactic astrophysics.Comment: 28 pages of text. 4 tables 9 figures. Accepted by PASP Review

Binary central stars of planetary nebula

Only a handful of binary central stars of planetary nebulae (PNe) are known today, due to the difficulty of detecting their companions. Preliminary results from radial velocity surveys, however, seem to indicate that binarity plays a fundamental,rather than marginal role in the evolution of PNe and that the close binary fraction might be much larger than the currently known value of 10-15%. In this review, we list all the known binary central stars, giving an updated census of their numbers and selected characteristics. A review is also given of the techniques used to detect binaries as well as selected characteristics of related stellar classes which might provide constraints (or additional puzzles) to the theory of PN evolution. Finally, we will formulate the conjecture that all PNe derive from binary interactions and suggest that this is not inconsistent with our current knowledge.Comment: 8 pages, no figures. Review presented at IAU Symposium 234 on Planetary Nebulae. Proceedings in pres

Do most planetary nebulae derive from binaries? I Population synthesis model of the galactic planetary nebula population produced by singlestars and binaries

We present a population synthesis calculation to derive the total number of planetary nebulae (PN) in the Galaxy that descend from single stars and stars in binary systems. Using the most recent literature results on galactic and stellar formation as well as stellar evolution, we predict the total number of galactic PNe with radii <0.9 pc to be (46,000 +/- 13,000). We do not claim this to be the complete population, since there can be visible PNe with radii larger than this limit. However, by taking this limit, we make our predicted population inherently comparable to the observationally-based value of Peimbert, who determined (7200 +/- 1800) PNe should reside in the Galaxy today. Our prediction is discrepant with the observations at the 2.9-sigma level, a disagreement which we argue is meaningful in view of our specific treatment of the uncertainty. We conclude that it is likely that only a subset of the stars thought to be capable of making a visible PN, actually do. In the second paper in this series, an argument will be presented that the bulk of the galactic PN population might be better explained if only binaries produce PNe. The predicted PN formation rate density from single stars and binaries is (1.1 +/- 0.5) x 10^{-12} PN/yr per cubic pc in the local neighborhood. This number is lower than the most recent PN birthrate density estimates of 2.1 x 10^{-12} PN/yr per cubic pc, which are based on local PN counts and the PN distance scale, but more in line with the white dwarf birthrate densities determined by Liebert et al. ((1.0 +/- 0.25) x 10^{-12} WD/yr per cubic pc). The predicted PN birthrate density will be revised down, if we assume that only binaries make PNe. This revision will imply that the PN distance scale has to be revised to larger values.Comment: 52 pages (referee format), 14 figures. Accepted by Ap

M4-18: The planetary nebula and its WC10 central star

We present a detailed analysis of the planetary nebula M4-18 (G146.7+07.6) and its WC10-type Wolf-Rayet central star, based on high quality optical spectroscopy (WHT/UES, INT/IDS, WIYN/DensPak) and imaging (HST/WFPC2). From a non-LTE model atmosphere analysis of the stellar spectrum, we derive Teff=31kK, log(Mdot/(Msun yr))=-6.05, v_inf=160 km/s and abundance number ratios of H/He<0.5, C/He=0.60 and O/He=0.10. These parameters are remarkably similar to He2-113 ([WC10]). Assuming an identical stellar mass to that determined by De Marco et al. for He2-113, we obtain a distance of 6.8kpc to M4-18 (E(B-V)=0.55mag from nebular and stellar techniques). This implies that the planetary nebula of M4-18 has a dynamical age of 3100 years, in contrast to >270 years for He2-113. This is supported by the much higher electron density of the latter. These observations may only be reconciled with evolutionary predictions if [WC]-type stars exhibit a range in stellar masses. Photo-ionization modelling of M4-18 is carried out using our stellar WR flux distribution, together with blackbody and Kurucz energy distributions obtained from Zanstra analyses. We conclude that the ionizing energy distribution from the Wolf-Rayet model provides the best consistency with the observed nebular properties, although discrepancies remain.Comment: 12 pages, 9 figures, accepted for MNRAS (latex uses mn.sty

