気管支喘息患者における努力肺活量(% FVC)の低下と気道炎症ならびに臨床病型との関連

Clinical features of asthmatics with a low % FVC (<80%) were studied in relation to airway inflammation and clinical asthma types. 1. Twenty four (75.0%) of the 32 subjects with a low % FVC had steroid-dependent intractable asthma. 2. A significant association between % FVC value and clinical asthma type was found. The value of % FVC was significantly lower in subjects with type II asthma (bronchiolar obstruction), in which significantly decreased proportion of lymphocytes,and significantly increased proportion of neutrophils in bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid were observed, than in those with type la-1 (simple bronchoconstriction) with (P<0.001) and without glucocorticoid therapy (P<0.02). 3. The % FVC value was significantly improved after treatment in type lb (hypersecretion) with BAL eosinophilia, but not in those with type II with BAL neutrophilia. These results demonstrate that marked decrease of % FVC in patients with asthma correlated with airway inflammation, and that airway reversibility by medication is very low in patients with type II asthma.努力肺活量(% FVC)低値を示す気管支喘息の臨床病態を明らかにするために気道炎症ならびに臨床病型との関連について検討を行った｡% FVCが80%未満の気管支喘息患者32名を対象として,スパイロメトリー,気管支肺胞洗浄(BAL)を施行し,臨床病態を解析し,治療効果の評価を行なった｡1.対象中24名(75%)の患者がステロイド依存性重症難治性喘息であった｡2.細気管支閉塞型喘息患者において,% FVC値の有意の低下が認められ,BAL液中のリンパ球の減少と好中球の増加が認められた｡3.FVC値,FEV1.0億の治療による改善は,BAL液中好酸球の増加を示す過分泌型喘息においては認められが,BAL液中好中球の増加を示す細気管支閉塞型喘息においては認められなかった｡ 以上より喘息患者における% FVC値の低下は気道炎症と関連しており,細気管支閉塞型喘息における治療による可逆性は著しく低下していることが示唆された

BAL液中好中球増加をともなわないⅡ型喘息について

Clinical features of asthma patients with bronchiolar obstruction (type Ⅱ asthma) were studied in relation to the proportion of neutrophils in bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid. Of 13 subjects studied, 7 were accompanied with BAL neutrophilia (53.5%) (BALn(+)) and 6 were without BAL neutrophilia (3.5%) (BALn(-)). 1. The mean age was higher in BALn(-) (66.0 years) than in BALn(+) patients (55.0 years). 2. Bronchial reactivity to methacholine was slightly higher in BALn(-) patients than in those with BALn(+). 3. The value of FEV1.0% was significantly lower in BALn(+) patints than in those with BALn(-) (p<0.01). 4. The proportion of BAL lymphocytes was signicantly more decreased in BALn(+) patients compared to the proportion in those with BALn(-) (p<0.001). 5. the values of serum IgG, IgA, and IgM were not significantly different between BALn(+) and BALn(-) patients, however, the value of IgG was more decreased in BALn(+) patients than in those with BALn(-). These results suggest that two kinds of type Ⅱ asthma ; one is with BAL neutrophilia related to suppressed immunity, and another is without BAL neutrophilia in part due to aging.細気管支閉塞型(Ⅱ型)喘息の臨床的特徴が,BAL液中の好中球頻度との関連のもとに検討された｡対象13例のうち,7例がBAL液中好中球増加(平均好中球頻度;53.5%)をともなう症例(BALn(+))で,残りの6例はBAL液中好中球増加 をともなわない(3.5%)症例(BALn(-))であった｡1.平均年齢は,BALn(+)症例(55.0才)に比べ,BALn(-)症例(66.0才)でより高い傾向が見られた｡2.メサコリンに対する気道過敏性は,BALn(+)症例に比べBALn(-)症例でやや高い傾向が見られたが,両者間に有意の差は見られなかった｡3.FEV1.0%値は,BALn(-)症例に比べBALn(+)症例で有意に低い値を示した(P<0.05)｡4.BAL液中リンパ球頻度はBALn(+)症例でBALn(-)症例に比べ有意に低い値を示した(P<0.001)｡5.血清IgG,IgAおよびIgM値には両者間に有意の差は見られなかったが,IgG値はBALn(+)症例でより低い傾向が見られた｡これらの結果より,Ⅱ型喘息にはBAL液中好中球増加を示す症例と示さない症例の2種類があること,そして前者は免疫能の低下と,そして後者は加齢とある程度の関連があることが示唆された

