The quasi-universality of nestedness in the structure of quantitative plant-parasite interactions

Understanding the relationships between host range and pathogenicity for parasites, and between the efficiency and scope of immunity for hosts are essential to implement efficient disease control strategies. In the case of plant parasites, most studies have focused on describing qualitative interactions and a variety of genetic and evolutionary models has been proposed in this context. Although plant quantitative resistance benefits from advantages in terms of durability, we presently lack models that account for quantitative interactions between plants and their parasites and the evolution of these interactions. Nestedness and modularity are important features to unravel the overall structure of host-parasite interaction matrices. Here, we analysed these two features on 32 matrices of quantitative pathogenicity trait data gathered from 15 plant-parasite pathosystems consisting of either annual or perennial plants along with fungi or oomycetes, bacteria, nematodes, insects and viruses. The performance of several nestedness and modularity algorithms was evaluated through a simulation approach, which helped interpretation of the results. We observed significant modularity in only six of the 32 matrices, with two or three modules detected. For three of these matrices, modules could be related to resistance quantitative trait loci present in the host. In contrast, we found high and significant nestedness in 30 of the 32 matrices. Nestedness was linked to other properties of plant-parasite interactions. First, pathogenicity trait values were explained in majority by a parasite strain effect and a plant accession effect, with no parasite-plant interaction term. Second, correlations between the efficiency and scope of the resistance of plant genotypes, and between the host range breadth and pathogenicity level of parasite strains were overall positive. This latter result questions the efficiency of strategies based on the deployment of several genetically-differentiated cultivars of a given crop species in the case of quantitative plant immunity

Caractérisation des déterminants génétiques et moléculaires liés à la résistance au dépérissement bactérien chez l'abricotier et analyse des risques associés

