Biotic homogenization or riparian refugia? Urban and wild land snail assemblages along a subtropical precipitation gradient

A noted impact of urbanization is the tendency for biotic homogenization, or the increase of similarity of geographically disparate communities. On the other hand, some urban habitats harbor biodiversity native to their region, a role potentially important in xeric landscapes, with irrigation increasing the coverage and availability of mesic habitats in an otherwise water-limited landscape. We assessed the relative importance of urban yards as agents of biotic homogenization or riparian refugia by characterizing community composition of Tamaulipan thornforest land snail assemblages across a pronounced precipitation gradient in far south Texas, USA. We quantified α- and β-diversity and assessed whether the land snail fauna of urban yards are more similar to each other across a precipitation gradient than they are to their wild counterparts, as well as determined the significance of moisture in driving Tamaulipan thornforest β-diversity, both in terms of turnover (changing species composition) and nestedness (species loss). Sites with both the wild and wet conditions had the highest values of species richness and abundance. Urban land snail communities were significantly homogenized, outweighing the influence of the precipitation gradient. We did not find urban yards served as a refuge for native, moisture-dependent, riparian snails. Our analyses find that turnover, not nestedness, is the largest contributor to β-diversity in these assemblages. Studies of urbanization should address regional spatial scales to quantify how urbanization modifies regional biodiversity arising from background environmental gradients. Such an approach could lead to improved understanding of how large metroplex areas could be used to maintain and even promote biodiversity

Terrestrial snail communities of the lower rio grande valley are affected by human disturbance and correlate with vegetation community composition

The lower Rio Grande Valley of Texas (LRGV) contains a unique, subtropical, semiarid floodplain with most of the few remaining Tamaulipan thorn forests in the United States. Less than 2% of Tamaulipan thorn forest remains, with urban and agricultural conversion potentially threatening diverse plant and animal communities native to the habitat. We performed vegetative community surveys and conducted a comprehensive survey of terrestrial snail communities in intact (refugia sites, minimally altered in recent times) and altered (previously cleared and regrown or restored) Tamaulipan thorn forest habitats of the LRGV. In a comparison of intact and altered sites that have comparable vegetation (paired sites), we found that intact sites had a less species-rich snail community than their altered counterparts, but this difference was not statistically significant. This counterintuitive result, in part reflects the fact that the most species-rich, intact snail communities (i.e., Sabal Palm Forest) have no altered (restored or regrown) counterparts and so were not included in the paired comparisons. A nestedness analysis supports this, finding that these unique intact sites, which have the highest species richness and no comparable restored sites, contain the largest pool of species in South Texas. Species richness of snails significantly correlated with a precipitation gradient. A general linear model incorporating mean canopy cover, mean plant height, plant abundance, and plant species richness shows a significant correlation with snail communities. This study is the only comprehensive survey of the snail communities of the lower Rio Grande Valley. - La cuenca baja del río Grande en Texas (LRGV) contiene una llanura de inundación única, subtropical y semiárida con la mayor´ıa de los remanentes de los bosques espinosos tamaulipecos en los Estados Unidos. Queda menos del 2% del bosque espinoso tamaulipeco, con la conversión a áreas urbanas y agrıcolas potencialmente amenazando las comunidades diversas de plantas y animales nativos del hábitat. Hicimos muestreos de comunidades vegetales y un muestreo comprensivo de comunidades de caracoles terrestres en hábitats de bosques espinosos tamaulipecos intactos (sitios refugio, con poca alteración en tiempos recientes) y perturbados (previamente cortados y recuperados o restaurados) en el LRGV. En una comparaci ´on de los sitios intactos con los perturbados con la vegetación comparable (sitios emparejados), sitios intactos tuvieron comunidades con menos riqueza de especies de caracoles que sus contrapartes alteradas, aunque la diferencia no fue estad´ısticamente significativa. Este resultado contra intuitivo, en parte refleja el hecho de que las comunidades intactas de caracoles mas ricas en especies (o sea, Sabal Palm Forest) no tienen contrapartes alteradas (restauradas o regeneradas) y por eso no fueron incluidas en las comparaciones emparejadas. Un análisis de anidamiento respalda esto, encontrando que estos ´unicos sitios intactos, que tienen la mayor riqueza de especies y ningun sitio comparable restaurado, contienen el grupo más grande de especies en el sur de Texas. La riqueza de especies de caracoles se correlacion significativamente con un gradiente de precipitación. Un modelo lineal general incorporando el promedio de cobertura del dosel, el promedio de altura vegetal, la abundancia de plantas, y la riqueza de especies de plantas muestra una correlación significativa con comunidades de caracoles. Este es el único muestreo comprensivo de las comunidades de caracoles de la cuenca baja del río Grande

Caveat consumptor notitia museo: Let the museum data user beware

Issue Lot accession information from natural history collections represents a potentially vital source of large datasets to test biodiversity, biogeography and macroecology hypotheses. But does such information provide an accurate portrayal of the natural world? We review the many types of bias and error intrinsic to museum collection data and consider how these factors may affect their ability to accurately test ecological hypotheses. Evidence We considered all Texas land snail collections from the two major repositories in the state and compared them with an ecological sample drawn across the same landscape. We found that museum collection localities were biased in favour of regions with higher human population densities and iconic destinations. They also tended to be made during attractive temporal windows. Small, uncharismatic taxa tended to be under-collected while larger, charismatic species were over-collected. As a result, for most species it was impossible to use museum lot frequency to accurately predict frequency and abundance in an ecological sample. Species misidentification rate was approximately 20%, while 4% of lots represented more than one species. Errors were spread across the entire shell size spectrum and were present in 75% of taxonomic families. Contingency table analysis documented significant dependence of both misidentification and mixed lot rates upon shell size and family richness. Conclusion Researchers should limit their use of museum record data to situations where their inherent biases and errors are irrelevant, rectifiable or explicitly considered. At the same time museums should begin incorporating expert specimen verification into their digitization programs