中高年発症型喘息患者におけるIgE系アレルギー反応の加令による変化

Age-related changes in IgE-mediated allergic reaction were examined in patients with late onset asthma, whose asthma occured over the age at onset of 40. 1. The number of patients with a high serum IgE level over 3001U/mℓ was larger in those between the ages at onset of 40 and 49 and over age at onset 60 than in those between the ages at onset 50 and 59. 2. A positive RAST score to Hdm and cockroach allergens was more frequently found in patients between 40 and 49 and over age 60 at onset compared to those between 50 and 59 at onset. In contrast, the number of patients with a positive RAST to Candida was larger in those between 50 and 59 at onset than in those of between 40 and 49 and over 60 at onset. 3. Severe asthma was more frequently and slight asthma was less frequently observed in patients between 50 and 59 at onset than in those of the other age at onset groups. These results suggest that IgE-mediated allergic reaction in patients between the ages at onset of 50 and 59 is different from that in those with early onset asthma, and that the reaction in patients between the ages at onset 40 and 49 and over 60 resembles to the reaction in those with early onset asthma.発症年令が40才以上の中高年発症型喘息患者におけるIgE系アレルギー反応の加令による変化について検討を加えた｡1.発症年令が40から49才と60才以上の患者では,50から59才の患者に比して血清IgE値が300IU/mℓ以上の高値を示す頻度が高い傾向が見られた。2.ダニ,ゴキブリに対するRAST陽性率は発症年令が50から59才の患者に比して,40から49才と60才以上の患者で高値を示した｡一方,カンジダに対するRAST陽性率は,発症年令が40から49才と60才以上の患者に比して,50から59才の患者で高値を示した｡3.発症年令が50から59才の患者では,他の発症年令の患者に比べて,重症例が多く,軽症例が少ない傾向が見られた｡以上の結果から,発症年令が50から59才の患者のIgE系アレルギー反応は若年発症型喘息患者と異なり,発症年令が40から49才と60才以上の患者のIgE系アレルギー反応は若年発症型喘息患者と 類似することが示唆された

気管支喘息に対する複合温泉療法の作用機序 2.内分泌･自律神経系および心因的要素に対する効果

Actions of spa therapy on endocrine-autonomic nerve system and psychological factors were analyzed in patients with bronchial asthma. In endocrine function, serum levels of cortisol and ACTH tended to increase after spa therapy. In autonomic nerve system, decrease in concentrations of serum adrenalin and noradrenalin was observed after spa therapy, and the difference between the initial levels before spa therapy and the levels after the therapy was significant in serum levels of adrenalin. However, serum levels of substance P and Bradykinin were not affected by spa therapy. To evaluate the action of spa therapy on mental condition in patients with asthma, four kinds of psychological tests, CMI, SDS, CAl and SD, were carried out. Improvement of mental disorders in patients with asthma is observed after spa therapy in all psychological tests. These results suggest that spa therapy acts effectively on endocrine-autonomic nerve system and improve psychological conditions.内分泌･自律神経系および心因的要素に対する温泉療法の効果が,気管支喘息を対象に検討された｡内分泌系では,血中コーチゾ-ルおよびACTH値が,温泉療法後に上昇することが示された｡また,自律神経系では,血中アドレナリンおよびノルアドレナリン濃度が温泉療法により減少することが示され,特に,血中アドレナリンは温泉療法前後の濃度に有意の差が見られた｡しかしながら,血中サブスタンスPおよびブラジキニン濃度には,温泉療法による有意の変動は見られなかった｡心因的要素に対する温泉療法の作用を検討するため,CMI,SDS,CAIおよびSDの4種類の心身医学的検査が行われた｡その結果,いずれの心身医学的検査においても,温泉療法により疾患に不利に働く心因的要素が改善する傾向が見られた｡これらの結果より,温泉療法が内分泌･自律神経系に対して有用な作用を有し,また,疾患に不利な心因的要素を改善させる作用を有していることがある程度示唆された