Within the genus Prunus, that contains highly valuable species, apricot (Prunusarmeniaca L.) is an emblematic Mediterranean crop. But apricot cultivation is constrainedby many biotic stresses, among which bacterial canker caused by Pseudomonas syringae(Psy) is particularly severe and can lead to the death of the trees in regions with humidand cold winters. Differences of susceptibilities have been observed between cultivars inorchards and create opportunities for disease management through genetic improvement.This thesis aimed to (i) identify genetic determinants linked to partial resistance to thebacterium and to (ii) study a factorial interaction design between both diversities of theplant and the pathogen (GxG interaction) in order to assess resistance genericity anddurability. With regard to the first objective, two complementary approaches were used :QRL (Quantitative Resistance Loci) mapping over four biparental progenies, amongwhich three were obtained with a cross involving a common genitor, and a genome-wideassociation study on a core-collection. The phenotypic data mobilized in this work rely onsymptoms issued from controlled inoculations and on mortality notations followingnatural infections in the orchard. These approaches led to the detection of 22 QRLs amongwhich only 2 QRLs, located on chromosomes 6 and 7, co-localized between the twomethods. Two main regions detected in the association study, over the chromosomes 5and 6, appeared to be in linkage disequilibrium and controlled 26 and 43% of the variationof the symptoms. A complementarity between two mechanisms, one that involves blockingthe infection of Psy and the other that limits bacterial mobility in the tissues has beenrevealed through the detection of QRLs over chromosomes 3, 6, 8 for one mechanism and1,4, 6 for the other, respectively. The second objective was fulfilled with a study of afactorial interaction design between 20 apricot accessions and 9 Psy strains, which weresampled according to the previous knowledge of the disease epidemiology in the orchard.Statistical analyses of phenotypic data obtained both from the orchard and a laboratorytest showed a clear predominance of the strain effect on symptom variability and a weakimportance of the GxG interaction factor. This last result highlighted a potentialgenericity of the resistance factors and favorable perspectives of durability in the orchard.The results issued from this thesis contribute to a better understanding of the mechanismsunderlying partial resistance of apricot to bacterial canker. Moreover, it provide markersand haplotypes of interest which could be mobilized in breeding programs.Parmi les Prunus, genre botanique d’intérêt économique important, l’abricotier (Prunusarmeniaca L.) est une culture emblématique du Bassin Méditerranéen. Il y est soumis à des contraintes biotiques importantes, parmi lesquelles le dépérissement bactérien, causé par Pseudomonas syringae (Psy), peut mener à des phénomènes de mortalité en verger au niveau des régions à hivers froids et humides. La mise en évidence de différences variétales en verger offre potentiellement des perspectives de contrôle de la maladie à travers le levier génétique. Aussi, ce travail de thèse avait pour principaux objectifs (i) d’identifier chez la plante des régions génomiques liées à la résistance partielle à la bactérie et (ii) d’étudier un plan factoriel d’interaction entre les diversités de la plante et de la bactérie (GxG) afin d’apprécier la généricité de la résistance et sa durabilité. Afin de répondre au premier objectif, deux approches complémentaires ont été mobilisées : une cartographie de QRLs (Quantitative Resistance Loci) sur quatre populations biparentales dont trois sont issues du croisement avec un géniteur commun ainsi qu’une analyse d’association sur une core-collection. Les données phénotypiques mobilisées correspondent à des symptômes issus d’inoculations contrôlées ainsi que des notes de mortalité obtenues suite à infection naturelle en verger. Ces deux approches (analyse de liaison et d’association) ont permis de mettre en évidence 22 QRLs de résistance, parmi lesquels seuls 2 QRLs sur les chromosomes 6 et 7 colocalisent entre les deux approches. Deux régions majeures détectées en étude d’association sur les chromosomes 5 et 6 se sont révélées être en déséquilibre de liaison et contrôlent près de 26 et 43% de la variation des symptômes. Deux mécanismes complémentaires reposant sur le blocage de l’infection de Psy et sur la limitation de la progression locale de la bactérie dans les tissus ont été mis en évidence à travers la détection de QRLs sur les chromosomes 3, 6, 8 d’une part et 1,4et 6 d’autre part. Le second objectif a été abordé grâce à une étude d’un plan factoriel d’interaction entre 20 accessions d’abricotier et 9 souches de Psy, échantillonnées d’après la connaissance de l’épidémiologie de la maladie en verger. L’analyse statistique de ce dispositif mis en œuvre à la fois en verger et en laboratoire a démontré la prédominance de l’effet du facteur souche dans la variabilité des symptômes étudiés et la très faible importance du facteur d’interaction GxG, indiquant une potentielle généricité des facteurs de résistance et des perspectives favorables à leur durabilité en verger.Les résultats issus de cette thèse contribuent à offrir une meilleure compréhension des mécanismes de résistance partielle au dépérissement bactérien de l’abricotier et fournissent des marqueurs et haplotypes, potentiellement mobilisables dans le cadre de programmes d’innovation variétale

Caracterization of genetic and molecular determinants of resistance to bacterial canker in apricot and analysis of the associated risks

