Phonetic analysis of speech and memory codes in beginning readers

Two experimental tasks, a speech segmentation and a short-term memory task, were presented to children who began to learn to read following either the "phonic" or the "wholeword" method. The segmentation task required the child to reverse two segments (either two phones or two syllables) in an utterance. The phonic group performed significantly better than the whole-word group in the "phonic reversal" task, but no difference appeared in the "syllable reversal" task. This indicated (1) that most children by the age of 6 years are ready to discover that speech consists of a sequence of phones and (2) that the moment at which they do it is influenced by the way they are taught to read. In the memory task, the children recalled series of visually presented items whose names either rhymed or did not. The difference in performance for the rhyming and nonrhyming series was significant in both groups. It was no greater for the phonic than for the whole-word group and was uncorrelated with the "phonic reversal" task. These results are discussed in connection with the distinction between ways of lexical access and ways of representing verbal information in short-term memory. © 1982 Psychonomic Society, Inc.SCOPUS: ar.jinfo:eu-repo/semantics/publishe