温泉療法による気管支喘息患者の心理的障害の改善

To evaluate improvement of mental disorders by spa therapy for 1-2 months, three kinds of psychological examinations, CMI (Cornel Medical Index), SDS (Selfrating Depression Scale) and CAI (Comprehensive Asthma Inventory) tests, were performed in 37 patients with asthma before and after spa therapy. 1. In CMI test, the scores of physical symptoms, respiratory symptoms, and CIJ symptoms significantly decreased after spa therapy. The score of psychical symptoms tended to decrease after the therapy, however, this was not significant. 2. The mean score of the subjects over 40 points in SDS test significantly decreased from 45.7 points before spa therapy to 37.5 after the therapy. 3. Mental disorders evaluated by various categories in CAI test were significantly improved after spa therapy. The average score in CAI test significantly decreased from 37.1 to 27.8 after the therapy. These results demonstrate that psychological disorders in patients with asthma are improved by spa therapy.気管支喘息に対する温泉療法(1-2ヶ月)による心理的障害の改善を評価するために,3種類の心理学的調査:CMI(Cornel Medical Index),SDS(Selfrationg Depression Scale),CAI(Comprehensive Asthma Inventory)を,気管支喘息患者37例を対象として,入院時と退院時に実施し比較した｡①CMIでは,身体的自覚症,呼吸器系症状およびCIJ症状が,温泉療法後に有意に改善した｡②SDS値が40以上の症例において,温泉療法後,平均値は45.7から37.5へ有意に減少した｡③CAIの種々の心理学的項目により評価した心理的障害は,温泉療法後に有意に改善した｡各心理項目の平均値であるCAIスコアは,治療後,37.1から27.8へ有意に低下した｡これらの結果から,気管支喘息患者に観察される心理的障害は,温泉療法により改善することが示唆された

Ⅱ型(細気管支閉塞)喘息と閉塞性細気管支炎における細気管支領域の炎症反応の差

Ventilatory function and inflammatory cells in airways were compared between patients with type Ⅱ (bronchiolar obstruction) asthma and those with obstructive bronchiolitis. 1. Age and age at onset were higher in patients with type Ⅱ asthma than in those with obstructive bronchiolitis. IgE-mediated allergic reaction was observed in patients with type Ⅱ asthma, but not in those with obstructive bronchiolitis. 2. In ventilatory function tests, all ventilatory parameters examined were lower in patients with type Ⅱ asthma compared to those with obstructive bronchiolitis, and the differences were significant in FEV1.0% (p<0.001), % MMF (p<0.02), and V50 (p<0.01). 3. The proportion of BAL neutrophils was very high in type Ⅱ asthma (55.7%) and obstructive bronchiolitis (74.4%), however, this was not significant. 4. Absolute numbers/BAL fluid of total cells, BAL macrophages and BAL neutrophils were significantly higher in patients with obstructive bronchiolitis than in those with type Ⅱ asthma. 5. The results on absolute number/mℓ of BAL cells demonstrated that number of BAL neutrophils markedly larger in patients with obstructive bronchiolitis compared to those with type Ⅱ asthma. These results show that high proportion of BAL neutrophils was observed in the two respiratory diseases, however, the degree of inflammation in airways was markedly greater in obstructive bronchiolitis.Ⅱ型喘息と閉塞性細気管支炎の臨床的特徴について,換気機能および気道炎症反応を中心に検討を加えた｡1.年齢,および発症年齢とも閉塞性細気管支炎に比べⅡ型喘息において高い傾向が見られた｡IgE系反応はⅡ型喘息では観察されたが,閉塞性細気管支炎では見られなかった｡2.換気機能では,測定された全ての換気パラメーターにおいて,その値は閉塞性細気管支炎に比べⅡ型喘息でより低い値を示し,FEV1.0%,% MMFおよび% V50では有意の差が見られた｡3.BAL液中好中球頻度は,Ⅱ型喘息(55.7%),閉塞性細気管支炎(74.4%)いずれにおいても高い値を示したが,両者間に有意の差は見られなかった｡4.一方,BAL液中の絶対数では,Ⅱ型喘息に比べ,閉塞性細気管支炎において,総細胞数,マクロファージおよび好中球数が有意の高値を示した｡5.また,lmℓあたりの細胞数の比較でも,閉塞性細気管支炎で好中球数が著明な高値を示した｡これらの結果より,この2疾患では気道内好中球増多は同様に見られるものの,その気道炎症の程度は明らかに閉塞性細気管支炎でより高度であることが示された