Parmi les Prunus, genre botanique d’intérêt économique important, l’abricotier (Prunusarmeniaca L.) est une culture emblématique du Bassin Méditerranéen. Il y est soumis à des contraintes biotiques importantes, parmi lesquelles le dépérissement bactérien, causé par Pseudomonas syringae (Psy), peut mener à des phénomènes de mortalité en verger au niveau des régions à hivers froids et humides. La mise en évidence de différences variétales en verger offre potentiellement des perspectives de contrôle de la maladie à travers le levier génétique. Aussi, ce travail de thèse avait pour principaux objectifs (i) d’identifier chez la plante des régions génomiques liées à la résistance partielle à la bactérie et (ii) d’étudier un plan factoriel d’interaction entre les diversités de la plante et de la bactérie (GxG) afin d’apprécier la généricité de la résistance et sa durabilité. Afin de répondre au premier objectif, deux approches complémentaires ont été mobilisées : une cartographie de QRLs (Quantitative Resistance Loci) sur quatre populations biparentales dont trois sont issues du croisement avec un géniteur commun ainsi qu’une analyse d’association sur une core-collection. Les données phénotypiques mobilisées correspondent à des symptômes issus d’inoculations contrôlées ainsi que des notes de mortalité obtenues suite à infection naturelle en verger. Ces deux approches (analyse de liaison et d’association) ont permis de mettre en évidence 22 QRLs de résistance, parmi lesquels seuls 2 QRLs sur les chromosomes 6 et 7 colocalisent entre les deux approches. Deux régions majeures détectées en étude d’association sur les chromosomes 5 et 6 se sont révélées être en déséquilibre de liaison et contrôlent près de 26 et 43% de la variation des symptômes. Deux mécanismes complémentaires reposant sur le blocage de l’infection de Psy et sur la limitation de la progression locale de la bactérie dans les tissus ont été mis en évidence à travers la détection de QRLs sur les chromosomes 3, 6, 8 d’une part et 1,4et 6 d’autre part. Le second objectif a été abordé grâce à une étude d’un plan factoriel d’interaction entre 20 accessions d’abricotier et 9 souches de Psy, échantillonnées d’après la connaissance de l’épidémiologie de la maladie en verger. L’analyse statistique de ce dispositif mis en œuvre à la fois en verger et en laboratoire a démontré la prédominance de l’effet du facteur souche dans la variabilité des symptômes étudiés et la très faible importance du facteur d’interaction GxG, indiquant une potentielle généricité des facteurs de résistance et des perspectives favorables à leur durabilité en verger.Les résultats issus de cette thèse contribuent à offrir une meilleure compréhension des mécanismes de résistance partielle au dépérissement bactérien de l’abricotier et fournissent des marqueurs et haplotypes, potentiellement mobilisables dans le cadre de programmes d’innovation variétale.Within the genus Prunus, that contains highly valuable species, apricot (Prunusarmeniaca L.) is an emblematic Mediterranean crop. But apricot cultivation is constrainedby many biotic stresses, among which bacterial canker caused by Pseudomonas syringae(Psy) is particularly severe and can lead to the death of the trees in regions with humidand cold winters. Differences of susceptibilities have been observed between cultivars inorchards and create opportunities for disease management through genetic improvement.This thesis aimed to (i) identify genetic determinants linked to partial resistance to thebacterium and to (ii) study a factorial interaction design between both diversities of theplant and the pathogen (GxG interaction) in order to assess resistance genericity anddurability. With regard to the first objective, two complementary approaches were used :QRL (Quantitative Resistance Loci) mapping over four biparental progenies, amongwhich three were obtained with a cross involving a common genitor, and a genome-wideassociation study on a core-collection. The phenotypic data mobilized in this work rely onsymptoms issued from controlled inoculations and on mortality notations followingnatural infections in the orchard. These approaches led to the detection of 22 QRLs amongwhich only 2 QRLs, located on chromosomes 6 and 7, co-localized between the twomethods. Two main regions detected in the association study, over the chromosomes 5and 6, appeared to be in linkage disequilibrium and controlled 26 and 43% of the variationof the symptoms. A complementarity between two mechanisms, one that involves blockingthe infection of Psy and the other that limits bacterial mobility in the tissues has beenrevealed through the detection of QRLs over chromosomes 3, 6, 8 for one mechanism and1,4, 6 for the other, respectively. The second objective was fulfilled with a study of afactorial interaction design between 20 apricot accessions and 9 Psy strains, which weresampled according to the previous knowledge of the disease epidemiology in the orchard.Statistical analyses of phenotypic data obtained both from the orchard and a laboratorytest showed a clear predominance of the strain effect on symptom variability and a weakimportance of the GxG interaction factor. This last result highlighted a potentialgenericity of the resistance factors and favorable perspectives of durability in the orchard.The results issued from this thesis contribute to a better understanding of the mechanismsunderlying partial resistance of apricot to bacterial canker. Moreover, it provide markersand haplotypes of interest which could be mobilized in breeding programs