Cool Wolf-Rayet central stars and their planetary nebulae

The research presented in this thesis is concerned with the properties of Wolf-Rayet central stars and their planetary nebulae (PN). Radial and nebular expansion velocities, reddenings and distances have been derived using different methods. A detailed analysis of the nebular physical parameters and abundances has been carried out for the PN of four cool Wolf-Rayet central stars, based on high resolution optical and UV spectroscopy. For the same sample, HST and ground based images are presented. Photoionization modelling of the PN is undertaken using different model stellar atmospheres and a comparison with empirically derived parameters is carried out. Non-LTE Wolf-Rayet stellar atmosphere modelling is described to the winds of two central stars with WC10 spectra. From this, stellar parameters are derived which are compared with estimates from independent model codes. The theory of low-temperature dielectronic recombination is applied and a method for the direct determination of the wind electron temperature is developed and applied to one WC11 and four WC10 central stars. Direct analysis of the stellar emission line spectrum of three of the four WC10 central stars is carried out using recombination line theory. A comparison is made between abundances derived using the non-LTE models and from recombination line analysis. Parameters derived from the non-LTE Wolf-Rayet models are used in an investigation of optical depth effects in the wind recombination lines. From this it is shown, for the first time, that low-lying lines usually considered to be optically thick and hence unsuitable for abundance determination, can be employed without substantial systematic effects. On the other hand, lines arising from dielectronic states are found to yield systematically lower abundances due to their being in LTE with the continuum. A classification system for Wolf-Rayet central stars is also developed, consistent with the classification of massive Wolf-Rayet stars

Constraints on Common Envelope Magnetic Fields from Observations of Jets in Planetary Nebulae

The common envelope (CE) interaction describes the swallowing of a nearby companion by a growing, evolving star. CEs that take place during the asymptotic giant branch phase of the primary and may lead to the formation of a planetary nebula (PN) with a post-CE close binary in the middle. We have used published observations of masses and kinematics of jets in four post-CE PN to infer physical characteristics of the CE interaction. In three of the four systems studied, Abell 63, ETHOS 1 and the Necklace PN, the kinematics indicate that the jets were launched a few thousand years before the CE and we favour a scenario where this happened before Roche lobe overflow, although better models of wind accretion and wind Roche lobe overflow are needed. The magnetic fields inferred to launch pre-CE jets are of the order of a few Gauss. In the fourth case, NGC 6778, the kinematics indicate that the jets were launched about 3000 years after the CE interaction. Magnetic fields of the order of a few hundreds to a few thousands Gauss are inferred in this case, approximately in line with predictions of post-CE magnetic fields. However, we remark that in the case of this system, it is impossible to find a reasonable scenario for the formation of the two jet pairs observed: the small orbital separation would preclude the formation of even one accretion disk able to supply the necessary accretion rate to cause the observed jets.Comment: 9 pages, accepted by MNRAS, Key words: Magnetic Fields, ISM: Jets and Outflows, Planetary Nebulae: Individual: Necklace, Planetary Nebulae: Individual: Abell 63, Planetary Nebulae: Individual: ETHOS 1, Planetary Nebulae: Individual: NGC 677

[WC] and PG1159 Central Stars of Planetary Nebula: the Need for an Alternative to the Born-Again Scenario

Hydrogen-deficient central stars of planetary nebula such as Wolf-Rayet and PG1159 central stars and some weak emission line stars are primarily composed of helium and carbon. This abundance is well explained by a scenario where a single post-AGB star experiences a last helium shell flash which ingests and burns, or simply dilutes, the remaining hydrogen atmosphere. But despite its success in matching the photospheric abundances of these stars, this scenario is faced with several observational challenges. A binary scenario is proposed here as a more natural way to face some of the most stringent observational constraints. In this scenario the H-rich primary in a close binary formed during a common envelope on the AGB, suffers a last helium shell flash, which results in a H-deficient primary with some of the characteristics needed to match the observations.Comment: 12 pages, 2 figures. To be published in the proceedings of the third symposium on hydrogen deficient stars. Tubingen September 200

The Effect of Tides on the Population of PN from Interacting Binaries

We have used the tidal equations of Zahn to determine the maximum orbital distance at which companions are brought into Roche lobe contact with their giant primary, when the primary expands during the giant phases. This is a key step when determining the rates of interaction between giants and their companions. Our stellar structure calculations are presented as maximum radii reached during the red and asymptotic giant branch (RGB and AGB, respectively) stages of evolution for masses between 0.8 and 4.0 Mo (Z=0.001 - 0.04) and compared with other models to gauge the uncertainty on radii deriving from details of these calculations. We find overall tidal capture distances that are typically 1-4 times the maximum radial extent of the giant star, where companions are in the mass range from 1 Jupiter mass to a mass slightly smaller than the mass of the primary. We find that only companions at initial orbital separations between ~320 and ~630 Ro will be typically captured into a Roche lobe-filling interaction or a common envelope on the AGB. Comparing these limits with the period distribution for binaries that will make PN, we deduce that in the standard scenario where all ~1-8 Mo stars make a PN, at most 2.5 per cent of all PN should have a post-common envelope central star binary, at odds with the observational lower limit of 15-20 per cent. The observed over-abundance of post-interaction central stars of PN cannot be easily explained considering the uncertainties. We examine a range of explanations for this discrepancy.Comment: 19 pages, 16 figures, accepted by Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Societ