肺活量(FVC)低値を示す気管支喘息の臨床的特徴

Clinical features of asthma patients with a low % FVC (<75%) were studied in relation to clinical asthma type and disease severity. 1. The value of % FVC was not related to patient age. 2. A significant association between % FVC value and clinical asthma type was found. The value of % FVC was significantly lower in subjects with type Ⅱ asthma (bronchiolar obstruction) than in those with type Ia-1 and type Ia-2 (simple bronchoconstriction) (p<0.001). 3. % FVC value significantly correlated with disease severity. The value in the subjects tended to decrease as their asthma conditions were more severe. 4. The % FVC value in the subjects was improved after treatment (complex spa therapy). These results demonstrate that a significant correlation is present between low % FVC and disease severity in asthma patients with a low % FVC.% 肺活量が75%以下の低値を示す気管支喘息について,その臨床的特徴を,臨床病型や重症度との関連のもとに検討した｡1.% 肺活量と年齢との間には関連は見られなかった｡2.% 肺活量と臨床病型との問には有意の関連が見られ,Ⅱ型喘息(細気管支閉塞型)における% 肺活量は,Ia-1型やIa-2型などの単純性気管支攣縮型に比べ,有意に低い値を示した｡3.% 肺活量はまた喘息の重症度と有意の関連を示した｡これらの症例では,喘息の重症度が増すにつれて,% 肺活量は減少する傾向が見られた｡4.これら症例の低値を示す% 肺活量は,治療(複合温泉療法)により改善される傾向が見られた｡以上の結果より,これらの症例(% 肺活量が75%以下)では,% 肺活量と喘息の重症度との間にある程度の関連があることが明らかになった

気管支喘息に対する複合温泉療法の作用機序 1.温泉療法の評価方法との関連

Action mechanisms of complex spa therapy (swimming training in a hot spring pool, inhalation with iodine salt solution, and fango therapy) were studied in relation to patient age, clinical asthma type, and airway inflammation. Actions of spa therapy were observed by two clinical effects : direct and indirect effects. Improvement of subjective symptoms, ventilatory function, and bronchial hyperresponsiveness was observed as direct effects of spa therapy, and improvement of suppressed function of adrenocortical glands as indirect effects of the therapy. The clinical effects of spa therapy were higher in patients over the age of 40. Regarding clinical asthma type, the effects were larger in patients with type Ib and type II asthma than in those with type Ia. The efficacy of spa therapy was closely related with airway inflammation in patients with type Ib and type II asthma.複合温泉療法(温泉プール水泳訓練,ヨードゾル吸入,鉱泥湿布療法)の作用機序が,年齢,臨床病型,気道炎症反応との関連のもとに検討された｡温泉療法の作用機序は,2種類の臨床効果,すなわち,直接効果と間接効果により観察された｡自,他覚症状の改善,換気機能の改善,そして,気道過敏性の改善などが,温泉療法の直接効果として,また,副腎皮質機能の改善が間接効果とし て観察された｡温泉療法の臨床効果は,40才以上の症例においてより有効であり,また,臨床病型別では､Ia型に比べ,Ib型およびⅡ型においてより有効であった｡Ib型やⅡ型の気管支喘息では,温泉療法の作用機序と気道炎症反応との間に密接な関連が認められた