Genome-wide association study of partial resistance to bacterial canker of apricot

Apricot, a highly valuable crop is threatened by the growing importance of bacterial canker caused by Pseudomonas syringae. Among the key factors able to control the disease, genetic improvement is a promising measure. The variability of susceptibility on branches and the characterization of genetic determinants through a genome wide association study were thus investigated on a core-collection.73 accessions were annually inoculated in the orchard with an aggressive strain of the bacterium for 4 years. Phenotypic data about the length of both external canker (lgc) and superficial browning (bs) of tissues were collected. The analysis displayed a highly environmental-dependent genetic variation with broad-sense heritabilities of lgc and bs reaching respectively 59% and 78% for the most severe year. Considering the two variance-maximizing years, genetic (G) and genetic x year (GxY) BLUP were predicted for each variable using a linear mixed model. Association analysis were performed with a 63,236 SNP set through both a multi-variate (GEMMA) and a multi-locus genome-wide analysis.By exploiting the between-years (multi-locus model on G and GxY terms) and between-phenotypes (multivariate model on lgc-bs G terms) correlations, 11 significant associations have been detected. Among them, two SNP impacting both lgc and bs expressions over the two studied years and explaining 41% and 31% of the total phenotypic variance were identified on chromosomes 5 and 6. A long-range linkage disequilibrium had been noticed between these two markers suggesting a co-selection effect. The associated SNP reported from this work will open up new opportunities for a Marker-assisted selection strategy

Genome-wide association multi-locus and multi-variate linear mixed models reveal two linked loci with major effects on partial resistance of apricot to bacterial canker

Background: Diseases caused by Pseudomonas syringae (Ps) are recognized as the most damaging factors in fruit trees with a significant economic and sanitary impact on crops. Among them, bacterial canker of apricot is exceedingly difficult to control due to a lack of efficient prophylactic measures. Several sources of partial resistance have been identified among genetic resources but the underlying genetic pattern has not been elucidated thus far. In this study, we phenotyped bacterial canker susceptibility in an apricot core-collection of 73 accessions over 4 years by measuring canker and superficial browning lengths issued from artificial inoculations in the orchard. In order to investigate the genetic architecture of partial resistance, we performed a genome-wide association study using best linear unbiased predictors on genetic (G) and genetic x year (G × Y) interaction effects extracted from linear mixed models. Using a set of 63,236 single-nucleotide polymorphism markers genotyped in the germplasm over the whole genome, multi-locus and multi-variate mixed models aimed at mapping the resistance while controlling for relatedness between individuals.[br/] Results: We detected 11 significant associations over 7 candidate loci linked to disease resistance under the two most severe years. Colocalizations between G and G × Y terms indicated a modulation on allelic effect depending on environmental conditions. Among the candidate loci, two loci on chromosomes 5 and 6 had a high impact on both canker length and superficial browning, explaining 41 and 26% of the total phenotypic variance, respectively. We found unexpected long-range linkage disequilibrium (LD) between these two markers revealing an inter-chromosomal LD block linking the two underlying genes. This result supports the hypothesis of a co-adaptation effect due to selection through population demography. Candidate genes annotations suggest a functional pathway involving abscisic acid, a hormone mainly known for mediating abiotic stress responses but also reported as a potential factor in plant-pathogen interactions.[br/] Conclusions: Our study contributed to the first detailed characterization of the genetic determinants of partial resistance to bacterial canker in a Rosaceae species. It provided tools for fruit tree breeding by identifying progenitors with favorable haplotypes and by providing major-effect markers for a marker-assisted selection strategy

Sélection génomique - Quelles perspectives chez les Prunus ?

National audienc

Une structure emboîtée universelle pour les interactions quantitatives entre les plantes et leurs parasites ?

National audienc

Many different recipes but one flavor: A universal nested structure of quantitative interactions between plant genotypes and their parasites, including viruses

National audienc