Molecular evolution of Adh and LEAFY and the phylogenetic utility of their introns in Pyrus (Rosaceae)

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>The genus <it>Pyrus </it>belongs to the tribe Pyreae (the former subfamily Maloideae) of the family Rosaceae, and includes one of the most important commercial fruit crops, pear. The phylogeny of <it>Pyrus </it>has not been definitively reconstructed. In our previous efforts, the internal transcribed spacer region (ITS) revealed a poorly resolved phylogeny due to non-concerted evolution of nrDNA arrays. Therefore, introns of low copy nuclear genes (LCNG) are explored here for improved resolution. However, paralogs and lineage sorting are still two challenges for applying LCNGs in phylogenetic studies, and at least two independent nuclear loci should be compared. In this work the second intron of <it>LEAFY </it>and the alcohol dehydrogenase gene (<it>Adh</it>) were selected to investigate their molecular evolution and phylogenetic utility.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>DNA sequence analyses revealed a complex ortholog and paralog structure of <it>Adh </it>genes in <it>Pyrus </it>and <it>Malus</it>, the pears and apples. Comparisons between sequences from RT-PCR and genomic PCR indicate that some <it>Adh </it>homologs are putatively nonfunctional. A partial region of <it>Adh1 </it>was sequenced for 18 <it>Pyrus </it>species and three subparalogs representing <it>Adh1-1 </it>were identified. These led to poorly resolved phylogenies due to low sequence divergence and the inclusion of putative recombinants. For the second intron of <it>LEAFY</it>, multiple inparalogs were discovered for both <it>LFY1int2 </it>and <it>LFY2int2</it>. <it>LFY1int2 </it>is inadequate for phylogenetic analysis due to lineage sorting of two inparalogs. <it>LFY2int2-N</it>, however, showed a relatively high sequence divergence and led to the best-resolved phylogeny. This study documents the coexistence of outparalogs and inparalogs, and lineage sorting of these paralogs and orthologous copies. It reveals putative recombinants that can lead to incorrect phylogenetic inferences, and presents an improved phylogenetic resolution of <it>Pyrus </it>using <it>LFY2int2-N</it>.</p> <p>Conclusions</p> <p>Our study represents the first phylogenetic analyses based on LCNGs in <it>Pyrus</it>. Ancient and recent duplications lead to a complex structure of <it>Adh </it>outparalogs and inparalogs in <it>Pyrus </it>and <it>Malus</it>, resulting in neofunctionalization, nonfunctionalization and possible subfunctionalization. Among all investigated orthologs, <it>LFY2int2-N </it>is the best nuclear marker for phylogenetic reconstruction of <it>Pyrus </it>due to suitable sequence divergence and the absence of lineage sorting.</p

Genetic Diversity and Domestication History in Pyrus

International audienc