Ia型(単純気管支れん縮型)喘息における気道過敏性について…年齢および気管支肺胞洗浄液中の細胞成分との関連について

Bronchial hyperresponsiveness was examined in relation to age, ventilatory function, and the proportion of bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) cells in 39 patients with type Ia asthma (simple bronchoconstriction) (25 with type Ia-1 and 14 with type Ia-2), classified by clinical symptoms. 1. The proportion of BAL eosinophils was significantly higher in type Ia-2 than that in type Ia-1 asthma patients. 2. Bronchial reactivity to methacholine was not different between type Ia-1 and type Ia-2 asthma patients. 3. Bronchial hyperreactivity tended to decrease as patient age was higher in both types of asthma. Neither ventilatory function (FEV1.0%) nor the proportions of BAL lymphocytes and neutrophils was not correlated with bronchial hyperresponsiveness in both types of asthma. 4. Bronchial reactivity to methacholine more dereased with the increase in the proportion of BAL eosinophils in both type Ia-1 and Ia-2 asthma patients. The results show that bronchial hyperresponsiveness in patients with type Ia asthma is correlated to patients age and the proportion of BAL eosinophils.気管支喘息患者Ia型(単純気管支れん縮型)39人(Ia-1型25人,Ia-2型14人)の気道過敏性を年齢,呼吸機能検査,気管支肺胞洗浄液(BAL)中の細胞成分と関連で検討を行った｡1.BAL液中の好酸球の比率はIa-1型に比べIa-2型で優位に高値であった｡2.メサコリンに対しての過敏性はIa-1型とIa-2型とで差を認めなかった｡3.気道過敏性はどちらの病型においても年齢にともなって減弱する傾向にあったが,一秒率及びBAL液中の好中球,リンパ球の比率とは相関しなかった｡4.メサコリンに対しての気道過敏性はIa-1型,Ia-2型ともにBAL液中の好酸球の比率が増加するにしたがって亢進した｡以上より単純気管支れん縮型(Ia型)の気管支喘息患者の気道過敏性はその年齢,BAL液中の好酸球の比率に相関することが示唆された

気管支喘息に対する複合温泉療法の作用機序 3.気道炎症反応との関連

The degree and characteristic of airway inflammation were evaluated by the proportions of bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) cells. Clinical asthma types such as Ia. simple bronchoconstriction, Ib. bronchoconstriction + hypersecretion, and Ⅱ. bronchiolar obstruction correlate with airway inflammation. The increased proportion BAL　neutrophils is characteristic of type Ⅱ asthma, and increase in BAL eosinophil count is often observed in type Ib asthma. Bronchial hyperresponsiveness also correlates with airway inflammation. Action of spa therapy has been speculated to be related to airway inflammation, since the therapy has no action inhibiting IgE-mediated allergic reaction. In fact, spa therapy is more effective in patients with type Ib and type Ⅱ than in those with type Ia showing slight degree of airway inflammation. Bronchial hyperresponsiveness is also improved by spa therapy. From a point of view, the direct action of spa therapy may be to clean airways and improve damaged mucous membrane of the airways, leading to suppression of airway inflammation.気道炎症反応の程度や特徴が,気管支肺胞洗浄液(BAL)中の細胞成分によって評価された｡Ia.単純性気管支攣縮型,Ib.気管支攣縮+過分泌型,Ⅱ.細気管支閉塞型などの各臨床病型は気道炎症反応と関連している｡BAL液中好中球増多は,Ⅱ型喘息の特徴的所見であり,また好酸球増多はIb型喘息でしばしば観察される｡気道過敏性もまた気道炎症反応と関連している｡温泉療法の作用機序としては,温泉療法にIgEにmediateされるアレルギー反応(液性因子相)を抑制する作用がないことから,気道炎症反応(細胞性因子相)の抑制が推測されている｡実際,温泉療法は,気道炎症反応が軽度なIa型喘息に比べ,Ib型やⅡ型などの明らかに気道炎症反応をともなう病型に対してより有効である｡気道過敏性もまた温泉療法により改善される｡これらの 結果から,温泉療法は,気道を清浄化し,気道粘膜を正常化することによって,気道炎症反応を抑制していくものと考えられる